Amélie the Musical review – a rocking realisation of the film

Watermill theatre, Newbury
Clever staging and warm performances make this adaptation of Jean-Pierre Jeunet’s film a visual treat

Last week’s fire at Notre Dame prompted various reflections on French identity. Although a more ephemeral entity, the 2001 film Amélie raised questions about the same theme: was its faux-nostalgic, CGI-ed presentation of 1990s Paris an airbrushing of the city’s modern, multicultural identity, or a valid expression of an aspect of “Frenchness”? This new musical adaptation shares this same dichotomy.

The story of the lonely girl who intervenes in the lives of others so as to spread happiness where there was sorrow has a fairytale quality that does not need a specific site. Yet the musical’s book, by Craig Lucas, follows the film in making references to the death of Princess Diana, thereby locating the action firmly in a real time and place (rather than a fictional Paris equivalent). The advantage of this is that it provides a pretext for a rocking, Elton John take-off pre-interval number (one of Daniel Messé’s many lively and subtle pastiche compositions). Mostly, though, the counterpoint between the sweet confection of the story and the realities of Paris in the 1990s jars – and not in a Brechtian way. It’s like piling crème Chantilly on to steak tartare.

This is a great shame because, in other respects, the production is much better than the film – less cloying, more fun. A brilliant ensemble of actor-musicians simultaneously present and enact the story. Under Michael Fentiman’s direction, set against Madeleine Girling’s design, wonderful ingenuities of movement and props zoom scenes and perspectives (the term “piano roll”, here, takes on a literal reality). As Amélie, Audrey Brisson offers a rare performance combining emotional nuance and heightened physicality. Overall, though, for me, the whimsicalisation of Paris strikes a fatal false note – stars, therefore, for the production rather than the material.

At the Watermill theatre, Newbury, until 18 May

Watch a trailer for Amélie.


Clare Brennan

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Amélie the Musical review – sepia-toned surrealism that's high on imagination
The arrival of the kind-hearted and introverted Parisian on the UK stage is a magical and emotional triumph of adaptation

Arifa Akbar

19, Apr, 2019 @7:55 AM

Article image
Whistle Down the Wind review – outstanding production of the Lloyd Webber musical
Tom Jackson Greaves thrillingly fuses movement with music in his revival of Andrew Lloyd Webber’s Louisiana-set take on the classic 60s film

Clare Brennan

31, Jul, 2022 @10:30 AM

Article image
Amélie the Musical review – kindness, kooks and kissing cellos in the city of love
It irons out the eccentricities in Jean-Pierre Jeunet’s film but this show has a timely message and delights in small pleasures

Chris Wiegand

02, Jun, 2021 @9:00 PM

Article image
Big Fish review – lifeless male bonding musical
Kelsey Grammer plays a father recovering from a stroke in this soppy, short-lived Broadway show

Susannah Clapp

12, Nov, 2017 @7:50 AM

Article image
Local Hero review – musical with a moral heart
Bill Forsyth’s adaptation of his 1983 film, with new music by Mark Knopfler, is topical all over again

Clare Brennan

31, Mar, 2019 @7:00 AM

Article image
Under Milk Wood review – sure-footed shapeshifting
Six actors play 37 roles in a beautifully balanced production of Dylan Thomas’s classic play for voices

Clare Brennan

05, Nov, 2017 @7:30 AM

Article image
Everybody’s Talking About Jamie review – joyous teen drag musical
The drama lacks oomph but sheer exuberance carries this coming-of-age tale by Tom MacRae and Dan Gillespie Sells

Clare Brennan

19, Feb, 2017 @8:00 AM

Article image
Yes! Yes! UCS! review – vibrant musical of worker power
Clyde dockworkers take a stand in 1970s Scotland, in an affecting new play by Townsend Productions

Clare Brennan

27, Feb, 2022 @11:30 AM

Article image
Come from Away review – surprisingly uplifting 9/11 musical
Making a song and dance of how Newfoundland took in thousands of diverted passengers after the World Trade Center attack is fun up to a point

Claire Armitstead

07, Apr, 2019 @7:00 AM

Article image
As You Like It review – the setting is the star
A green adaptation of Shakespeare’s romcom focuses on the climate crisis, but takes its time to get the blood stirring

Clare Brennan

04, Jul, 2021 @10:00 AM