Evening at the Talk House review – Wallace Shawn's dark comedy plays it safe

Romulus Linney Courtyard Theatre, New York

Despite a strong performance from a perfectly cast Matthew Broderick, this play about a play doesn’t cut as deep as it should

Wallace Shawn is a playwright not so much interested in the skull beneath the skin as in the guts roiling below the casual suiting. We are animals, Shawn insists, creatures of brute desire and decay. We want sex and food and power. Civilization? Window dressing. In his new play, Evening at the Talk House, Shawn makes these arguments baldly and with uncomfortable aptness (are we all just baskets of deplorables?). But as produced by the New Group, the play digests so easily and un-queasily that it can feel like it was barely there at all.

The opening moments, as directed by Scott Elliott, are somewhat immersive. Audience members mingle with actors while marshmallows and gummies and fizzy drinks circulate on trays. The marshmallows ought to turn to ashes in the mouth as the play unfolds; mostly they taste pretty sweet. Once seats are taken, the playwright Robert (Matthew Broderick) explains the occasion for the gathering, the 10-year anniversary of a notorious flop, Midnight in a Clearing with Moon and Stars. Though the play failed, it attracted the notice of a ruthless politician – and Robert’s star has been on the rise ever since.

But at the Talk House, which is in Robert’s starched description and Broderick’s bleating tones, the “almost-legendary, wonderfully quiet and genteel club, known far and wide at one time for its delicious and generously-sized snacks”, it becomes clear that many of Robert’s former colleagues have fallen on more adamantine times. (This includes Shawn himself, playing an actor in pajamas recovering from an assault.) Several of them have even taken to targeting citizens and foreign nationals for execution, and at least one has worked as a murderer. Also dead: theater. No one misses it much. When the play opened in London late in 2015 – before Brexit, before Trump – many reviewers complained that it was inept and dull. It isn’t. But despite the ways in which world events have dovetailed with is content, it doesn’t have the morally searching qualities of Shawn’s best work, like The Fever and Aunt Dan and Lemon, plays that seduce you with their intelligence and welcome, then rabbit-punch you with visions of your own cowardice and cravenness and complacency.

Evening at the Talk House ought to be a body slam. Instead, it barely beats you up at all. In place of nauseating personal culpability, there’s a memory-play haze haunting the thing, perhaps a consequence of Robert’s long opening monologue that sets the scene. Despite some lovely performances (Jill Eikenberry and Michael Tucker, especially, and a perfectly cast Broderick) the stakes seem perilously low, which is odd considering that the collapse of civilized society or at the very least an assassination or two threatens.

But this is the way the play – and maybe the world – ends, not with a bang but with a marshmallow.


Alexis Soloski

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Plaza Suite review – Sarah Jessica Parker sells Neil Simon’s marriage comedy
The Sex and the City star plays well opposite her husband Matthew Broderick in an overlong triptych of bitter relationship tales

Alexis Soloski

29, Mar, 2022 @1:00 AM

Article image
Evening at the Talk House review – Wallace Shawn says the unsayable
A theatrical reunion lurches into a bad-dream debate about targeted bombings

Kate Kellaway

29, Nov, 2015 @8:00 AM

Article image
Evening at the Talk House review – Wallace Shawn throws a hell of a party
In his blunt new play, set in a genteel private club, Shawn tackles political barbarism via showbiz bitchery

Michael Billington

25, Nov, 2015 @12:39 PM

Article image
Sylvia review – Annaleigh Ashford excels in canine comedy
AR Gurney play about a middle-aged man who falls in love with a mutt might be a shaggy dog story, but Matthew Broderick and his co-star make it sing – or howl

Alexis Soloski

28, Oct, 2015 @2:00 AM

Article image
Broadway in a garage: the clumsy pleasures of Rosie O'Donnell's star-studded livestream
A host of big names, including Lin-Manuel Miranda and Sarah Jessica Parker, took part in a self-congratulatory yet oddly charming YouTube-based revue

Alexis Soloski

23, Mar, 2020 @2:52 PM

Article image
What to say about ... Wallace Shawn's Aunt Dan and Lemon at the Royal Court
Don't look like a wally when your friends discuss the Royal Court's revival of Shawn's 1985 play about sex and politics. Just squeeze the critics for some quotes

Leo Benedictus

01, Jun, 2009 @2:33 PM

Article image
Straight White Men review – Armie Hammer skewers male privilege in dark comedy
A subversive look at masculinity boasts canny, self-aware performances and a shrewd dissection of gender roles

Alexis Soloski

24, Jul, 2018 @2:00 AM

Article image
Chicken and Biscuits review – under-baked Broadway comedy
A funeral at a Black church promises chaotic and culturally specific comedy but the end-product feels more like a broad, lukewarm sitcom

Gloria Oladipo

11, Oct, 2021 @5:34 PM

Article image
It's Only a Play review – Nathan Lane parties, Matthew Broderick looks pooped
Even a cast including The Producers’ duo – alongside F Murray Abraham, Rupert Grint and Stockard Channing – can’t save this play about plays

Alexis Soloski

10, Oct, 2014 @5:40 PM

Article image
Kid Victory review – John Kander's melodies haunt dark abuse musical
The Broadway legend’s lovely music-box refrains and mournful orchestrations give emotional weight to the melancholy story of a teenager who was kept chained in a basement for a year

Alexis Soloski

23, Feb, 2017 @3:15 AM