Until the Flood review – fleshed-out fictions from a real-life killing

Traverse theatre, Edinburgh
Dael Orlandersmith transforms into her characters, dispassionately inhabiting their reactions to the shooting of black teen Michael Brown by a white policeman

Dael Orlandersmith’s play both is and isn’t about the 2014 shooting of black teenager Michael Brown by white police officer Darren Wilson. This event is the catalyst for Until the Flood, which digs into the aftermath of the shooting and unearths ugly truths about race in the United States.

Over the last few decades, American theatre has developed a tradition of processing trauma through documentary. Until the Flood follows in the footsteps of The Laramie Project and Anna Deveare Smith’s verbatim shows, bearing more than a passing resemblance to the latter. The play is based on interviews with people in St Louis, but – unlike Smith – Orlandersmith has turned these real people into fictionalised composites.

In front of a candle-filled, flickering memorial to Brown, each speaker is fully inhabited and dispassionately held up for inspection. With a single item of clothing and a subtle shifting of her limbs, Orlandersmith transforms into her characters one by one. There’s the young black man who jitters with fear, praying that he escapes Brown’s fate; the racist who leans into the audience as he spits out the N-word; the white woman who fiddles nervously with her wine glass as she tries to see both sides.

Race comes in and out of focus. Orlandersmith allows her characters to be more than their politics or prejudices, a choice that can make the racism even more horrifying when it rears its head. We get a glimpse of these people’s lives, their struggles and dreams, making it harder to dismiss them when they utter something abhorrent. No matter how educated the white speakers, what’s striking is their failure to grasp structural racism, the inability to appreciate their own privilege.

The politics of the play itself is understated. There’s an implicit statement in the delivery of these monologues by Orlandersmith as a woman of colour, but she doesn’t let even a flicker of her own judgment about the characters inflect her performance. Only at the very end does she step into her own skin and deliver a spare, ambiguous poem, hinting at both hope and despair for the future of her country.

Until the Flood is at the Traverse theatre, Edinburgh, until 25 August, and at Arcola theatre, London, 4-28 September.
Read all our Edinburgh festival reviews.

Contributor

Catherine Love

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Parakeet review – punk eco-musical promotes DIY activism
Brigitte Aphrodite and Quiet Boy’s colourful show follows a trio of teens in Margate who form a punk band and campaign to save a tree

Chris Wiegand

08, Aug, 2019 @9:11 AM

Article image
Arthur review – man and baby in unique double act
Daniel Bye enlists the help of his five-month-old son in an unpredictable hour-long exploration of nature versus nurture

Mark Fisher

08, Aug, 2019 @5:00 AM

Article image
Roots review – whimsical 'folk jokes' and a very greedy cat
The 1927 company became darlings of the festival scene after their first fringe outing, but this showcase of traditional tales lacks urgency

Mark Fisher

11, Aug, 2019 @2:24 PM

Article image
The Incident Room review – Yorkshire Ripper retelling puts police in the spotlight
New Diorama’s beautifully crafted play casts doubt on titillating tales of the notorious serial killer, but can’t escape the clutches of morbid fascination

Catherine Love

05, Aug, 2019 @3:00 PM

Article image
Red Dust Road review – Jackie Kay adaptation loses its way
Sasha Frost sparkles as a curious and vulnerable Kay searching for her birth parents, but this unfocused production fails to capture the intimacy of the soul-searching memoir

Mark Fisher

15, Aug, 2019 @10:07 AM

Article image
Courtney Pauroso: Gutterplum review – the latest sexy clown from Dr Brown
More anarchic comedy, sexual frankness and in-yer-face clowning from the director behind Natalie Palamides

Brian Logan

07, Aug, 2019 @7:00 PM

Article image
Kai Samra review – shrewd standup puts his industry through the wringer
Society’s ‘follow your dreams’ mantra is pulled apart in a poignant show that tackles race, class and brotherly love

Brian Logan

12, Aug, 2019 @5:00 AM

Article image
Jordan Brookes review – refuses to play by the normal rules of comedy
Brookes delivers one of the coups of this year’s fringe with this deconstruction of a standup set, in which you never know what he’ll do next

Brian Logan

17, Aug, 2019 @7:00 PM

Article image
Jessica Fostekew review – punchy polemic about gender stereotyping
The standup rails against old-fashioned ideals of femininity, the diet industry and society’s policing of women’s bodies. It’s strong stuff.

Brian Logan

17, Aug, 2019 @11:43 AM

Article image
Jackie Kay on putting her adoption on stage – and getting a pay rise for her successor
When Scotland’s national poet travelled to Nigeria to ask her birth father if he ever thought of her, he said no. Does it hurt to put this on stage? And should the next ‘makar’ be on £30,000?

Peter Ross

07, Aug, 2019 @3:50 PM