The Deep Blue Sea review – Rattigan's furious tide of doomed passion

Minerva, Chichester
Nancy Carroll is magnificent as a woman shamed by a failed affair with a younger man, in a play that seethes with postwar English anger

Two critics, a Young Turk and an Old Hack, emerge from a performance of Terence Rattigan’s 1952 play. On the journey home, they fall into eager debate.

Young Turk: What an amazing play! I never knew old man Rattigan had so much blood in him. But you’re probably fed up with seeing this piece by now?

Old Hack: Not at all. I think it’s Rattigan’s profoundest exploration of one of his favourite themes: the inequality of passion. After all, it shows a woman, Hester Collyer, driven to suicidal desperation by the inability of her lover, Freddie Page, to fulfil her emotional and sexual needs. It says a lot about postwar England while offering a timeless study of the human heart.

YT: That’s what I loved about Paul Foster’s production. I’d expected something a bit tight-lipped and restrained, like Brief Encounter. But Hester and Freddie really go at it hammer and tongs. Freddie, who has had a good war but can’t adjust to the postwar world, reminded me of the heroine of David Hare’s Plenty, and Hester even prefigures John Osborne’s Jimmy Porter in her need for a partner who can match her fire.

OH: All true. But this is also a play about a very English kind of male inhibition – which is perfectly exemplified by Hester’s high court judge husband, Sir William, who pleads with her to return. His tragedy is that he is a victim of his class in the way he equates love with social convention, but Gerald Kyd is encouraged to play him with such table-thumping ferocity that you’re almost surprised Hester doesn’t go back to him.

Gerald Kyd plays Hester’s husband Sir William.
Class tragedy … Gerald Kyd plays Hester’s husband Sir William. Photograph: Manuel Harlan

YT: You’re dead wrong. The production’s whole point is that all these characters have a hidden fury. That’s true of Hadley Fraser’s Freddie, who is not just some cheery ex-RAF chappie but a man whose sense of failure drives him to drink and who is the play’s real victim, in that he goes off to almost certain death.

OH: Fair enough. But did the actors have to shout so much? Perhaps we can agree about Nancy Carroll’s Hester. At times, she looked at Freddie with the tender gaze of the hopelessly smitten: at other times, as when she swept a bottle of whisky off the table, she seemed to pulsate with rage. I liked her best, however, when she was at her quietest, as in the scenes with the struck-off doctor – beautifully played by Matthew Cottle – where she perfectly caught Hester’s sense of shame and despair.

YT: I thought she was magnificent all through. She conveyed Hester’s hysteria but there were also subtle touches such as the way she carefully packed in Freddie’s luggage the two things that mattered most to him: a mounted cricket ball and a copy of Wisden!

OH: That was good. But I still feel in Rattigan there is a tension between the power of the emotion and the means of expression, which I only truly felt in the desolate final moments.

YT: That’s a cliched vision of how Rattigan should be played. I loved this production because it was about two incompatible souls trapped in an impossible situation. I’d unhesitatingly give it five stars.

OH: I’d give it three.

YT: Shall we agree to split the difference?

At the Minerva, Chichester, until 27 July.

Contributor

Michael Billington

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Ross review – Joseph Fiennes captures TE Lawrence's troubled spirit
Fiennes gives an accomplished performance in an elegantly mounted production of Terence Rattigan’s uneven play

Michael Billington

10, Jun, 2016 @11:13 AM

Article image
The Chalk Garden review – Penelope Keith sparks a twee rebellion
Despite its pitch-perfect lead, this version of Enid Bagnold’s class comedy lacks the emotionally charged edginess that gives it bite

Arifa Akbar

03, Jun, 2018 @2:06 PM

Article image
Shadowlands review – Bonneville dazzles as CS Lewis in divine revival
Questions of faith and loss drive a masterly story of the Narnia author in Rachel Kavanaugh’s deeply poignant production

Mark Lawson

03, May, 2019 @11:58 AM

Article image
While the Sun Shines review – fresh-as-paint Rattigan revival
Superb performances power the ingeniously plotted story of a young earl’s marriage to the daughter of an impoverished duke

Michael Billington

17, Jun, 2019 @6:00 AM

Article image
The Meeting review – quiet Quaker rebellion provokes crisis of faith
Charlotte Jones’s drama pitches a non-violent religious community on to the Napoleonic wars’ spiritual frontline

Michael Billington

20, Jul, 2018 @12:47 PM

Article image
Macbeth review – John Simm excels despite much toil and trouble
The murderous thane faces witches, relentless video and a musical assault in this lengthy production but emerges as a figure of rare complexity

Michael Billington

29, Sep, 2019 @10:41 AM

Article image
The Deep Blue Sea review – Helen McCrory blazes in passionate revival
Terence Rattigan’s powerful portrait of emotional turmoil in postwar Britain is beautifully played – if only the sound effects weren’t so disruptive

Michael Billington

09, Jun, 2016 @10:53 AM

Article image
Love in Idleness review – Trevor Nunn reveals Rattigan's political divide
Eve Best and Helen George star in a production that merges the playwright’s Love in Idleness with its former iteration, Less Than Kind

Michael Billington

21, Mar, 2017 @7:00 AM

Article image
Angels and demons: the unmissable theatre, comedy and dance of autumn 2017
Hamilton hits London, Bryan Cranston’s news anchor goes berserk, Wayne McGregor turns his DNA into dance, Mae Martin revisits her teen addictions and Toyah Willcox is a time-travelling queen

Michael Billington, Lyn Gardner, Judith Mackrell and Brian Logan

12, Sep, 2017 @5:00 AM

Article image
Hamlet, Cabaret and a fistful of Romeos: the best theatre, comedy and dance of autumn 2021
Cush Jumbo tackles the troubled prince, Jessie Buckley and Eddie Redmayne head for 30s Berlin, while standup favourites and dance spectaculars burst back on the stage

Arifa Akbar, Brian Logan and Lyndsey Winship

26, Aug, 2021 @7:00 AM