Ronan Keating in Once review – night of cracked hearts as Guy meets Girl

Phoenix, London
The Boyzone star acquits himself well but despite Enda Walsh’s colourful characters, this show sounds too tasteful

Ronan Keating: ‘Acting the role of a singer does my head in’

Once may be quite enough for some, but this cunningly unassuming musical – which opened in the West End last year and is based on the 2006 movie – is clearly hoping to clean up at the box office with its new star. Former Boyzone singer Ronan Keating has taken over the role of a Dublin singer-songwriter with a broken heart but lungs in perfectly good working order.

Director John Tiffany sprinkles bucket-loads of theatrical fairy dust over this guy-meets-girl musical with considerable help from movement director Steven Hoggett; designer Bob Crowley, who sets the whole thing in a pub-like space full of mottled mirrors; and the gorgeous melting, shadowy illuminations of lighting designer Natasha Katz.

Tiffany makes it look simple as he creates a moody, textured evening full of cracked hearts and an almost Chekhovian sadness at life’s missed opportunities. It makes the traditional musical and jukebox shows, still so dominant on our stages, look like an alien life form. It’s just a pity that the yearning ballads all sound so similar and similarly tasteful.

A scene from Once by Edna Walsh at the Phoenix theatre, London
Playing, stamping, dancing … Once. Photograph: Tristram Kenton

Keating’s Guy, bereft at the departure of his girlfriend to live in New York, spends his evenings singing in the kind of Dublin bar where every customer is a skilled musician, and his days mending things in his Da’s shop. Then just as he’s about to chuck in the performing, Girl (Jill Winternitz) walks into the bar. She’s a talented pianist with a husband back home in the Czech Republic, and a broken vacuum cleaner. Guy and Girl bond over a domestic appliance – and a love of music.

In many ways this is a lovely show, made all the better by the fact that it doesn’t follow either the traditional love story or the failure-to-fame story formula. It’s full of ambiguities. This is a show about all those Cinderellas who never get to go to the ball, and the most moving moment comes in the recording studio when they each reveal the hidden hinterland of their emotional and daily lives in a sequence that is like a low-key version of A Chorus Line. There is another fantastic scene as Guy and Girl argue their case with a bank manager for a loan, during which we simultaneously glimpse the frustrations of other everyday lives going nowhere via Hoggett’s inspired choreography.

But while Winternitz’s quirky Girl is the story’s motor and brings momentum, Guy is such a passive figure that it’s hard to detect his appeal. Keating acquits himself decently, but there’s not much he can do with a character whose default setting is anguished yearning and who is little more than a vacuum. The lack of personality and energy at the heart of the show is partially made up for by Enda Walsh’s array of colourful characters, and the piece is best when all the brilliant actor-musicians on stage are involved: playing, stamping, dancing and also hinting at the waterfalls of sadness and desperation behind their smiling eyes.

• Until 21 March. Box office: 0844 b871 7629. Venue: Phoenix, London

Ronan Keating: ‘Acting the role of a singer does my head in’

Contributor

Lyn Gardner

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Once review – Ronan Keating hits the right notes as humble busker
The Boyzone star’s acting errs on the wooden side, but there’s no doubt about his singing performance, writes Kate Kellaway

Kate Kellaway

30, Nov, 2014 @12:05 AM

Article image
Ronan Keating takes the lead in Once in his West End debut

The Boyzone singer will star in the romantic musical adapted from the Oscar-winning film

Ben Beaumont-Thomas

06, Jun, 2014 @9:37 AM

Article image
Ronan Keating: ‘Acting the role of a singer does my head in’
The ex-Boyzone singer-songwriter talks to Liz Hoggard about the challenge he faces taking on the lead role in hit West End musical Once

Liz Hoggard

02, Nov, 2014 @12:05 AM

Article image
Bowie musical Lazarus to open in London
‘Unapologetically weird’ show, one of the star’s final projects, to run this winter at King’s Cross Theatre

Mark Brown Arts correspondent

25, Jul, 2016 @10:55 AM

Article image
Pinocchio review – the wooden wonder struts his stuff in a brilliant return to his roots
The puppetry is ingenious and the songs are a joy as Dennis Kelly and John Tiffany carve a morality play out of Carlo Collodi’s original story

Michael Billington

15, Dec, 2017 @10:08 AM

Article image
Once - review

Michael Billington: Simplicity and sweet melancholy in charming musical about missed opportunities

Michael Billington

09, Apr, 2013 @10:01 PM

Article image
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child wins eight prizes at WhatsOnStage awards
Sold-out show wins best new play, best director and three acting prizes, while Billie Piper wins best actress for Yerma

Mark Brown Arts correspondent

19, Feb, 2017 @9:30 PM

Article image
Evita review – Argentina's queen of hearts as a high-school mean girl
Andrew Lloyd Webber’s epic gets a rock-concert revival that features pom-poms and twerking but lacks central chemistry

Arifa Akbar

09, Aug, 2019 @11:23 AM

Article image
Lazarus review – Michael C Hall is a loving alien in spectacular Bowie fantasy
David Bowie and Enda Walsh’s sequel to The Man Who Fell to Earth is staged with visual sophistication by Ivo van Hove but it’s rarely emotionally engaging

Michael Billington

08, Nov, 2016 @10:00 PM

Article image
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child breaks Olivier nominations record
Show’s 11 nominations including best actor are most for a new play, while Groundhog Day dominates musical categories

Mark Brown Arts correspondent

06, Mar, 2017 @6:46 PM