Put the smartphone down Aggers old chap. This spat really isn’t cricket | Barney Ronay

The BBC has reprimanded its cricket correspondent Jonathan Agnew after a foul-mouthed rant against journalist Jonathan Liew

Oh, stop it Aggers. The news that Jonathan Agnew MBE, the BBC’s voice of cricket, has been reprimanded by the corporation for repeatedly calling a journalist at the Independent “a cunt” might come as a bit of shock to those who follow Agnew’s sunny broadcast presence.

Everyone loves a high-profile tiff. But this isn’t really a tiff, just a bad judgment call on one side. Agnew has since apologised to Jonathan Liew after the abusive direct messages came to light.

I should declare an interest here. I know and like Liew, and feel dismayed on his behalf that he should receive a sustained and menacing screed of abuse from a senior figure in his industry. I also understand why Agnew was upset, as he believed that Liew was calling him a racist.

The abusive messages were a response to an article Liew had written in which he expressed concern about some of the language used in the media to describe Jofra Archer’s selection for England. Liew was writing about the notion of structural prejudice in the way we express ourselves, a shifting, gossamer thing that can often creep in unexpectedly but which can reinforce unhelpful tropes and stereotypes.

This was the passage towards the end that led to the BBC cricket correspondent’s foul-mouthed tirade, not to mention some unpleasant accompanying allusions to mental health problems.

Liew wrote: “‘A huge call,’ warned Jonathan Agnew. ‘Morale and camaraderie is a big part in team performance.’ Which feels instinctively unarguable – who doesn’t love morale and camaraderie, after all? – until you begin to ask why Archer is deemed such a grave threat to it.”

There was a comparison with Agnew’s warmer welcome for Gary Ballance, a white player of Zimbabwean origin. Further down, and summing up a lot of elements above, Liew wrote: “There’s an incendiary word you could posit to describe all this, but I’m not going to use it.”

This was the first response from Agnew: “Fucking disgraceful. You have massive chips on your shoulder ... you are a racist.”

Liew replied that this was not about name calling but a wider societal issue to do with “the huge privilege we enjoy in the media, the subtle and often unconscious biases that occasionally seep into our language … Happy to engage further on this topic if you are prepared to put your pantomime outrage to one side. If not apologies for the offence caused and I wish you well.”

What came next was an unanswered blurt of abusive fury.

Agnew: “You really have issues”

Agnew: “Apologise now”.

Agnew: “I’m going no further on the advice of people who know you and think you are a cunt. I know you are. Think on.”

Agnew: “CUNT”

Agnew: “You are so strange I don’t know if you’d be upset to know those who think you are a cunt”

Agnew: “If you think so in hindsight then you have a chance. If you don’t ...

Agnew: “I’m SO angry”

Agnew: “Book yourself in somewhere”

Agnew: “You need help”

Agnew: “Who the fuck are you?”

At the end of which, we probably all need help. What’s going on here exactly? I should point out that Liew is a waspish but well-liked journalist. The notes of the Cricket Writers’ Club meeting where Agnew raised his grievances in a written statement record the room bursting into laughter when Liew, who was late, walked in halfway through.

The other interest to declare here is that Agnew has done something similar but far less serious and bullying with me. Those who know him say Agnew is a very nice man, that he can just be thin-skinned. This is probably right. In my case Agnew was angered by an article in which I said I preferred TalkSport’s coverage and the Agnew-style voice could be a bar to cricket for some who found him slightly bumptious and Middle England.

In response he sent me a weirdly personal angry message. Later there was a strange email late at night referring to a listener interaction, and telling me “people like you” don’t realise how loved he is, how nice he is, what a beautiful person. In the course of which he took time to very lovably call me “a wanker”. Which is, you have to admit, quite funny.

At the time I suggested he should stop doing this kind of thing as it’s just a bad idea. He has a perfect right to take issue with people. I’m glad he cares enough. He will perhaps call me a cunt for writing this, and I defend his right to do so. Maybe he’s right!

I don’t think Jonathan Agnew is a racist. I don’t think Liew ever suggested he was one but read the messages to Liew and something else emerges. Not just the sense of a pattern of unpleasant behaviour but something wider too. Abusing younger journalists from a position of power is a damaging thing to do. Even more uncomfortable is the spectacle of one of English cricket’s most influential media figures abusing a young English journalist of Chinese heritage who has brought up an issue of race, who is trying to talk about nuance and about the way we use language.

Agnew can disagree with this or take it on board. He might say, I am angry about this, explain yourself. But if the response is just: you are a cunt, then he is clearly not getting this right.

Sign up for the Spin, our weekly cricket email.

Agnew has now resigned from the Cricket Writers’ Club; quite rightly given his abuse of another member. And even if Danny Baker got the boot this week for something far less deliberately vitriolic, the BBC has probably done the right thing in reprimanding him.

In the end this is a very minor bump in the road at the start of cricket’s big summer, something Agnew will be at the heart of. Perhaps as the sport tries to spread its wings a little it is a good moment to think about voices, about how we talk to others, and who we want to see doing that. This is something to learn from. And in the meantime, do put the sweary smartphone down my dear old thing.

Contributor

Barney Ronay

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
BBC’s five-year deal with the ECB is a win for cricket and its audiences | Roger Mosey
State broadcaster’s five-year deal to show more than 100 hours of live cricket each summer from 2020 is well merited and long overdue, according to a former director of BBC Sport

Roger Mosey

30, Jun, 2017 @2:35 PM

Article image
‘Say it ain’t so Steve’ – at least this scandal shows cricket still matters | Barney Ronay
While cricket’s ball-tampering furore will die down Steve Smith and his side have brought much of the fury on themselves by neglecting the values Australians attach to the game

Barney Ronay

26, Mar, 2018 @4:41 PM

Article image
Experimentation may be the only option in this stalled summer of English cricket | Vic Marks
Cricket fans only want good a scorecard to pore over but that seems far away, two weeks into what should be the new season

Vic Marks

23, Apr, 2020 @7:00 AM

Cricket: ECB chairman Giles Clarke has claimed that the BBC is letting down cricket
Giles Clarke, chairman of the ECB, has accused the BBC of failing cricket by not bidding for the television rights

Owen Gibson

18, Dec, 2008 @2:16 AM

Article image
The Spin | Isn’t it about time cricket consigned ‘chinaman’ to the past?
With the laws of the game now encompassing gender-neutral terminology, the banishing of a phrase coined in Yorkshire more than 90 years ago seems a little overdue

Andy Bull

28, Mar, 2017 @12:37 PM

Article image
The Anti-Sports Personality of the Year awards 2017
Before the BBC’s Sports Personality of the Year awards on Sunday celebrate the best of 2017, here are our anti-heroes from the sporting world this year

Simon Burnton

14, Dec, 2017 @11:00 AM

Article image
Cricket World Cup 2019: Guardian writers’ predictions
Victory for England, fireworks from Chris Gayle and a Sri Lankan meltdown: our pundits set out their forecasts for a month and a half of ODIs

Guardian sport

29, May, 2019 @9:55 AM

Article image
Joe Root’s omission from Spoty carries a health warning for English cricket | Barney Ronay
When the No1 Test batsman in the world proves invisible to the BBC it is time England took steps to engage with a terrestrial TV audience before it is too late

Barney Ronay

01, Dec, 2015 @4:59 PM

Article image
The Spin | A brief history of the Cricket World Cup
From its humble beginning in 1966, the tournament’s history is filled with English despair and southern hemisphere triumph

Simon Burnton

28, May, 2019 @11:16 AM

Article image
False allegations can match real corruption in damaging cricket | Andy Bull
Loose claims in an al-Jazeera documentary have bundled three separate claims of malpractice into one, with some of the information coming from a self-proclaimed crook

Andy Bull

29, May, 2018 @2:00 PM