Golf can begin to heal wounds by bringing Henrik Stenson back as Ryder Cup captain | Ewan Murray

Swede’s reappointment for 2025 would offer proof of compromise as LIV joins forces with the DP World and PGA Tours

The only current certainty in elite golf is uncertainty. A month has passed since confirmation that Saudi Arabia’s Public Investment Fund has joined forces with the PGA and DP World Tours to promote peace on the fairways but nobody apparently has a clue about details for the future. The situation is so stark that golfers who prefer root canal treatment to media duties are suddenly stopping journalists to elicit information about how this all unfolds. This is a wonderful mess.

LIV and its much-maligned rebels have understandably seized upon the vacuum. Full steam ahead is the unrelenting message from this tour. It would be an exaggeration to suggest LIV golfers are crowing about the legitimacy afforded to their circuit by the mainstream tour alliance but smiles are barely masked. When Lee Westwood and Ian Poulter went on the front foot against the leadership of the PGA and DP World Tours on Wednesday, it was from a position of strength rather than nervousness. Nobody can really take the proclamations of golf administrators seriously any more, such has been the U-turn on all things PIF.

Next week will see representatives from the PGA Tour stand before a Senate committee in Washington. There, one assumes, they will attempt to explain why making a commercial agreement with a foreign entity of dubious human rights association, which they worked so hard to disparage and disrupt, makes perfect sense for corporate America.

Legal paperwork filed recently in Florida has emphasised the strength of the PGA Tour’s 2022 position, including, in their briefing notes, a certain Tiger Woods. He was due to press home to his fellow professionals why huge LIV offers should be rebuffed. PGA Tour loyalty was essential. “Do what I did: tell the Saudis to go fuck themselves. And mean it,” was among acerbic bullet points for Woods to convey.

Suitably embarrassed – presumably including the notion anybody could tell him what to do – Woods took the rare step of speaking out on social media when this paper circulated. “I have never seen this document until today,” said the 15-time major winner. “I did not attend the players’ meeting for which it was prepared.” Which is just as well. One of the world’s most famous sportsmen would otherwise be caught in the midst of an international incident.

As the PGA Tour plays verbal tennis with senators, the DP World Tour will be staging one of its marquee events. Close calendar proximity to the Open Championship helps the Scottish Open command a strong field. Rory McIlroy, Scottie Scheffler, Viktor Hovland, Justin Thomas and Jordan Spieth are among those who will tee up in East Lothian. The same court documents shone a light on the European Tour Group, which was branded a “borderline distressed asset” during analysis by the PGA Tour in 2022. Keith Pelley, the European Tour Group’s (ETG) chief executive, surely has a duty to respond to the scathing critique while focus is on one of his tournaments.

Henrik Stenson playing on the LIV tour at Valderrama this month
Henrik Stenson playing on the LIV tour at Valderrama this month. Photograph: Octávio Passos/Getty Images

There is no guidebook for the kind of saga mainstream tours and their executives found themselves embroiled in as the Saudis waded into this sport. Desperately trying to cling on to what was already theirs can be defended. The ETG was a viable enough entity for the Saudis to pursue their golf objectives with them. The PGA Tour was bizarrely eyeing a merger with a company it seemed to have little regard for. Their attention may have been better served closer to home, given the ridiculous prize-fund commitments undermined by costly litigation and the subsequent shaking of hands with the PIF. Westwood, Poulter and others took a monumental gamble; which has paid off but carried huge risk. Golfers are wise not to gloat.

On 6 June, Pelley was among those to herald a great day for golf. For that to be true, previously jilted tours have to swallow some pride. Pelley can control one easy fix. The ongoing success of the Ryder Cup was, by its own admission, the key reason the PGA Tour had designs on its equivalent in Europe, the ETG. The fact the biennial meeting of Europe and the United States was dragged into golf’s civil war – who can be picked, who cannot be picked, who can be a captain, who cannot be a captain – has never felt satisfactory. Punters flock to Ryder Cups to support a cause, not a tour.

Henrik Stenson was stripped of 2023 European captaincy duties after signing for LIV. The Swede came across as optimistic with his belief he could combine LIV appearances with leading Europe in Rome this September.

Yet this was during febrile times, when lawsuits raged and relationships disintegrated. If we really are to accept golf is on the verge of coming together, if there is a genuine desire to meet on common ground, Stenson should be appointed, without challenge, to lead Europe in 2025.

It is such a blissfully obvious scenario, far removed from what corporate elements are flung into golf’s ecosystem. Ryder Cup Europe should already be plotting this move. Stenson sits apart from Poulter, Sergio García and Westwood in that he was already in position as a captain.

He was deemed worthy of the post. Cynically, the exodus to LIV by Ryder Cup icons left the continent desperately short of captaincy options. Moving away from individuals born in the UK or Ireland should always be encouraged. Since Bernhard Langer in 2004, only two captains have hailed from continental Europe.

Traditionalists within the DP World Tour setup will not like this notion, of course. Stenson, 47, resigned his membership as a means to avoid sanction for playing on LIV. This, however, is not a confrontational individual, nor one who would seem averse to playing at a sensible level in Europe in the future.

Stenson’s reinstatement would be a statement of sporting intent. It would offer proof of compromise and collective thinking. Without this, golf will rumble on in this state of unease and confusion until leaders offer proper insight into their proposed brave new world. You get the impression they haven’t come close to working that out for themselves yet.


Ewan Murray

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Koepka and Mickelson reignite Ryder Cup conversation for LIV rebels | Ewan Murray
Makeup of the United States Ryder Cup team remains a thorny issue with notable performances from interlopers at Augusta National

Ewan Murray

11, Apr, 2023 @2:34 PM

Article image
LIV Golf risks becoming an irrelevance in Saudi sportswashing portfolio | Ewan Murray
Rebel tour has lost momentum heading into 2023 leaving those tempted by the riches promised facing an uncertain future

Ewan Murray

02, Jan, 2023 @7:00 PM

Article image
‘He will win a lot more’: Brooks Koepka can rival greats for majors, says coach
Brooks Koepka’s US PGA victory means he has five majors and his coach, Pete Cowen, thinks the American can win another four

Ewan Murray at Oak Hill

22, May, 2023 @1:53 PM

Article image
Sport’s most memorable moments of 2022 – No 3: Golf
From US Open glory for Matt Fitzpatrick to Tiger’s emotional farewell to St Andrew’s via a Ko masterclass and LIV fireworks

Ewan Murray

28, Dec, 2022 @2:15 PM

Article image
Henrik Stenson dedicates Open victory to late friend Mike Gerbich
Henrik Stenson said becoming Open champion was made sweeter by beating a competitor like Phil Mickelson as the Swede did with a record-equalling last major round of 63

Ewan Murray at Royal Troon

17, Jul, 2016 @7:59 PM

Article image
Phil Mickelson marches on with Henrik Stenson hot on his heels
Phil Mickelson has a one-shot lead over Henrik Stenson after the second day of the 2016 Open Championship at Royal Troon

Ewan Murray at Royal Troon

15, Jul, 2016 @6:14 PM

Article image
‘There needs to be changes’: Ian Poulter takes aim at golf authorities
Lee Westwood has criticised ‘hypocrites’ over LIV Golf while Ian Poulter remains hopeful of being Ryder Cup captain in future

Ewan Murray at the Centurion Club

05, Jul, 2023 @2:49 PM

Article image
Sky Sports yet to agree deal for US Open golf as broadcast talks hit stalemate
Sky have yet to agree a deal after the initial proposal from the USGA was turned down

Ewan Murray at Augusta National

03, Apr, 2023 @2:22 PM

Article image
Europe’s Ryder Cup plans in turmoil with Henrik Stenson set to join LIV tour
The split in golf will widen significantly on Wednesday with the expected confirmation that Henrik Stenson will not captain Europe in the Ryder Cup next year

Ewan Murray

19, Jul, 2022 @6:27 PM

Article image
Augusta’s LIV decision shows the Masters is looking out for itself | Ewan Murray
The true feelings of those in charge at Augusta remain hard to read but one thing is clear – locking out players is not good for business

Ewan Murray

22, Dec, 2022 @8:00 AM