When We Have Sufficiently Tortured Each Other review – it's explicit but hardly shocking

Dorfman, London
Cate Blanchett and Stephen Dillane add some heft to an uninspired exploration of modern sexual mores

Advance reports of people fainting in the stalls suggested we might be in for something shockingly sensational. The blunt truth, however, is that Martin Crimp’s play – subtitled “12 Variations on Samuel Richardson’s Pamela” – proves to be a diagrammatic exploration of modern sexual mores shorn of any social context.

It is left to the admirably uninhibited central performers, Cate Blanchett and Stephen Dillane, to literally put some flesh on a drily cerebral text. Richardson’s 1740 novel shows a 15-year-old serving girl resisting a predatory master before finally marrying him.

Under Katie Mitchell’s agile production and Vicki Mortimer’s design, the action is shifted to a modern garage, where Blanchett and Dillane – simply characterised as Woman and Man – enact a series of sadomasochistic power games.

The Man, asserting his economic authority, emerges as a patriarchal bully; the Woman, seeking freedom through recording her ideas on a laptop, strikes a note of mocking defiance. But the pair constantly swap roles so that she dons his clothes and air of toxic repressiveness while he submits to her while sporting a blonde wig, black underwear and a maid’s costume.

We live, Crimp implies, in a world where gender is fluid, sex becomes a form of domination, and the balance of power between men and women is rapidly shifting. There is nothing surprising about the argument. But first-rate drama depends on a collision of equal forces, and that is where Crimp’s play breaks down. The Man, seeking to imprison his victim like Richardson’s Lord B or offering material wealth in exchange for freedom, simply emerges as a neurotic weakling easily outwitted by the woman’s resilience.

When the roles are reversed, the Woman assumes a brisk masculinity while he, in female garb, seems curiously defenceless. However valid the point, it makes for an uneven contest.

Fortunately, the two actors are highly watchable. Blanchett has an extraordinary capacity to shift vocal and physical registers. As a woman she seems wily, guileful and undefeated: when she strokes the man’s thigh with an elegantly stockinged foot she invests the gesture with irony and even makes her fetishistic assumption of a wedding dress feel like an act of protest. But when she becomes the male tormentor, she makes expressive use of deep chest-notes without ever lapsing into vicious caricature. As we know from her previous work in film and theatre, she is a consummate actor.

Dillane has the tougher task in that the Man, even when supposedly bossing the show, is always on the back foot. However, Dillane, with his bony features and disordered mass of greying hair, has the ability to make the male illusion of power interesting, and there is good support from Jessica Gunning as his housekeeper, who seizes on a hint in Richardson’s novel to suggest a lesbian fascination with her master’s prisoner.

Mitchell’s production is sexually explicit, but I can only assume that anyone shocked by the play’s arguments about the overthrow of oppressive masculinity and the malleability of gender must have spent the last decade in monastic seclusion.

• At the Dorfman, London, until 2 March.

Contributor

Michael Billington

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The week in theatre: When We Have Sufficiently Tortured Each Other and more – review
Cate Blanchett and Stephen Dillane can’t save a clunky S&M study of sexual politics

Susannah Clapp

27, Jan, 2019 @8:00 AM

Article image
Cate Blanchett to debut at National Theatre in new Martin Crimp play
Actor is cast opposite Stephen Dillane in production to be directed by Katie Mitchell

Mark Brown Arts correspondent

13, Jun, 2018 @11:59 AM

Article image
Pamela's power: the novel behind Cate Blanchett's controversial new play
Samuel Richardson’s tale of sexual harassment was a sensation in the 18th century. But can Martin Crimp’s modern reworking make sense in the era of #MeToo?

John Mullan

25, Jan, 2019 @3:00 PM

Article image
Cate Blanchett on her S&M-themed play: 'I see theatre as a provocation'
Cate Blanchett has played queens, vagabonds and Bob Dylan. Now the double Oscar-winner is hitting the London stage and hinting at a farewell from acting. We talk to the team behind the avant garde play about sexual domination

Andrew Dickson

09, Jan, 2019 @5:00 PM

Article image
Big and Small – review

Cate Blanchett shines as a chattering optimist who is too good for the world she inhabits, writes Michael Billington

Michael Billington

15, Apr, 2012 @1:16 PM

Article image
Small Island review – Levy’s Windrush epic makes momentous theatre
Andrea Levy’s story of first-generation Jamaican immigrants in postwar Britain has been skilfully adapted and staged with hurtling energy

Michael Billington

02, May, 2019 @11:11 AM

Article image
Zauberland review – after horrors, a feeling of 'so what' remains
Crimp, Foccroulle, Mitchell and Schumann combine their considerable forces to tell a shocking story, inspired by the Syrian conflict, that fails to have the impact it should

Andrew Clements

16, Oct, 2019 @4:00 PM

Article image
I'm Not Running review – David Hare's Labour play hits political bullseyes
Hare’s state-of-the-nation drama pricks the mind and is supported by strong performances but it lacks momentum

Michael Billington

10, Oct, 2018 @10:11 AM

Article image
Chekhov's revolutions: the Russian master still speaks to a world in flux
On the centenary of the Russian revolution, a glut of revivals show Chekhov’s characters struggling to adjust to the social earthquakes that engulf them

Lyn Gardner

14, Nov, 2017 @7:30 AM

Article image
Five people faint due to violence in National Theatre's Cleansed
Graphic scenes in stage revival of Sarah Kane’s play prove too much for viewers, with 40 leaving early in first six shows

Hannah Ellis-Petersen

24, Feb, 2016 @12:06 PM