Cotton Panic! review – a story of solidarity that deserves better

Upper Campfield Market Hall, Manchester
Jane Horrocks stars in a collage of song, history and drama whose most powerful presences are its stage projections

“Can you help me a bit?” A spotlit Jane Horrocks revolves through the space where the audience is standing, hemmed in by three giant screens. She waves her arms. Her white floaty dress floats. It’s a clear case of Kate Bush-itis, but the paramedics are busy reviving audience members who have become faint from standing in the crowded arena of this atmospheric but hot market hall. Horrocks, unhelped, returns to the stage. Here, she is once more spotlit – and backlit, through her flimsy frock – as she sings and dances in front of three male musicians, who appear and disappear, as spotlights determine. The effect is amateurish. It shouldn’t be.

The words deserve better: they echo the pleas of Manchester factory workers suffering appalling hardships in the “cotton panic” of 1861-5, yet still standing in solidarity with the as-yet unfreed slaves of the then disunited states of America. This is the subject of what is billed by Manchester international festival as an “industrial music drama”, but is redefined by a publicist on the eve of press night as “a gig”. It comes across as a collage of songs (folk, pop, blues and hymn) montaged with samples of 1860s texts, presented within a soundtrack of soft-focus industrial synthpop, provided by Wrangler (the trio, including Stephen Mallinder, formerly of Cabaret Voltaire, are credited with co-creation, alongside Horrocks and her partner, writer Nick Vivian; Wils Wilson directs).

Jane Horrocks in Cotton Panic!

On the three screens are projected images of cotton blown in the air, of moving figures, including choreographer-dancer Lorena Randi, often with wind machine-blown clothes and hair (Chris Turner is credited with visuals). Among the images are performers not present. Although absent, their presence is powerful: gigantic, in closeup, they movingly deliver texts or simply stare towards the auditorium, listening to hard facts. Most are not white. Their names are difficult to decipher in the fanzine-style, poorly reproduced programme and are not included in the credits on MIF’s website.

The event approaches the present with a reportage-style film (to the Clash’s White Riot), featuring Black Lives Matter placards. Manchester workers in the 1860s believed this. So should we, and it matters that we recognise one another as equals. Here are the names, as given, smudgily, in the paper programme and not at all on the website, of those who appeared on film (some familiar, others less so): Fehinti Balogun, Isaura Barbé-Brown, Fiston Barek, Amy Bell, Teresa Cendon-Garcia, James Heron, Eva Hladaj, Ajibola Ibidapo-Obe, Glenda Jackson, Deborah Rock, William Thompson.

Cotton Panic! – trailer.

Contributor

Clare Brennan

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Cotton Panic! review – Jane Horrocks sings out for solidarity in tribute to Manchester mills
The folk songs of mill workers combine with the gospel tunes of black slaves in a gig-theatre show linking the histories of England’s north and America’s south

Lyn Gardner

11, Jul, 2017 @8:00 PM

Article image
Manchester international festival theatre roundup – emotion socks you in the face
A captive audience is ruffled in immersive refugee drama The Welcoming Party. Elsewhere, powerful tales of sons and fathers and a war room full of women

Susannah Clapp

16, Jul, 2017 @7:00 AM

Article image
Party Skills for the End of the World review – short on fear, long on balloons
A doomed attempt to mix disaster survival and party games gets the otherwise promising Manchester international festival off to a shaky start

Susannah Clapp

09, Jul, 2017 @6:55 AM

Article image
The Welcoming Party review – immersive show charts fear and hope in Fortress Britain
In Theatre-Rites’ remarkable, rackety promenade piece, staged in the world’s first railway warehouse, actors tell their own stories of migration

Lyn Gardner

10, Jul, 2017 @2:55 PM

Article image
Boris Charmatz’s 10,000 Gestures: pushing forward, one step at a time
Boris Charmatz’s blistering new work is, he says, like life – a blizzard of unique moves, never repeated

Sarah Crompton

16, Jul, 2017 @7:00 AM

Article image
Party Skills for the End of the World review – Armageddon meets Blue Peter
This Manchester foray into disaster survival, perhaps tamed by recent events, emphasises fun and craftwork rather than posing serious existential questions

Lyn Gardner

02, Jul, 2017 @10:18 AM

Article image
The week in theatre: Tree; Invisible Cities; Peter Gynt – review
Tree is less exciting than the row about its authorship

Susannah Clapp

14, Jul, 2019 @7:00 AM

Article image
Vicky Featherstone: ‘Theatre is in the middle of a big change’
The Royal Court artistic director on risk-taking, role models and her latest project – putting women in the Dr Strangelove war room…

Miranda Sawyer

02, Jul, 2017 @8:00 AM

Article image
King Lear review – Glenda Jackson is magnificent
Less is more as Glenda Jackson exudes command in Deborah Warner’s fitfully brilliant production

Susannah Clapp

13, Nov, 2016 @8:00 AM

Article image
Fatherland review – three dads and a ladder give a voice to angry Britain
This thrilling play about three sons who go home to their dads – and their childhoods – shows verbatim theatre’s power to heed the forgotten

Michael Billington

06, Jul, 2017 @2:07 PM