Brexit gags, catsuits and coke-snorting cops: A Beggar's Opera for our times

John Gay’s 18th century satire is a work whose essential remit is to confront the uncomfortable. How is Robert Carsen’s take dealing with the homeless crisis, Brexit and the #metoo movement?

Lads in tracksuits hurl themselves across the stage, all hoods and fists and aggro. There’s no music, but screeching sirens and dense thuds of bodies hitting the floor and each other. Then the overture kicks in with a brute shock of sweet-voiced lutes and harpsichords. The contrast works like a punch in the gut, and the audience lets out a collective gasp.

Musical and moral collisions abound in any production of The Beggar’s Opera. John Gay’s 18th-century satire is a gleeful period piece of irredeemably patchy values: heartthrob villain who makes gang crime look sexy and misogyny cute; clingy damsels who paint a flagrantly unreconstructed portrait of the female psyche – meek or manipulative, or both. But The Beggar’s Opera is also a riot and a farce, wickedly funny when done right. Packed with tender airs and lusty singalongs, it is the original musical. What’s a director to do? Ditch it? Dodge it? Rewrite it?

A new account directed by Robert Carsen with period-instrument accompaniment from Les Arts Florissants opts for the rewrite tactic without losing sight of the original. The text is updated (sharp new words by Ian Burton) as a 21st-century East End crime comedy. The cast, all of them singer-actors from the musical theatre world, can deliver proper bawdy when required. With dirty language and Brexit satire set to elegant baroque tunes, the production – which comes to the Edinburgh international festival this week – has been billed a beggar’s opera “for our own turbulent times”.

That billing has turned out to be more accurate than the festival’s marketing team could have imagined. The production was created for the Théâtre des Bouffes du Nord in Paris, a house made famous in the 1980s when director Peter Brook turned it into a hotbed of pared-back, provocative theatre. The building is a fading beauty on the tracks of the Gare du Nord, not far from the Canal Saint-Denis in the north-east of the city, where, in the past year, thousands of migrants and refugees have been living in makeshift tent villages under bridges along the canal. Aid workers have described “catastrophic sanitary conditions” and reported thieves, abusers and people traffickers targeting the camps. Bouffes du Nord is a stone’s throw away and, with the first image in Carsen’s production a homeless man huddled in a sleeping bag against a cardboard box, the appropriation of poverty as theatrical gesture is glaring.

Robert Burt and Beverley Klein as Mr and Mrs Peachum in The Beggar's Opera, at the Edinburgh international festival 2018.
Gender politics … Robert Burt and Beverley Klein as Mr and Mrs Peachum. Photograph: Murdo MacLeod/Guardian

“It is a problem,” Carsen acknowledges. “But problems are not to be ignored. The Beggar’s Opera was written as a rebellion against grandiosity. Everything about it questioned perceived morals of the time. Gay wanted to expose the hypocrisy of the elite and politicians, to provoke debate by romanticising the shifting morality of criminals. This piece reflects all levels of society. Yes, I was aware that constructing the image of a homeless person on stage would have added resonance, given the situation in Paris right now, but it’s an opera about the real world. I think it’s right that we don’t flinch from what we see on the streets.”

Indeed, The Beggar’s Opera stirred things up from the start. It opened on Drury Lane in 1728 and was an instant hit, performed in Dublin, Glasgow, New York and Jamaica – and every year in London for the remainder of the 18th century. Audiences loved the tunes. They left the theatre humming the medley of pop songs that had been loosely arranged for the opera by Johann Pepusch. But that wasn’t all. There is no other opera remembered by the name of its librettist rather than its composer. The great appeal of The Beggar’s Opera was that its commentary felt real, that Gay had dared to tell the jokes that others didn’t, and that nobody was spared. Opera was supposed to be about gods and noblemen; Gay made thieves and prostitutes his leading lords and ladies. His libretto held a mirror to high society by turning class values topsy-turvy, and made clear allusions to real-life corruption cases that implicated everyone up to the then prime minister, Robert Walpole, himself – who went to see the opera, hated it and banned its sequel.

Olivia Brereton as Lucy Lockit, Benjamin Purkiss as Macheath and Kate Batter as Polly Peachum in The Beggar’s Opera, at Kings Theatre, Edinburgh international festival 2018.
Pretty fools … Olivia Brereton as Lucy Lockit, Benjamin Purkiss as Macheath and Kate Batter as Polly Peachum. Photograph: Murdo MacLeod/Guardian

This is an opera whose essential remit is to confront the uncomfortable. And for all its clever updating, Carsen’s production remains fairly faithful to the original concept: contemporary vernacular, contemporary satire. The action is transplanted to London’s 21st-century underbelly, where the chief of police snorts cocaine and Jenny Diver is an icy dominatrix in a latex catsuit. The Brexit jokes come thick and fast, and digs at the phrase “strong and stable” got a wry laugh from the Paris audience.

What doesn’t update quite so neatly is the gender politics. Women in The Beggar’s Opera are brassy matriarchs (Mrs Peachum), devious vixens (Diver) or pretty fools (Lucy Lockit and Polly Peachum). Carsen admitted to heated debate in the rehearsal room over what to do with these caricatures, but, ultimately, the values of the piece are ingrained. ”In the age of #MeToo,” Carsen says, “not everything has to be bent to fit.”

Beverley Klein, who plays Mrs Peachum, agrees she found the dynamics problematic. “We noticed ourselves trying to contrive ways of changing it,” she says, “but in the end these are the characters and this is the story. No matter how far you meddle with the text and try to inject the women with agency, you just have to accept their fates if you’re going to do this opera. I’m playing a traitorous elderly prostitute. I never thought I’d be hauling myself around in a plastic miniskirt at my age.”

Matters of period authenticity are more malleable when it comes to the music of The Beggar’s Opera, not least because there are no original orchestral parts, only indications of where the big tunes should go. Any new production needs to make a call on how to reconstruct it. Bertolt Brecht and Kurt Weill rewrote the music in the 1920s and rebranded it The Threepenny Opera. Benjamin Britten made a neat performing version in the 1940s. There have been settings in Rio slums and productions by all-female Japanese troupes.

The music for Carsen’s production was prepared by William Christie, a pioneer of historically informed performance practice, who enthuses about his decision to work with musical theatre voices rather than baroque specialists. “Nobody knows what the sound was like for the original productions,” he says, “so authenticity becomes a grey area. We are certainly talking about singers who could act. Back then there was no distinction. We’re talking about simple songs – call it folk songs, or pop music of the period. It was a kind of music that didn’t require trained voices. It was opera for the public, opera to debunk operatic style. So why would we use operatic voices to sing it now? We’re on the right side of authenticity, certainly compared to singers who sing the hell out of it as though it were Mozart.”

And the band? Christie describes a “1930s Duke Ellington setup. We have fashioned an improvising orchestra of individuals who can riff and swing. Only the odd solo is written out. It’s the first time it has ever been done like this and it required the absolute best players who can take on that kind of agency.” For all the scabrous Brexit jabs and plastic miniskirts, it’s this musical collision – live-wire baroque improv meets musical theatre – that might just prove the most daring aspect of the production.

At King’s theatre, Edinburgh, 16-19 August.

Read all our Edinburgh festival reviews.


Kate Molleson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
The Beggar's Opera review – the original jukebox musical reimagined
An updated version of John Gay’s classic features gags about the royal wedding and Brexit, but the music has missed a trick

Rowena Smith

17, Aug, 2018 @4:00 PM

Article image
The Barber of Seville review – engaging Rossini reboot of sight gags and
A young ensemble cast fizzes in Laurent Pelly’s playful production, with Catherine Trottmann’s agile Rosina most memorable

Rowena Smith

06, Aug, 2018 @3:35 PM

Article image
Youth takes centre stage at Edinburgh international festival
Celebration of young people and end of first world war are key themes of this year’s event

Severin Carrell Scotland editor

14, Mar, 2018 @6:30 PM

Article image
La Cenerentola review – Cinderella has a ball with exuberant panto kitsch
Stefan Herheim’s Lyon Opera production is hyperactively camp – even the conductor has a cameo – but the singing is warm and rich

Rowena Smith

26, Aug, 2018 @9:57 AM

Article image
Così fan Tutte review – Mozart's frothy opera turns nasty
Transplanted to 1930s Eritrea, Christopher Honoré’s version skims off the froth and stirs in the darker themes of power play, violence and abuse

Kate Molleson

26, Aug, 2016 @11:10 AM

Article image
Edinburgh festival offers refunds for controversial opera before opening
Christophe Honoré’s Così fan tutte has been described as a ‘provocative and sexually explicit’ adaptation Mozart’s opera

Chris Johnston

27, Jul, 2016 @8:57 PM

Article image
Century Song review – 100 years of black women's history in 60 minutes
Through song, dance and costume, Neema Bickersteth brings to life a wealth of characters with incredible energy and a startling voice

Bridget Minamore

21, Aug, 2018 @1:46 PM

Article image
'Buildings tell stories': how the housing crisis inspired an Edinburgh show
Geoff Sobelle riffs on cramped city living in his festival production Home by building a two-up, two-down from scratch and inviting the audience inside

Matt Trueman

13, Aug, 2018 @3:00 PM

Article image
50 shows to see at the Edinburgh fringe 2018
Superstar standups, daring dance, Brexit cabaret and a Bon Jovi musical … Dive into our guide to some of the shows at the world’s biggest arts festival

Brian Logan and Chris Wiegand

29, Jun, 2018 @1:54 PM

Article image
What Girls Are Made Of review – I was a teenage indie star
Darlingheart’s Cora Bissett writes and stars in an artfully told look at the highs and lows of her time in a band

Kate Wyver

15, Aug, 2018 @6:09 AM