Cummins’ lack of intent shows sharp contrast of styles before Ashes | Andy Bull

Idling tempo while batting in World Test Championship against India felt unfamiliar compared with Stokes’ all-action approach

Lunchtime at the Oval, and Australia are six wickets down with a lead of 373. Alex Carey’s at one end, 41 not out off 61 balls, Mitchell Starc’s at the other, 11 off 19. It’s already over a hundred runs more than anyone’s ever scored in the fourth innings to win a Test here, and that particular match was way back in the 1902 Ashes, when Gilbert Jessop blazed his 76-ball hundred. The pressing question then, the one everyone was chewing over in the food and drink queues, was: “What’s next?” A burst of attacking cricket, a tumble of tail-end wickets?

What we got, instead, was one of those soporific hours when play slows down to an amble. Starc threw the odd shot, a clip through midwicket for four, a punch down the ground for another, Carey tinkered around in singles. The crowd quietened down, the sun drifted overhead, aeroplanes came and went. Tick. A single off one over. Tock. A single off the next. Tick. Another single from the one after. Tock. In 10 overs, Australia scored all of 31 runs. The second hand wavered, even seemed to be moving backwards.

The lead grew, past the 378 England made to beat India at Edgbaston last year, past the 404 Don Bradman’s Australia scored to beat England at Headingley in 1948, and then on beyond the world record of 418 set by Brian Lara’s West Indies against Australia in 2003. Carey reached his fifty, and pressed on into the 60s. Everyone kept one eye on the balcony, wondering whether, and when, Pat Cummins was going to call them in and set to bowling, but he was still padded up, ready and waiting for his turn to bat.

Which duly arrived when Starc was caught at slip. India had taken the new ball by now, and the run rate had perked up. But it still wasn’t particularly clear what Cummins achieved in the 15 minutes he spent at the crease, other than showing off a matinee idol drive, and stacking another 10 runs on top of the teetering 434 his team had already piled up.

Not that you blame Cummins for wanting all that padding, even on a pitch like this, where the bounce has been capricious, the short balls vicious, and the ball has spun from the rough. This is an era when teams have been setting record scores right around the world. England, of course, did it last year, but so did Pakistan, who made 344 to beat Sri Lanka at Galle, and West Indies, who made 395 to beat Bangladesh in Chittagong the year before. Everyone expects that 418 will, like Jessop’s record, be broken sooner rather than later.

Australia’s Alex Carey hits a boundary on the fourth day of the World Test Championship against India.
Alex Carey scored an unbeaten half-century as Australia built up a big lead against India. Photograph: Kirsty Wigglesworth/AP

And there were points, when India were 91 for one, when Cummins might even have been glad to have a few more. But still it was hard, watching the innings drift like this, not to let your mind wander to wondering exactly how England would have gone about it. Ben Stokes’s approach would, you guess, have been a little more Shakespearean. “If it were done when ‘tis done, ‘twere well it were done quickly.” So stop bloody prodding at it or let’s get on with the bowling. Pootling along at three an over when you have a 400-run lead is the kind of thing that might get you dropped from his team.

  • Download the Guardian app from the iOS App Store on iPhone or the Google Play store on Android by searching for 'The Guardian'.
  • If you already have the Guardian app, make sure you’re on the most recent version.
  • In the Guardian app, tap the Menu button at the bottom right, then go to Settings (the gear icon), then Notifications.
  • Turn on sport notifications.

Test match cricket has always had larghissimo passages, languors are a part of its charm, but their appeal seems to be lost on Stokes. For anyone who has been watching England this past year, Australia’s idling tempo felt very unfamiliar, as if, oh yes, I remember, this is the way the game’s usually played. You doubt, somehow, that Stokes has spent too much time following what’s going on here at the Oval while he’s been away in Scotland this week, but it was easy to imagine what he would have made if he had been watching. Not much. He would have damned the lack of intent.

England are so impatient that he’s declared in the first innings four times in 14 Tests now, never mind the second. Australia batted 84.3 overs here. England haven’t spent that long at the crease in the third innings of a Test since Stokes took over. Which isn’t to say he has got it right, or that Cummins has either, just that if you play for one of them you’re a lot more likely to enjoy the fifth day off than if you do the other. If the Ashes were being settled on the golf course you’d think England would win just because of all the extra practice they’ve been getting.

But on the cricket pitch, who knows? Stokes’s England are certainly going to leave Australia plenty of time to work in, and you can bet Australia’s batsmen will look to use every last bit of it. They are a team that spent two days making 480 when they played India in Ahmedabad in March, and in the deciding game of a series they ended up losing. It will make for a sharp contrast in styles. I’d call it the tortoise and the hare, only I’m English, and we all know how that one played out.


Andy Bull at the Kia Oval

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Despite the fury, Cameron Green’s catch leaves no grounds for complaint | Geoff Lemon
Indian fans believed Shubman Gill was wrongly dismissed but the laws are clear – although that won’t stop the arguments

Geoff Lemon at the Kia Oval

10, Jun, 2023 @6:30 PM

Article image
Virat Kohli gives India a glimmer of hope after Australia set daunting target
Virat Kohli and Ajinkya Rahane steadied the ship for India after they were set a daunting target of 444 by Australia

Simon Burnton at the Kia Oval

10, Jun, 2023 @6:26 PM

Article image
Late bloomer Scott Boland primed to deliver Ashes impact for Australia
Scott Boland was largely unknown arriving on the international stage at the age of 32 for Australia but the late bloomer’s weapons can make Ashes impact

Geoff Lemon at the Kia Oval

11, Jun, 2023 @4:59 PM

Article image
Pat Cummins loses cool but not threat as Australia’s attack excels again | Geoff Lemon
Australian bowlers may have seen chances go down but the fact they produce so many is more significant

Geoff Lemon at the Kia Oval

09, Jun, 2023 @6:00 PM

Article image
Beware, England: Steve Smith looks like a batting immortal again | Geoff Lemon
The Australian’s dominant century in the World Test Championship final against India strikes an ominous note before the Ashes

Geoff Lemon at the Kia Oval

08, Jun, 2023 @5:52 PM

Article image
‘Ashes define eras’: Australia switch focus after easy India win in WTC final
Pat Cummins has said he is preparing for an ‘era-defining’ few weeks after leading Australia to victory in the World Test Championship final

Simon Burnton at the Kia Oval

11, Jun, 2023 @2:38 PM

Article image
Ashes to Ashes, rust to bust: England must find groove to remedy sloppy start | Tim de Lisle
Ben Stokes’s declaration on day one was a mistake but it was not a fatal one and a lack of match practice really undid England in the opening Ashes defeat

Tim de Lisle

24, Jun, 2023 @11:00 AM

Article image
Glorious English summer hustle has been an Ashes rush like no other | Geoff Lemon
As the light fades on my journey – from Lauren Filer on another plane to Stuart Broad’s Oval exit – joy at an epic series lingers

Geoff Lemon

06, Aug, 2023 @7:00 AM

Article image
Australia’s Head-start changes emphasis and puts India to the sword | Geoff Lemon
When Travis Head arrived at the Oval crease, his side were in a precarious position – now they will enter day two well in charge

Geoff Lemon at the Kia Oval

07, Jun, 2023 @6:36 PM

Article image
Labuschagne and Smith keep Australia in control of final after India fightback
Australia lead India by 296 runs with six second innings wickets intact after the third day of the World Test Championship at the Kia Oval

Simon Burnton at the Kia Oval

09, Jun, 2023 @5:51 PM