Ain't Too Proud review – thrilling music but shallow drama in Temptations musical

Imperial Theatre, New York

Broadway’s latest jukebox music is electrified by fantastic singing and dancing but let down by some inert storytelling

There’s a chilly irony at the shrink-wrapped heart of Ain’t Too Proud: The Life and Times of the Temptations, the thrillingly performed and dramatically static jukebox musical on Broadway. This is a musical that’s about (if it’s about anything) the perils of fame. And a goose of fame is what it offers to the Temptations, the consummate R&B group that has been grooving in unison for almost six decades.

Like most jukebox musicals, this is a show made for the group’s fans. After the first number, The Way You Do the Things You Do, Otis Williams (Derrik Baskins), the last surviving member of the original Temptations, turns to the audience and says, “’member that”. About half of the Imperial Theatre, a great Broadway barn, had been singing along. So yes, that is ’membered. But it’s surface-skating book and skip-hop chronology probably means that the less you know about the Temptations, the more you’ll enjoy it.

The story begins in 1950s Detroit when Otis does a brief stint in juvie, set to Runaway Child, and then meets Melvin Franklin (Jawan M Jackson), a nice kid with a brimstone bass. He picks up Eddie Kendricks (Jeremy Pope), a spun-sugar tenor, and Paul Williams (James Harkness), a satiny baritone, and they form the Elgins, who become the Temptations after signing with Motown’s Berry Gordy. When the first lead singer leaves, they poach David Ruffin (Ephraim Sykes), a raspy, high-voltage tenor, and the hits, most of them written by Smokey Robinson, keep coming.

Ephraim Sykes in Ain’t Too Proud
Ephraim Sykes in Ain’t Too Proud. Photograph: Matthew Murphy

Because most of the Temptations early lyrics are generic – “The way you do the things you do” – the book hasn’t had to deform itself to set up the songs and the director, jukebox doyen Des McAnuff, can freight a number like Shout with a lot of storytelling. But while Dominique Morisseau (Skeleton Crew) is a tip-top playwright, firmly dedicated to the Motor City and finely attuned to social dynamics and interpersonal ones, the book is a cavalcade of banalities and bromides: “Things were about to change for the Temps in a big way.” “Sometimes you let go of one dream to get to something bigger.” “Thought my brothers would live forever. But I guess the only thing that really lives forever is the music.”

Because harmony is lovely to hear but tricky to show, the book mostly centers on brisk scenes of conflict. The theme: “Whenever your life is shaky, fame makes it worse.” But as the show is based on Otis Williams’s biography, even these scenes are softened and often undercut by Otis’s direct address. Morisseau doesn’t really give us an emotional hold on the characters (Too bad Smokey gave You Really Got a Hold on Me to the Miracles.) There’s a late-game attempt to wring father-son pathos and though it’s undergirded by real tragedy, it feels false. What would a musical centered around a more volatile member – Ruffin, say – have sounded like?

So why see Ain’t Too Proud? For the songs, of course, and the undiluted pleasure of watching five superb singers and dancers perform them. McAnuff, and the music director and arranger, Kenny Seymour, have given the actors enough space to make the songs their own. They’re still recognizable, but with intonations and accents that make them distinct. The choreography, by Sergio Trujillo, channeling “man with the moves” Cholly Atkins, is a little more athletic than what the Temps actually performed and Sykes an Alvin Ailey-trained dancer is electric as is his every vigorous pas de deux with the microphone stand. No one should be too proud to applaud that.


Alexis Soloski

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Shucked review – corny musical brings country to Broadway
An original new musical about corn offers plenty of dad jokes served with some likable big numbers

Adrian Horton

05, Apr, 2023 @1:00 AM

Article image
SpongeBob Squarepants: The Broadway Musical review – sugar-shock visual pleasure
An eclectic selection of original songs, written by everyone from John Legend to Aerosmith, meshes awkwardly with vibrant production design in this entertaining yet forgettable musical

Alexis Soloski

05, Dec, 2017 @3:00 AM

Article image
Once Upon a One More Time review – frothy Britney Spears musical
There’s some fun to be had in a splashy attempt to squeeze the pop star’s music into a meta-fairytale crowd-pleaser even with potholes along the way

Adrian Horton

29, Jun, 2023 @6:36 PM

Article image
Jagged Little Pill review – Alanis musical hits Broadway with a bang
Oscar-winning screenwriter Diablo Cody has brought Alanis Morissette’s music to the stage with a contrived yet hugely entertaining show

Alexis Soloski

06, Dec, 2019 @2:00 AM

Article image
Girl from the North Country review: Conor McPherson's grim, ravishing Bob Dylan musical
The acclaimed playwright has used the songbook of Bob Dylan to create an overstuffed yet often transcendent 30s-set Broadway show

Alexis Soloski

06, Mar, 2020 @2:30 AM

Article image
The Cher Show review – Broadway musical is a mixed bag of pop excess
A jukebox ode to the megastar contains some dazzling numbers but suffers from some clumsy storytelling

Alexis Soloski

04, Dec, 2018 @2:00 AM

Article image
Michael Jackson musical to hit Broadway in 2020
A stage show about the King of Pop’s life featuring the biggest hits from his catalogue is now in development

Jake Nevins

19, Jun, 2018 @3:35 PM

Article image
Ain’t Too Proud review – a Temptations jukebox musical by numbers
This plodding account of the Motown band’s highs and lows is more than a little soulless

Arifa Akbar

20, Apr, 2023 @11:01 PM

Article image
‘The perfect gateway’: are Broadway audiences ready for a K-pop musical?
The first Broadway show celebrating Korean culture hopes to show there’s ‘more to K-pop than just Gangnam Style’

Adrian Horton in New York

29, Nov, 2022 @2:56 PM

Article image
A Strange Loop review – Michael R Jackson’s thrilling Broadway triumph
The audacious and uproarious musical, which leads this year’s Tony nominations, is a meta masterpiece about a Black queer writer writing about a Black queer writer

Gloria Oladipo

17, May, 2022 @6:03 PM