Matilda the Musical review – still a revoltingly subversive success

Lyric theatre, Sydney
Australia finally gets the Tony and Olivier award-winning adaptation of Roald Dahl’s classic by Dennis Kelly and local hero Tim Minchin on his homepatch

Roald Dahl down under: Aussies name their favourite books – what’s yours?• * Matilda the Musical: the Australian premiere – in pictures

While the very first line (and joke) of Matilda the Musical is sung by a nine-year-old, the laugh it prompts comes straight out of the mouths of adults.

“My mummy says I’m a miracle.” Six words that ring wryly true for any grown-up – parent or not – who has despaired at the baby conveyor belt of their Facebook news feed or dozed off as former party friends boast about their kid’s perfect poo.

Of course, the Roald Dahl book on which this staggeringly successful stage show is based, is the story of a miracle child. Matilda Wormwood is reading Dickens and Dostoyevsky by five but has the misfortune to be born to a mother and father who’d rather she watch telly, be a boy, or better still, bugger off entirely.

Five years is also how long Australia has been waiting for Matilda since its Royal Shakespeare Company premiere in 2010. “Not fair!” we cried, particularly as the show’s Tony and Olivier award-winning music and lyrics are the work of an Aussie – comedian Tim Minchin – alongside Dennis Kelly.

But now the show has finally arrived in Sydney, and boy! – or rather, girl! (“I’m a girl!” Matilda reminds her toad of a father), it looks and sounds good.

As in London and New York, four young performers share the title role, and the show lives or dies on their energy. Matilda is an introvert, not an easy thing for a young actor to pull off, but the night I’m in, Molly Barwick nails her character’s confidence and contemplation – no doubt matched by the other Matildas: Sasha Rose, Bella Thomas and Georgia Taplin.

The grown-ups aren’t half bad either. They’re 100% bad. If Daniel Frederiksen and Marika Aubrey bring out the pantomime in Matilda’s parents, then James Millar as her terrifying headmistress Miss Trunchbull is the deliciously wrong dame. Because Matilda the Musical isn’t really a kids’ show at all.

Minchin and Kelly constantly poke us where it hurts in ways Disney could only dream of, drawing a line from the fears and injustice of childhood to the inevitable failings and disappointments of growing up.

Revolting: the Sydney cast of Matilda The Musical
Revolting: the Sydney cast of Matilda The Musical Photograph: James D. Morgan/REX Shutterstock

Having the pupils of Crunchem Hall school played interchangeably by child and adult actors adds to this effect. When Matilda and her kind-hearted teacher Miss Honey (a pitch perfect Elise McCann) duet in the heartbreaking second-half opener, When I Grow Up, they’re not just singing as one – they might as well be the same person.

Small quibbles: the story-within-a story Matilda tells her librarian (a hearty Cle Morgan) distracts a little from Dahl’s original narrative and Miss Trunchbull, while an awe-inspiring mix of bulldog and camp, could do with being as scary as she is in the book.

But this is still a revolting success – the show’s climactic song even puns on that most Dahlian of words. “We are revolting children / living in revolting times / We sing revolting songs / using revolting rhymes,” scream the kids as they dance out their frustrations in Peter Darling’s attitude-laden choreography.

In a country where Dahl’s book Revolting Rhymes was taken off the shelves of Aldi in 2014 after conservatives complained about the use of the word “slut”, this takes on extra meaning. As Imogen Russell Williams wrote of that incident: “Children need darkness, grotesquerie and gore, and the sense of being trusted with ‘the real story’ that Dahl has always given them. Even if (perhaps especially if) that makes grown-ups uncomfortable.”

Matilda the Musical does feel uncomfortable at times, and it’s all the better for it. It’s also a riotously uplifting love letter to the power of story and the stage.


Nancy Groves

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Matilda the Musical – review

Tim Minchin's musical rendition of Roald Dahl's Matilda is irresistible, writes Imogen Carter

Imogen Carter

27, Nov, 2011 @12:05 AM

Article image
‘It had to be dark’ – how we made Matilda the Musical
‘We didn’t give Matilda any songs because she was shy. Then we realised: it’s a fricking musical – the protagonist needs to sing!

Interviews by Chris Wiegand

08, Nov, 2021 @3:00 PM

Article image
Matilda - review

This anarchically joyous, gleefully nasty and ingenious musical adaptation of Roald Dahl's story of a loveable moppet who scoffs Dickens and Dostoevsky like other kids eat sweets is an evening of unadulterated bliss, writes Lyn Gardner

Lyn Gardner

25, Nov, 2011 @12:56 AM

Article image
RSC's Matilda: the Musical a hit on Broadway
The Royal Shakespeare Company's first Broadway premiere for 15 years deemed 'even more glorious than we were promised'

Matt Trueman

12, Apr, 2013 @5:45 PM

Article image
How to make the Australian musical: from The Sapphires to Strictly Ballroom
With Muriel’s Wedding the Musical making its debut in November, we take a look back at mainstage shows through the ages – the good and the bad

Steve Dow

14, Jun, 2017 @7:00 PM

Article image
Matilda the musical: Daughters on stage
Four young girls have shared the role of Matilda in London's West End musical hit. Now they have been nominated for an Olivier award. Susanna Rustin talks to them and their mothers about what it's like to find themselves in the limelight

Susanna Rustin

06, Apr, 2012 @11:05 PM

Article image
Tim Minchin on his Groundhog Day musical: 'we think it's all right'
Upcoming stage adaptation of Harold Ramis film needs just ‘one more song’, reveals comedian at Australian premiere of Matilda the Musical

Alexandra Spring

21, Aug, 2015 @6:32 AM

Article image
Matilda on way to Broadway success
Matt Trueman: The RSC's hit production still faces strong competition from a revival of Annie and Rodgers and Hammerstein's Cinderella

Matt Trueman

12, Mar, 2013 @12:57 PM

Article image
Helpmann awards: Tim Minchin's Matilda the Musical scoops record 13 prizes
Eight young actors who played the title role share one of musical’s four acting awards, while Minchin wins best original score

Melissa Davey

26, Jul, 2016 @2:28 AM

Article image
Roald Dahl down under: Aussies name their favourite books – what's yours?
His twisted tales have been part of our collective childhood since the 1960s. As Matilda the Musical opens in Sydney, Australian performers, directors and writers choose their favourite Dahl stories

Alexandra Spring

20, Aug, 2015 @2:22 AM