Man and Superman review – Ralph Fiennes masters Shaw’s contrary male

Lyttelton theatre, London
Simon Godwin’s modern-dress revival sprinkles fun on the social debate as it reduces a very masculine hero to helplessness in the face of feminine seduction

“My method,” Bernard Shaw once said, “is founded upon music.” So it seems fitting that Simon Godwin’s modern-dress revival of this epic comedy should open with John Tanner, played by Ralph Fiennes, choosing a track from Don Giovanni on Desert Island Discs and end on a note of Mozartian ecstasy. What we see, in the intervening three-and-a-half hours, is akin to spoken opera.

At first, I had doubts about Godwin’s updating. The comedy of the first two acts depends heavily on Shaw’s exposure of social hypocrisy and reversal of theatrical conventions. He was, after all, writing in 1901-03 when Tanner’s revolutionary ideas, as well as the notion of an unmarried woman getting pregnant, might have seemed faintly shocking: today we take them in our stride. In the second act we see Tanner fleeing by car to Spain to escape the clutches of the pursuing heroine, Ann Whitefield. But the joke about the chauffeur who is wiser than his employer belongs to a period in which other comedies, including JM Barrie’s The Admirable Crichton, pointed up the helpless dependency of the rich.

Man and Superman: Jack Tanner (Ralph Fiennes) flees with his chauffeur, played by Elliot Barnes-Worrell.
Comical escape … Jack Tanner (Ralph Fiennes) flees with his chauffeur, played by Elliot Barnes-Worrell. Photograph: Tristram Kenton/The Guardian

What is astonishing about Godwin’s production is that it triumphs where Shaw’s play is most difficult. The stumbling-block, often omitted, is usually the prolonged Don Juan In Hell scene: a dream-sequence where Tanner morphs into the famous libertine and a Spanish brigand into the devil. Not only is it all talk but Shaw’s ideas about woman’s role in fathering a new Superman now seem, rather dubiously, to be holding the mirror up to Nietzsche. But the debate is here animated by superb staging, with designer Christopher Oram’s glass wall taking on mutliple colours and allowing us a shadowy glimpse of the future products of what Tanner calls the Life Force.

Shaw’s ironic joke is that Don Juan spouts endlessly about intellect and will but, back in the real world, Tanner is helpless before Ann Whitefield’s amorous pursuit. In a masterly performance, Fiennes catches all Tanner’s contradictions.

He brings out precisely, with left leg thrust eagerly forwards, the vanity and arrogance in Tanner’s proclamation of his revolutionary principles. Translated into Don Juan, he argues the case for creative evolution with passion and urgency. But he is at his funniest in the final act when, confronted by Ann’s ardour, he exudes an impotent despair.

Man and Superman: Tanner encounters a Spanish brigand, played by Tim McMullan (left)
Home truths … Tanner encounters a Spanish brigand, played by Tim McMullan (left) Photograph: Tristram Kenton/The Guardian

The trickiest role, in some ways, is Ann herself. She is obviously intended to be a strong woman and force of nature. By casting Indira Varma in the role, the production gives her a sexual glamour that makes Tanner’s pretended resistance look palpably absurd: what Varma also catches excellently is Ann’s mix of calculation and charm. There is a supremely funny performance from Tim McMullan as both a helplessly lovelorn Spanish brigand and a suavely ironic Devil who holds court in Hell over a lavishly endowed drinks trolley. And, in a play rich in supporting characters, there is good work from Faye Castelow as a hard-headed romantic fugitive and Nicholas Le Prevost as a deep-dyed conservative who imagines himself an advanced thinker.

Even I, as an ardent Shavian, would concede there are moments when you wish the old boy would get a move on. But his wit, often funnier than that of Wilde, endures. So too, whatever we think of his ideas, does the felicity of his prose which, as he intended, achieves the seductive rhythm of music.

Until 17 May. Box office: 020 7452 3000. Venue: Lyttelton theatre at the National, London


Michael Billington

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Ralph Fiennes and Simon Godwin: our satanic take on Shaw’s Superman
Most productions cut a whole act from Man and Superman. But Ralph Fiennes and director Simon Godwin plan to unleash its full Nietzschean power

Mark Lawson

05, Feb, 2015 @7:30 AM

Article image
Man and Superman review – Ralph Fiennes towers as Shaw’s Don Juan
Simon Godwin’s whirling revival of Shaw’s loquacious 1903 play proves fashion wrong in emphatic style

Susannah Clapp

01, Mar, 2015 @7:00 AM

Article image
Antony and Cleopatra review – Okonedo and Fiennes are a magnificent match
Simon Godwin directs a terrific and epic National Theatre production, filled with passion and delusion

Michael Billington

27, Sep, 2018 @10:11 AM

Article image
'An amazing force': Ralph Fiennes on Barbara Jefford's power and passion
In plays by Pirandello and Shakespeare, Jefford – who has died aged 90 – displayed incredible precision, says her co-star

Interview by Chris Wiegand

16, Sep, 2020 @5:13 PM

Article image
Richard III review – Ralph Fiennes gets to grips with Shakespeare's ruthless ruler
In Rupert Goold’s production, Fiennes sacrifices some of the character’s irony while Vanessa Redgrave softens the often scolding Queen Margaret

Michael Billington

16, Jun, 2016 @10:00 PM

Article image
Straight Line Crazy review – Ralph Fiennes enthrals as the man who shaped New York
Fiennes heads an electrifying cast in David Hare’s dynamic portrait of Robert Moses, an aggressive yet visionary urban planner who refused to back down

Mark Lawson

24, Mar, 2022 @12:01 AM

Article image
Ralph Fiennes and Sophie Okonedo win at Evening Standard theatre awards
Duo triumph for performances in Antony and Cleopatra, as Hamilton and Company also land prizes

Mark Brown Arts correspondent

18, Nov, 2018 @10:45 PM

Article image
Ralph Fiennes to direct and star in TS Eliot's Four Quartets
A solo theatre adaptation, co-produced by Theatre Royal Bath and the Royal & Derngate, will tour the UK this summer

Chris Wiegand

17, Mar, 2021 @2:29 PM

Article image
100 years of Man and Superman: Michael Holroyd on Bernard Shaw
A century after it was first performed in its entirety, Shaw’s monumental Man and Superman returns to the London stage. The playwright’s biographer explores the strange birth of a masterpiece, as revered by writers as it is feared by actors

Michael Holroyd

07, Feb, 2015 @10:00 AM

Article image
The Master Builder review – Fiennes at the height of his powers
Ibsen’s play about an architect jealous of rivals and haunted by guilt presents a searing self-portrait for a magnetic actor

Michael Billington

04, Feb, 2016 @12:40 AM