Josh Tongue shows England potential as Stuart Broad puts on masterclass | Simon Burnton

Twelve months after debating retirement, the bowler showed promise on the first day of his Test debut against Ireland

The sun came just before lunch, breaking the blanket of cloud which had looked so encouraging as England started the day. “We’re here to score runs, take wickets and win games – and we like to do all three as quickly as we can,” enthused Ben Stokes in the programme, and after winning the toss and taking the briefest glance at the concrete-grey slab that hung over the ground there seemed no doubt that his quickest route to victory lay through unleashing his bowlers to cause chaos with a new ball and a green-tinged pitch.

But England weren’t just here for that, given they had very deliberately decided not to select the team that would be most likely to take wickets and win the game as quickly as possible. A minor groin strain and an abundance of caution meant Jimmy Anderson would have no chance here to add to his 685 Test wickets, and the recent memory of an ankle problem was enough to rule out Ollie Robinson.

Chris Woakes, who has taken 27 wickets at an average of 11.33 in five previous games at Lord’s for his country, has no fitness difficulties and seemed pretty convinced as late as Wednesday afternoon that he would be making his first Test appearance in 14 months, was left out on the basis that, as Stokes explained, “everyone knows what he offers”.

No, England weren’t primarily here to score runs or take wickets. They were here to go through the motions, to hone their competitive edge with an eye on the Ashes, to ease Jonny Bairstow back into the team after injury and to assess the one member of the side who retained an air of mystery. Stokes chose to bowl and the stage was set: this would be Tongue’s test.

  • Download the Guardian app from the iOS App Store on iPhone or the Google Play store on Android by searching for 'The Guardian'.
  • If you already have the Guardian app, make sure you’re on the most recent version.
  • In the Guardian app, tap the Menu button at the bottom right, then go to Settings (the gear icon), then Notifications.
  • Turn on sport notifications.

Josh Tongue collected his cap from Anderson before play and the ball and a pat on the back from Stuart Broad as he prepared for his first over. Before he starts his run-up, his left hand reaches across his chest to deliver the ball to his right and then stays there as if held in a sling as he pounds his way towards the crease. He is, of course, familiar with slings, having endured two failed operations on his right shoulder, and 14 months out of the game, before a doctor suggested that Botox injections may alleviate the pressure on a trapped nerve that was causing near-constant pain. He is not the first person to be rejuvenated by Botox, but rarely can its effect have been more convincing. If he uses his time here to seek advice from Anderson, 15 years his senior, perhaps Tongue can offer some in return on how it feels to seriously consider retirement.

From the start and throughout Tongue’s pace was good, edging occasionally beyond 90mph, and his accuracy likewise. He started with a maiden, and then another. Just before lunch he came back with instructions to bowl short at James McCollum, allowing the captain to assess another facet of his game and the batter to repeatedly duck out of the way, and those appeared to remain his orders throughout the following session. This tactic never seemed the most likely method of taking wickets as quickly as possible, but then that wasn’t the point.

By mid-afternoon every bowler had a wicket but Tongue, and if there was no sign of desperation in the way he bowled perhaps there was in the way he appealed for lbw when another short ball glanced off Curtis Campher’s helmet and deflected to Bairstow. Stokes had already burned two reviews, including one when an excellent delivery from Tongue forced McCollum into awkward evasive action and flicked what turned out to be a pocket on its way through. As the players huddled to consider another, the captain was notably absent, Stokes timing his arrival for the moment the DRS timer ticked to zero and providing once there only consolation.

Stuart Broad celebrates getting the wicket of McCollum caught by Root at 1st slip during day one of the England v Ireland 1st test match at Lords Cricket Ground.
Stuart Broad celebrated a 20th five-wicket haul in Tests for England against Ireland. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The Guardian

Tongue bowled only three more overs, and not at all after tea. So there was no moment of celebration and vindication to crown Tongue’s first day as a Test cricketer, but plenty of positives to take from it (particularly for the old family friend who collected £50,000 courtesy of a bet he placed back in 2009 that the then 11-year-old would one day represent his country). A player who 12 months ago was considering his career in the past tense is now one for the future.

But in the end it was Broad, courtesy of a 20th five-wicket haul in Tests, who stood out. He did so as he took the field, the only player wearing a bright white wide-brimmed hat while all around him chose caps, and he did so as he departed, when he was the one holding the ball in the air while all around him applauded. Perhaps everyone knows what he offers, but sometimes the same old answers are also the right ones.


Simon Burnton at Lord’s

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Uncapped Josh Tongue joins England Test squad to face Ireland
Josh Tongue, the uncapped Worcestershire seamer who dismissed Australia’s Steve Smith at the start of the month, has been added to the England Test squad to face Ireland next week

Ali Martin

24, May, 2023 @2:36 PM

Article image
Josh Tongue to make England Test debut against Ireland at Lord’s
Josh Tongue has been parachuted into the England team for the first Test of the summer against Ireland starting on Thursday

Simon Burnton

30, May, 2023 @5:30 PM

Article image
Broad’s five-wicket haul puts England in commanding position against Ireland
England ended the first day of the one-off Test against Ireland at Lord’s on 152-1, 20 runs behind the visitors who were all out for 172

Ali Martin at Lord’s

01, Jun, 2023 @6:20 PM

Article image
‘Big tick’: Broad happy after England’s bowlers make short work of Ireland
Stuart Broad hailed the mindset of England’s bowling attack after they dismissed Ireland for 172 on the first day of the Test match at Lord’s

Simon Burnton at Lord’s

01, Jun, 2023 @8:03 PM

Article image
Ireland fans few in number but big on enthusiasm despite team’s struggles | Emma John
A Thursday start means this Test has seen fewer supporters in green than hoped, but those who were at Lord’s did not flag

Emma John at Lord's

02, Jun, 2023 @6:46 PM

Article image
McCollum’s lack of first-class cricket highlights Lord’s challenge for Ireland | Andy Bull
The dearth of longer-format matches in the visitors’ playing schedule means they are being set up to fail on the Test match stage

Andy Bull at Lord’s

01, Jun, 2023 @7:00 PM

Article image
Josh Tongue defends England in face of Kevin Pietersen’s ‘shambolic’ jibe
Josh Tongue said England were unlucky on the opening day of the second Ashes Test after Kevin Pietersen described their display as ‘absolutely shambolic’

Simon Burnton at Lord's

28, Jun, 2023 @7:53 PM

Article image
Ben Duckett looking to nudge England selectors with World Cup looming
Ben Duckett, who is vice-captain in the ODI against Ireland at Trent Bridge, said he is excited by the idea of a possible central contract and ‘more England cricket’

Ali Martin

22, Sep, 2023 @3:08 PM

Article image
Stuart Broad arranges farewell Test to his liking as bandana bows out | Andy Bull
The England quick wanted one last shot at Australia so he created a new delivery and got inside David Warner’s head for all time

Andy Bull at the Kia Oval

30, Jul, 2023 @5:32 PM

Article image
Ireland stun England at T20 World Cup to throw Super 12 group wide open
Ireland triumphed over England at the T20 World Cup, with Andy Balbirnie’s 62 from 47 balls crucial before rain ended the contest

Simon Burnton at the Melbourne Cricket Ground

26, Oct, 2022 @8:17 AM