A heroic but predictable ending as Scotland fall to South Africa’s size | Andy Bull

Rough and tumble World Cup clash suited Eben Etzebeth and company, with Scotland sucked into playing opponent’s game

It must be something about Marseille. For the second day running the city hosted a right rough-and-tumble game of rugby. It looked, for long stretches, less like a match than something dark going on down a back alley after hours in the old port, the sort of thing which you might cross the street to avoid. At one point it really did break out into a fight, when Ben White bundled Damian de Allende into touch and everyone came wading in after them. The Scotland captain, Jamie Ritchie, raced across to make his point and suddenly found himself in the unfortunate position of having to square off against Eben Etzebeth.

Ritchie is 6ft 3in and 17st, but Etzebeth still towers overs him. He fixed him by the scruff and shot him the sort of malicious grin he might give a cow he was planning to eat for dinner later that evening. Ritchie, to be fair to him, glared back like he wanted Etzebeth to know he was welcome to try. Brave as it was, the moment rather summed it all up. It felt very much like Scotland got sucked into trying to play South Africa at their own game, which, just look at the size of them, was only ever going to be a mistake.

There were casualties. Etzebeth himself went off soon after, replaced by RG Snyman, who has the general mien of a man who cooks himself two Ali Prices for breakfast most mornings. Jesse Kriel collided head-first with Jack Dempsey and was damn lucky to escape without any penalty at all, Finn Russell was smashed back, repeatedly, and spent stretches of the match flat on his back and gasping for breath.

Everywhere you looked people seemed to be bleeding, or sporting fresh wrap, strapping, and bandages and the doctors were off and on like a couple of cuckoos popping out of a broken clock.

All these stoppages meant the first half stretched on the best part of an hour. It had everything you would want in a game of rugby if you’re a front-rower. There were nine scrums, and Scotland’s pack did brilliantly to win two of them against the head, something no one has done against South Africa so far this year.

The second of them, from five metres inside South Africa’s half, led to Scotland’s solitary penalty goal. Problem was their lineout wasn’t working nearly so well, and it’s been the source for almost three‑quarters of the tries they’ve scored so far this year.

South Africa’s Damian de Allende tackles Finn Russell of Scotland.
Finn Russell, tackled by Damian de Allende, was not given the time or space to be at his creative best for Scotland. Photograph: Neal Simpson/Shutterstock

Here they missed two attacking opportunities on South Africa’s 22 because George Turner threw the ball over the back. When they finally did get it right, at the third time of asking, they worked an overlap off the back of it but it sputtered out when Darcy Graham held on to the ball too long. It was just about the only time in the first 60 minutes they found any real room in which to work. The South African defence was so fast, and so fierce, that Russell never had time or space to try any of his midfield wizardry; every time it seemed like he might be about to whip a rabbit out of the hat, someone clobbered him before he could finish the trick. There is more than one side to Russell, though, and he mucked in with the scrapping, he even threw himself into a superb tap tackle to stop Grant Williams scoring a great freewheeling try in the dying minutes.

You could see what Scotland wanted to do. They were trying to play in a hurry, to make it a helter‑skelter free‑for‑all, and Russell kept calling for quicker ball, flapping his arms wide either side in exasperation. But South Africa weren’t about to be rushed. They play a slow and stifling style of rugby, at least until one of their brilliant wings Kurt‑Lee Arendse and Cheslin Kolbe gets on the ball. Then, all of a sudden, the match snaps into fast-forward and everything starts to move like a chain unspooling from a broken winch and the exhausted defenders are left trying to snatch it back before it runs away altogether.

Over 40 minutes the general effect was that Scotland came off like a man trying desperately hard to prop up an elephant’s bottom to stop it from sitting on him. It was a heroic attempt, with a predictable ending.

South Africa duly flattened them in the minutes after half-time, scoring once when Pieter-Steph du Toit bundled his way over after a series of rushes, and then again three minutes later when Manie Libbok picked out Arendse with a brilliant high, hanging cross‑field kick into the space behind Duhan van der Merwe. That settled it at 18-3.

Scotland actually started to show a little more of themselves afterwards, perhaps because South Africa were flagging, or felt they had won the game already. It was too little, though, too late, a last squeak from a side who you guess will need every one of the 14 days they have before their next game to recover from this one.


Andy Bull at the Stade de Marseille

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
South Africa’s Du Toit and Arendse break Scotland resistance for win
South Africa’s Jesse Kriel escaped punishment for a first-minute upright tackle as the world champions went on to beat Scotland 18-3

Robert Kitson at the Stade de Marseille

10, Sep, 2023 @6:06 PM

Article image
Du Toit overcomes major medical scare to join South Africa’s greats | Jonathan Liew
Springbok forward could have lost a leg in 2020 due to a rare condition but has battled back to win another World Cup

Jonathan Liew in Paris

29, Oct, 2023 @6:00 PM

Article image
Government declares ‘the Webb Ellis is in South Africa’s kant’
The South African government said ‘the Webb Ellis is in South Africa’s kant’ in a statement referencing the row over the alleged racial slur after the World Cup semi-final win over England

Gerard Meagher in Paris

29, Oct, 2023 @10:00 PM

Article image
Farrell’s Ireland gear up to meet South Africa’s might in heavyweight contest
Springboks’ nuke squad has dominated the pre-match agenda with size of challenge impossible to duck for Ireland, with the world No 1 ranking at stake

Robert Kitson in Paris

21, Sep, 2023 @7:05 PM

Article image
Borthwick to call on cavalry with Farrell poised to lead England against Wales
Steve Borthwick is expected to call on some experienced players for England’s clash with Wales on Saturday with the captain Owen Farrell set to return

Gerard Meagher

09, Aug, 2023 @8:40 PM

Article image
Rugby World Cup awards: the best player, the best match – our verdicts
From that monumental quarter-final weekend to Kurt-Lee Arendse’s wonder try and the emergence of Portugal, the Guardian’s rugby experts hand out their awards

Robert Kitson, Gerard Meagher, Andy Bull, Jonathan Liew, Michael Aylwin and Luke McLaughlin

30, Oct, 2023 @3:00 PM

Article image
Relief of South Africa shows just how close England came to victory in Paris | Andy Bull
Saturday came down to tiny margins. Unpicking England’s puzzle took the defending champions to the edge of reason

Andy Bull in Paris

22, Oct, 2023 @1:31 PM

Article image
Dupont produces his best on biggest stage but South Africa deliver the pain | Jonathan Liew
France’s scrum-half barely put a foot wrong despite a fractured cheek but he was up against a stronger team in Paris

Jonathan Liew at the Stade de France

15, Oct, 2023 @10:41 PM

Article image
RFU reacts with fury to World Rugby ending Mbonambi case without hearing
RFU has said it is ‘deeply disappointed’ there will not be a hearing by an independent disciplinary panel into Tom Curry’s claim of racial abuse

Gerard Meagher in Paris

26, Oct, 2023 @4:49 PM

Article image
World Rugby in reputational minefield with call on Curry and Mbonambi incident | Robert Kitson
The sport’s governing body, the Rugby Football Union and South Africa have all added fuel to the debate’s fire

Robert Kitson in Paris

26, Oct, 2023 @3:53 PM