Boycott questions over Beijing Winter Olympics raise eerie echoes of 1936 | Sean Ingle

China’s treatment of Uighurs has been deemed by Canada as genocide. Are we about to legitimise the regime responsible?

History doesn’t repeat itself, but it often rhymes. I am staring at two bundles of newspaper clippings – one present day, one past – and feeling a deepening chill. The first pile details China’s treatment of the Uighur Muslim population in Xinjiang, where more than a million people have been “re-educated” in camps, as well as the calls for the 2022 Winter Olympics to be stripped from Beijing. The second is from the Manchester Guardian in 1935, recording the abuse of Jews in Germany and demanding a boycott of the Berlin Games. The echoes are eerie. The looming question, then as now, is what the world should do.

The similarities don’t end there. In 1931, when Germany was awarded the Olympics, it was a republic. But when the Nazis seized power and began interning Jews two years later, the International Olympic Committee refused to shout too loudly for fear of irritating its hosts. A similar playbook has been employed since the China Cables detailed the horrific mistreatment of the Uighurs in November 2019. The IOC told me recently that it “must remain neutral on all global issues” but insisted that “we received assurances that the principles of the Olympic charter will be respected in the context of the Games”.

But amid reports of large numbers of women being subject to forced sterilisation – and 13 tonnes of human hair suspected to have been shaved from women and sold as extensions abroad – others are not so sedate. Last week the Canadian parliament voted 266-0 to declare it as genocide – with lawmakers also calling on the IOC to move the 2022 Games from Beijing “if the Chinese government continues this genocide”.

So how should we react? In the build-up to the Berlin Olympics, the Manchester Guardian had no doubts. In a powerful editorial it called on Britain to boycott the Games since “the Nazis have injected the political poison of antisemitism into the principle of human equality upon which the Games have been based and without which they are spiritually dead”.

That editorial followed a series of missives from the paper’s athletics correspondent, who reminded readers that those Jews “who have not escaped into exile have lived a life of anxiety, poverty and persecution”. It must not be forgotten, he added, “that the Nazi philosophy is essentially hostile to the Olympic ideal”.

When threats of a US and British boycott began to increase, the IOC sent one of its members, Charles Hitchcock Sherrill, to Germany to investigate. He was hardly an impartial choice: two years earlier he had praised Hitler as the strongest man in Europe. Unsurprisingly Sherrill gave the Berlin regime a clean bill of health, saying the treatment of Jews in Germany was as “little his business as the lynching of negroes in the American south”.

He did, though, eke one concession: the Jewish fencer Helen Mayer, who had been in exile in the US for four years, was allowed to compete for Germany. It was enough to blunt the calls for a boycott.

But the Guardian’s man on the ground was clear that the IOC had largely fallen in line. While crediting the IOC president Count Henri de Baillet-Latour for getting two Jewish members of the organising committee reinstated in the early days of the Nazi regime, he added: “Since then the IOC has done nothing; it takes cover behind the undertakings given to it by Germany … and ignores the plain fact they have been broken.”

Spectators in the Olympic stadium during a victory ceremony at the 1936 Games.
Spectators in the Olympic stadium during a victory ceremony at the 1936 Games. Photograph: Ullstein Bild/via Getty Images

Yet I remain unconvinced that boycotts work. Remember Moscow 1980? And, indeed, Los Angeles. It also seems painfully unfair that athletes should suffer – and sport become a proxy battleground – while western countries are hailing billions of pounds in bilateral trade with China and the rest of us are enjoying our iPhones.

One solution would be to avoid awarding Olympic Games to countries with terrible human rights records. And China is also ranked 177th in the world press freedom index – below only Eritrea, Turkmenistan and North Korea. Then again, the IOC has form – and not just with Sochi in 2014. In 1974, the Americans were awarded the Winter Games in Lake Placid while the smell of its napalm and cluster bombs in Vietnam, Laos and Cambodia was still fresh.

Incidentally, while rummaging through the archives I also found two letters from Philip Noel-Baker, the only person to win both an Olympic medal and a Nobel prize. The first, written in 1935, supported a boycott of the Berlin Games, warning that while it would be a grave matter to abandon them at this late stage, “it would be a far graver matter” to take part.

However 45 years on, Baker had changed his mind. “Some have argued that Hitler’s presence in the stadium greatly increased his power over the German people and his prestige in the world,” he wrote. “But his power was absolute already.

Sign up to The Recap, our weekly email of editors’ picks.

“The message of the Games was that the chosen competitors of all the nations were one great happy family, inspired by the same bounds of sportsmanship, bound by common ties of common interest and friendship. The message made Nazi doctrine and Nazi practice abhorrent to anyone with eyes to see.”

Perhaps. Yet another image from Berlin also lingers in my mind. After the Olympic flame was extinguished, massive spotlights began to criss-cross 100m above the stadium. And then thousands of people stood up and began to bellow “Heil Hitler” and sing “Deutschland, Deutschland über alles”.


Sean Ingle

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Beijing and Almaty contest Winter Olympics in human rights nightmare
On Friday the IOC will award Beijing or Almaty the 2022 Games but with both bids prompting so many concerns the process should be restarted from scratch

Jules Boykoff

30, Jul, 2015 @10:39 AM

Article image
The Guardian view on the Tokyo Olympics: must the show go on?
With coronavirus surging in Japan and internationally, this summer’s Games are a risky prospect


12, Apr, 2021 @5:25 PM

Article image
EU votes for diplomats to boycott China Winter Olympics over rights abuses
Non-binding resolution also calls for governments to impose further sanctions on China as tensions rise

Helen Davidson in Taipei

09, Jul, 2021 @7:21 AM

Article image
Russia banned from Winter Olympics over state-sponsored doping
Russia has been banned from the 2018 Winter Olympics in Pyeongchang for an ‘institutional conspiracy’ to corrupt London 2012 and Sochi 2014, while the former sports minister Vitaly Mutko has been banned for life

Sean Ingle

05, Dec, 2017 @6:33 PM

Article image
Raab says UK boycott of Beijing Winter Olympics possible over Uighur abuses
Foreign secretary tells committee withdrawal not ruled out if evidence against China continues to mount

Patrick Wintour Diplomatic Editor

06, Oct, 2020 @5:12 PM

Article image
Sochi Winter Olympics will be safe from terrorism, says IOC president
The International Olympic Committee president, Thomas Bach, has said there are no regrets from the IOC over awarding the Winter Games to Sochi

Owen Gibson

27, Jan, 2014 @5:36 PM

Article image
Uighur campaigners to target 2022 Beijing Winter Olympics sponsors
Activists will write to companies in bid to persuade them to use their influence with Chinese government

Patrick Wintour Diplomatic editor

18, Jan, 2021 @6:00 AM

Article image
Holding 2022 Winter Olympics in Beijing is all about status, not snow | Richard Williams
The IOC is a willing accomplice by ignoring the environmental costs of making snow and building the necessary infrastructure for 2022 Winter Olympics

Richard Williams

07, Aug, 2015 @2:15 PM

Article image
IOC must decide which way to jump over Russia at the Olympics | Owen Gibson
A vast database of damning evidence should help root out more offenders but a new global anti-doping system is needed after the Rio Olympic Games

Owen Gibson

21, Jul, 2016 @1:48 PM

Article image
IOC under fire after ‘dismissing’ claims of genocide against Uighurs in China
The IOC faced fresh criticism from human rights groups who have accused it of hiding behind political neutrality to stage the Beijing Winter Olympics

Sean Ingle

12, Mar, 2021 @10:12 PM