Girls and Boys review – gut-wrenching Carey Mulligan charts a marriage's end

Royal Court, London
Mulligan is a joy to watch as she brings her expressive powers to bear in Dennis Kelly’s flawed but compelling one-hander

Carey Mulligan has had quite a week. First she shone as the warily intelligent cop in David Hare’s compelling TV drama, Collateral. Now she occupies the stage alone for 90 minutes in Dennis Kelly’s new play and charts with consummate skill the disintegration of a relationship. She is a joy to watch; only later did I find myself asking serious questions of the play itself.

Mulligan plays an unnamed woman (can characters please have monikers?) who begins by describing her first sight of her future husband in an easyJet queue at Naples airport. An amused smile plays about Mulligan’s lips, and her eyes sparkle as the woman recalls her hitherto rackety life and the delight with which she saw her spouse-to-be put a couple of queue-jumping models in their place. We are instantly intrigued, as we are by the next scene, which shows the woman as a harassed young mum coping with two unseen children who have the luck to be named as Leanne and Danny.

This alternation of confessional chat and pressurised domesticity continues throughout the piece. Mulligan is brilliant at engaging with the audience and charting the gradations of the relationship with the husband. He runs a thriving business importing antique wardrobes; she cons her way into a job as a development executive in TV documentaries. The sex, we’re told, is terrific, and the couple have two lively, imaginative kids. But halfway through we get intimations of disaster, and a play that starts as comedy ends as tragedy.

Girls and Boys
Intimations of disaster … Girls and Boys. Photograph: Marc Brenner

Mulligan, whose expressive features gradually acquire the stark lineaments of pain, couldn’t be this good if the writing weren’t strong. Kelly, lately associated with family shows such as Matilda and Pinocchio, returns to a theme that haunted much of his earlier work: the nature of violence. Here he is particularly concerned with whether it is built into the male gender’s DNA. It is striking that, in the children’s fantasy games, Danny is destructive and Leanne constructive. Mulligan’s character finds herself working on a putative TV doc that seeks to statistically record testosterised aggression and devise a system that would make it harder for men to gain power. It is quite a leap, however, from this to the play’s shattering conclusion.

The form also pre-empts doubt or debate. Describing the unravelling marriage, Mulligan says at one point: “I am, of course, just giving you one side … But that’s what happens when you have just one person talking.” This may be Kelly’s attempt to disarm criticism, but it also reminds us of the limited perspective of the solo piece.

The night before I happened to have seen a play, Peter Gill’s The York Realist, in which you sympathised equally with two lovers sundered by class and circumstance. Drama can do that, whereas, in the one-person play, you are forced to rely on the testimony of the speaker. Here you have only the woman’s word for it that the catastrophe is motivated by professional jealousy. This doesn’t gainsay the immense subtlety of Mulligan’s performance or the clarity of Lyndsey Turner’s direction and Es Devlin’s design, which moves rapidly from a box-like space to a blanched sitting-room that seems to exist in the speaker’s memory.

It’s a gut-wrenching piece, but if you are going to invoke Euripides, as Kelly does, I’d suggest you need to present both sides of the story.


Michael Billington

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Dennis Kelly on Girls and Boys: 'I was shocked Carey Mulligan did it'
The Matilda playwright has written a shattering solo drama that he didn’t think his star would read. He talks about fear, masculinity and burying secrets

Lyn Gardner

22, Feb, 2018 @2:37 PM

Article image
The week in theatre: Girls & Boys; The York Realist – review
Alone on stage for an hour and a half, Carey Mulligan is extraordinary in Dennis Kelly’s gripping new play

Susannah Clapp

18, Feb, 2018 @8:00 AM

Article image
All-star Pinter, a Suranne Jones thriller and Carey Mulligan goes solo: 2018's essential theatre
Brace yourself for The Birthday Party, an EasyJet love story, Sting’s shipyard musical and Ben Whishaw as Brutus

Michael Billington

01, Jan, 2018 @10:05 AM

Article image
'They said I wasn't hot enough': Carey Mulligan hits out again at magazine review
Variety review of black comedy Promising Young Woman prompts actor to speak out on industry’s institutionalised sexism

Catherine Shoard

28, Jan, 2021 @10:52 AM

Article image
Skylight review – Nighy and Mulligan in moving mixture of politics and love | Michael Billington

Michael Billington: The combination of private pain and public rage in this revival of David Hare's play hits you straight between the eyes

Michael Billington

18, Jun, 2014 @10:00 PM

Article image
The Ritual Slaughter of Gorge Mastromas

A City suit sells his soul in this enjoyable if slightly unsubtle morality tale by Matilda the Musical's Dennis Kelly, writes Michael Billington

Michael Billington

12, Sep, 2013 @10:57 AM

Article image
Skylight review – Bill Nighy and Carey Mulligan have a melancholy pull
David Hare’s play is about the state of the nation and matters of the heart, as two fornmer lovers with differing political views are reunited years after their affair

Alexis Soloski

03, Apr, 2015 @12:23 PM

Article image
The Ritual Slaughter of Gorge Mastromas; Hysteria; A Boy and His Soul – review
There's a surprising start for Vicky Featherstone's first season at the Royal Court, writes Susannah Clapp

Susannah Clapp

14, Sep, 2013 @11:06 PM

Article image
Collateral review – Carey Mulligan shines in a damaging political drama
David Hare’s state-of-the-nation drama might start out like Law & Order: Southwark Victims Unit but it turns into a lucid meditation on contemporary Britain

Lucy Mangan

12, Feb, 2018 @10:00 PM

Article image
Black Men Walking review – rap, race and rambling hit peak resonance
Mixing poetry and politics, Yorkshire-based rapper Testament has created a witty, innovative piece that says a lot about British identity and racial history

Michael Billington

23, Mar, 2018 @10:54 AM