Musicals we love: Blood Brothers

Willy Russell's boisterous show has an authentic working-class voice, socialist principles and sweetly melodic songs

If you ask a class of drama students why they chose their subject, a majority will answer with an anecdote about seeing a heart-stopping production at a formative age. For me, Willy Russell's Blood Brothers wasn't exactly that (when I saw it at the age of 18, I'd already developed a theatregoing habit), but it did make a tremendous impression.

If I'm calculating right, it was Friday 7 January 1983, and I'd managed to buy a ticket for a preview performance in the very back row, upstairs at the Liverpool Playhouse. It must have been the last seat in the house.

At one point in Chris Bond's production, a door jammed and Barbara Dickson, the first Mrs Johnstone, had to make her entrance round the side. The audience liked that. We knew it was a preview and it made it more real. We gave her an extra round of applause.

Back then, Russell's reputation on Merseyside meant a large audience was happy to turn out for an unknown play. Thanks to John, Paul, George, Ringo … & Bert, Our Day Out and Educating Rita, Russell and other Liverpool playwrights had moved new writing out of the studio-theatre ghetto. I'd heard about Blood Brothers because my mum, a teacher, had seen Russell's earlier nonmusical version on a schools tour, but otherwise, it was just a new show by a popular local author that everyone wanted to see.

What excited me at the time was that this was a musical that had everything. Andrew Schofield came on as a narrator who spoke in rhyming couplets ("So, did y' hear the story of the Johnstone twins?/As like each other as two new pins") which gave the show an air of Greek tragedy. It had a narrative arc to match. That could have been pretentious, except this show was also boisterous, earthy and funny.

It had an authentic working-class voice and, in its story about twins brought up on either side of the class divide, it wore its political heart on its sleeve. This was 18 months after the Toxteth riots, the era of Militant councils and Boys from the Blackstuff, and to find socialist principles enshrined in a popular musical felt like a tremendous provocation. It wasn't West End glitz, it was theatre rooted in its place and time.

All this, and a set of sweetly melodic songs by Russell himself that reminded us musicals could work in a folk/pop idiom – just as they had done in the golden era of Broadway. I'm Not Saying a Word, Tell Me It's Not True, Marilyn Monroe … has any playwright since Noël Coward doubled up so persuasively as a composer?

Recently, a friend told me he'd seen the show on a UK tour and was shocked by how bad it was. I don't know, I wasn't there. Maybe it became something else after 30 years. But back at the start of 1983, Blood Brothers stood for everything I believed theatre could be.

More from this series: Lyn Gardner on Follies, Alfred Hickling on Annie, Brian Logan on Sunshin on Leith, Mark Lawson on London Road


Mark Fisher

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Musicals we love: Annie

Continuing our series on favourite shows, Alfred Hickling explains why he's a big fan of the little girl who bounces back from hard knocks

Alfred Hickling

27, Jan, 2014 @4:33 PM

Article image
Musicals we love: Les Misérables

Its storyline is ridiculous, but the glorious melodrama of Les Mis will leave you weeping uncontrollably. And, says Alison Flood, the songs couldn't be more rousing

Alison Flood

05, May, 2014 @11:02 AM

Article image
Musicals we love: Newsies

Walt Disney Studios's film about the New York newsboy strikes of 1899 was a flop – but a stage revival nearly 20 years later proved that some still root for the underdog, writes Erin McCann

Erin McCann

14, Apr, 2014 @12:23 PM

Article image
The Producers: musicals we love

Mel Brooks's 1968 film makes even greater sense on the stage – especially with the peerless Nathan Lane in the lead role, writes Ryan Gilbey

Ryan Gilbey

26, May, 2014 @7:00 AM

Article image
Musicals we love: Sweeney Todd
Stephen Sondheim's serial-killing barber may be an unsavoury hero, but the musical skilfully mixes savagery, tragedy and comedy to create a work of art that leaves one in awe, writes Michael Billington

Michael Billington

03, Mar, 2014 @11:43 AM

Article image
Musicals we love: Sondheim's Follies
Lyn Gardner: Beginning our series of Guardian writers' favourite musicals, Lyn Gardner describes why she loves Stephen Sondheim's 1971 'pas de deux of regret'

Lyn Gardner

20, Jan, 2014 @10:37 AM

Article image
Musicals we love: Sunshine on Leith

In the latest in our series on our favourite shows, Brian Logan applauds a jukebox musical that situates the songs of the Proclaimers in real 21st-century Britain

Brian Logan

03, Feb, 2014 @3:19 PM

Article image
Musicals we love: Into the Woods

Soon to appear in film form with Meryl Streep as the Witch, Sondheim's plainest musical blends adult stories with grim fairytales to spellbinding effect, writes Veronica Horwell

Veronica Horwell

07, Jul, 2014 @5:26 PM

Article image
Musicals we love: The Beggar's Opera

It was the first juke-box musical, filled with highwaymen, thieves, jailers and trollops in bulging corsets – I loved it when I was 10 and I still love it now, writes Laura Barnett

Laura Barnett

28, Apr, 2014 @7:00 AM

Article image
Musicals we love: London Road

In the latest in our series on writers' favourite shows, Mark Lawson explains his potentially controversial choice of this verbatim musical about the Ipswich serial murders

Mark Lawson

10, Feb, 2014 @8:00 AM