Latest twist in Saracens salary cap scandal threatens a descent into pure farce | Robert Kitson

The Saracens salary cap scandal has already deeply damaged the domestic league - but it now appears the worst is yet to come for the club, its players, and the game as a whole

What a mess. Not only for Saracens, currently neck-deep in a reputational slurry pit of their own making, but for everyone involved. And, talking to those at the heart of the onrushing scandal, there remains plenty more to come. Ordeur, ordeur! Saracens playing in the Championship next season is barely the half of it.

Consider, for example, the collateral damage that has already been done to English league rugby. Now triple it. If Saracens really have been operating over the salary cap this season by as much as £2m – having already been fined £5.36m and deducted 35 league points for breaching the cap for the previous three seasons – the situation is truly farcical. Talk about bare-faced cheek as well as brazen cheques.

It is not much use sheltering behind the allegation, most loudly expressed on Twitter by their ex-director of rugby Brendan Venter, that others are at it too. Even if so does that totally exonerate Saracens’ flagrant breaches of the regulations? With each passing day it seems ever more incredible that the club initially considered appealing the original judgment.

Any wriggle room has slowly disappeared. Even Sarries seem to have recognised they are completely snookered, with no trick shot available to free them from their current predicament. Even getting rid of their top players – the Owen Farrells, the Maro Itojes - tomorrow was a non-starter. The salary cap “year” commences in July so half their sizeable wages have already been paid. Severance payments would also have to be included under the cap and barely any other English clubs would be able to afford them anyway if they wish to remain compliant.

What happened at Saracens yesterday in the salary cap fiasco?
Chief executive Ed Griffiths told the players that this season’s salary cap would be exceeded and the club will be deducted 35 points to add to the 35 taken off two months ago for cap breaches in the three previous seasons, leaving them on -42.

Does this mean they will be relegated?
They are all but down. They can finish on a maximum of 28 points, which may be enough if London Irish's form continues, but the next five matches are being played during the Six Nations and based on their average so far, Saracens would get to seven. 

Why can they not comply with the salary cap now?
No details were released of the hearing that fined them £5.36m and deducted 35 points. Reports say Saracens will be £2m over this year. Releasing players won't help because compensation counts in the cap, loan moves are all but out because other clubs have little room within the cap and wage cuts would have been massive. 

What happens to the players?
Saracens will take a financial hit in the Championship and face another fine, around £2m, unless they can bargain their way out of it having accepted the drop. With a Lions tour at the end of next season they may look to loan out players like  Owen Farrell and Maro Itoje, while Brad Barritt and Alex Lozowski are out of contract in the summer. Paul Rees

The ripple effect threatens to be considerable, both internationally and domestically. England are due to announce their Six Nations’ squad on Monday and commence their championship campaign against France in Paris in a fortnight. Farrell, Itoje, Jamie George, the Vunipolas, Elliot Daly ... they would not be human if their minds were not currently a whirl of personal and professional uncertainty, at the mercy of events beyond their control. Do they stay on a sharply-reduced salary? Do they move in order to remain a Premiership player? Might they have to flee abroad? Or might relegation, perversely, keep the guts of the squad together, with temporary loan deals easing the pain?

Even the RFU’s confirmation that Eddie Jones can, if necessary, select players from the Championship had a jagged edge to it. For a start it signalled that, at Twickenham, they are braced for the unthinkable. Even if all the players stay put, on sharply reduced wages, playing at Ampthill and Doncaster is not obviously great preparation for an autumn Test series. Might it also affect their chances of British and Irish Lions selection?

It gets worse. Relegation would mean they cannot feature in the European Champions’ Cup for the next two seasons. What does that do to their marketability? How can Farrell, as England captain, possibly juggle such an unenviable situation? How will the club’s sponsors react? Will the next generation of talented young players be remotely as keen to wear the club’s badge?

The future of Owen Farrell, the Saracens and England captain, is in doubt.
The future of Owen Farrell, the Saracens and England captain, is in doubt. Photograph: Tess Derry/PA Images

At the back of the players’ minds will also be another nagging thought: should they have seen some of this coming? Sure, it is not strictly their business how their club’s finances are handled. But did no one think to wonder, as they looked around the dressing-room with its legions of top internationals, how they could assemble and retain this calibre of squad while no one else was doing so? If not, perhaps they should have done.

Maybe the gleam of all that silverware – three European Cups in the last four years, four of the last five Premiership titles – dazzled everyone too much. Maybe they concluded, as Venter says, that everyone else was doing it. Any sense of complacency, either way has now evaporated, replaced by the cold, hard reality that their initial heavy punishment is no longer the end of it.

Serious questions also need to be asked about the continuing suppression of the original judgment. Even its author, Lord Dyson, cannot believe it has not been publicly released. It scarcely helps that there remains lingering bad feeling dating back to previous hushed-up Premiership salary cap breaches, after which a line in the sand was supposedly drawn. And why not? If, even this season, you have been losing to a team in breach of the regulations, it is going to sting. No wonder Premiership Rugby has belatedly tightened its stance: it simply cannot afford for a different club to be relegated in June, only for Saracens to be unmasked for breaking salary cap rules again.

The Breakdown: sign up for our weekly rugby union email.

Only in the last few weeks, since Griffiths’ return, has any real sense of mea culpa surfaced in north London. It is not going to be enough to save the club from an even heavier fall. For all their impressive academy conveyor belt and enlightened player management, their legacy is now tarnished. Has it left an indelible stain on the English league? Undoubtedly. The whole steaming mess threatens to stink out the Six Nations this year and, potentially, beyond.


Robert Kitson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Bristol owner says Saracens should have been punished sooner
The RFU insisted there are no plans to investigate Saracens after Bristol owner Steve Lansdown said they should have been relegated sooner

Robert Kitson

21, Jan, 2020 @5:20 PM

Article image
Saracens pick Mako Vunipola despite mandatory rest period agreement
Saracens have picked Mako Vunipola for Sunday’s game against Bath even though he is due a mandatory rest after playing for four straight weeks since the Six Nations

Gerard Meagher

13, Apr, 2018 @4:28 PM

Article image
Pirates' stellar win offers lessons for Eddie Jones and English rugby | Robert Kitson
The national coach says the Championship is ‘something I don’t really worry about’, but the state of a league that helps to shape tomorrow’s internationals should be a concern

Robert Kitson

09, Mar, 2021 @11:45 AM

Article image
Saracens lacking safety certificate to admit 10,000 or more fans to stadium
Saracens are not able to safely admit 10,000 or more supporters to their stadium because they do not have the necessary certificate, raising questions over the stringent criteria that govern promotion to the Premiership

Exclusive by Gerard Meagher

19, Oct, 2022 @6:52 PM

Article image
Saracens’ Mark McCall hits out at RFU after England training camp injuries
Mark McCall, the Saracens director of rugby, has hit out at the timing of this week’s England training camp in Brighton, at which two players have suffered long-term injuries

Paul Rees

06, Oct, 2016 @8:59 PM

Article image
Brendan Venter of Saracens faces RFU charge over referees outburst
The Rugby Football Union has charged the Saracens director of rugby with conduct prejudicial to the interests of the game

Paul Rees

06, Jan, 2010 @5:58 PM

Article image
Saracens turn focus on recapturing Premiership title from Exeter | Robert Kitson
This year there will be no distractions as the European champions attempt to regain the domestic crown from last season’s surprise package

Robert Kitson

07, May, 2018 @7:59 AM

Article image
Dyson report deal-by-deal: how Saracens breached the salary cap
The Dyson report into Saracens’ salary-cap misdemeanours is out, and here we detail how the primary overspends were made

Michael Aylwin

23, Jan, 2020 @7:13 PM

Article image
Guinness Premiership: Saracens 15-22 Leicester
The Saracens director of rugby criticised refereeing standards after his side suffered their second Premiership defeat in a row

Mike Averis at Vicarage Road

04, Jan, 2010 @12:10 AM

Article image
Saracens facing further investigation for potential breach of salary cap
Saracens will be further investigated by Premiership Rugby for a potential breach of salary cap regulations relating to the club’s co-investment arrangements with a number of their high-profile players.

Gerard Meagher

10, Apr, 2019 @10:03 PM