Marcus Smith keeps his cool in molten heat of classic to be England hero | Andy Bull

With the Twickenham crowd screaming at the end of a helter-skelter game, the England fly-half was the calmest man around to slot the match-winning penalty

And Eddie said it wasn’t about revenge. You could have fooled me in the final hectic moments of this helter-skelter game, when all the Twickenham crowd was up on its feet and screaming, while the players down below set about each other, pushing and shoving in the rush of blood, everyone desperate to stake their claim on the game. There were two points in it then, and less than a minute left to play. And from the middle of all this chaos, out stepped Marcus Smith, to line up the match-winning kick. It was only 25 metres or so out, but these were, without doubt, the highest stakes he’s played for yet.

Watching on from the sidelines, Jonny Hill turned to Courtney Lawes and said “imagine taking this kick”. Away behind Smith, Freddie Steward was muttering to himself “please don’t miss, please don’t miss.”

Smith didn’t even seem to think twice. Of course, he made it. Even then, South Africa weren’t done fighting. Referee Andrew Brace had to bring in the TMO to rule on one last England penalty after the restart, after Eben Etzebeth clattered into Steward as he made a catch. And again everyone swarmed around Brace, fighting over his decision. Lawes, who had already been replaced, even came charging on to the pitch himself, and had to be pulled away again by Hill, who chased after him. Lawes said afterwards that he had got overexcited because he thought the game was over already.

When Brace finally blew his whistle again, the South Africans charged Smith, who had to whip quickly around on his heels and boot the ball backwards into touch. I’m not sure Twickenham has ever sounded as loud as it did in those final moments.

God, but it was a hell of a game, a reminder of everything you love about Test rugby. It was one of England’s best wins since Jones took charge in 2016, all the better because it looked, for so long, like they were bound to lose. Me, I thought they’d blown it when there were five minutes left, and they were trailing by two points. They won a penalty after Siya Kolisi took out Joe Marchant in the air. It was in goal-kicking distance, a metre or so inside South Africa’s half, but they decided to kick to touch instead. They had only just scored a brilliant try off a lineout, so you could understand why, but this time Etzebeth stole the ball, and the chance was gone.

Raffi Quirke dives in to score England’s third try during their 27-26 victory against South Africa at Twickenham.
Raffi Quirke dives in to score England’s third try during their 27-26 victory against South Africa at Twickenham. Photograph: Dan Mullan/The RFU Collection/Getty Images

South Africa had dominated the second half. England had the edge in the scrums in the first 40 minutes, when their rookie front row won all four. They were awarded three penalties off them, and scored tries off the back of two. But South Africa readjusted at half time and the game had changed. They won three scrum penalties in a row, two against Kyle Sinckler, and another against Will Stuart, who were both penalised for standing up, buckling under the intolerable pressure. The second of them led to a lineout, which South Africa turned into a rolling maul that rumbled 10m, then 20m downfield into England’s 22. Desperate, they conceded another penalty for collapsing the maul.

So, South Africa mauled again. And this time came right up to England’s try line. It became a game of inches, a pile of mad thrashing bodies in a heap, the ball lost somewhere in the thick of it, till it emerged, somehow, in the arms of Max Malins, flat on his back, and beaming a brilliant smile. Those are the moments, down there in the dirt, fighting to hold the line, that tell you so much about the character of a team. England didn’t win the match then, but they would have lost it if they’d given in. “The only reason we won that game is we were fighting for each other,” Lawes said afterwards.

The Breakdown: sign up and get our weekly rugby union email.

South Africa had to settle for a penalty. That made it a one-point game, 18-17. And then England scored that try. It was a brilliant one, against the run of play. They went short at a lineout in midfield, Raffi Quirke slipped the ball to Henry Slade, who snapped it on to Marchant while Smith ran a dummy loop around the back that wrongfooted the defenders lining up in front of them. Marchant beat Lukhanyo Am with a step, and set off downfield. Quirke, razor quick, was right there alongside him on his inside shoulder to take the final pass. It was a lethal bit of finishing. But it brought them only a minute’s grace. South Africa scored off what felt like the very next play, and it was back to being a one-point game again. Then South Africa kicked the penalty to go two points ahead, and set up those final minutes.

Jones said there’s a lot left to work on. They conceded 18 penalties. In Test rugby, teams aim to keep their total in single figures but England’s indiscipline has been a running theme this year and unless they fix it, it is going to cost them sooner rather than later. But Jones, a relentless taskmaster, wouldn’t have it any other way. He wants them ready for 2023, and there are, undoubtedly, the makings of a very special team here.


Andy Bull at Twickenham

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Eddie Jones warns England hero Marcus Smith to avoid ‘poison’ from media
England’s Eddie Jones implored Marcus Smith to avoid listening to media ‘poison’ after the fly-half’s winning kick against South Africa

Gerard Meagher at Twickenham

20, Nov, 2021 @8:13 PM

Article image
South Africa’s thin confidence popped by farcical Charlie Chaplin try for England | Michael Aylwin
The Springboks came to bully England but the scars inflicted by All Blacks thrashing were brutally exposed by a moment of slapstick at Twickenham

Michael Aylwin at Twickenham

12, Nov, 2016 @7:38 PM

Article image
Leader Owen Farrell the foundation of Eddie Jones’s new-look England | Andy Bull
Eddie Jones’s England look increasingly like their co-captain Owen Farrell’s side as Saracens fly-half’s work-rate and fortitude proved key against South Africa

Andy Bull at Twickenham

04, Nov, 2018 @8:00 AM

Article image
Malcolm Marx comedy of errors undoes South Africa against England | Robert Kitson
South Africa proved to be their own worst enemy as they made a series of errors in their 12-11 loss to England

Robert Kitson at Twickenham

03, Nov, 2018 @6:05 PM

Article image
South Africa fail to turn clock back to Yokohama in England defeat | Daniel Gallan
The Springboks fought hard but were unable to dominate the contest in the way they did two years ago in the World Cup final

Daniel Gallan at Twickenham

20, Nov, 2021 @7:26 PM

Article image
Assured Marcus Smith moves another step towards England’s driving seat
New recruit looked comfortable in his third international and may turn out to be the perfect foil for Owen Farrell

Andy Bull at Twickenham

13, Nov, 2021 @9:45 PM

Article image
Eddie Jones uses Ali inspiration to outfox lumbering South Africa | Andy Bull
Head coach draws on Rumble in the Jungle tactics to ease England to long overdue victory against the Springboks and extend his winning run to 10 games

Andy Bull at Twickenham

12, Nov, 2016 @7:40 PM

Article image
Stuart Lancaster has much to worry about as England regress
Andy Bull: South Africa returned to winning ways with a 31-28 win in at Twickenham in a game that highlighted the lack of intelligence and control in England’s backline

Andy Bull at Twickenham

15, Nov, 2014 @7:08 PM

Article image
England 27-26 South Africa: autumn international player ratings
Henry Slade produced a man-of-the-match performance but it was a tough afternoon for Jonny May

Gerard Meagher at Twickenham

20, Nov, 2021 @6:24 PM

Article image
Owen Farrell’s kicks and hits help England overcome South Africa
Against all the odds England beat South Africa 12-11 thanks to four penalties and backs-to-the-wall defending against the world’s biggest pack

Paul Rees at Twickenham

03, Nov, 2018 @5:29 PM