Jordan Spieth must get past Rory McIlroy to make history at US PGA | Ewan Murray

The young Texan is looking to complete a full set of majors at Quail Hollow but the Northern Irishman could turn into party pooper for the home crowd

The enthralling conclusion to the Open Championship did not supply proof of Jordan Spieth’s ferocious competitive spirit . Events at Royal Birkdale last month merely served as a reminder. Though his technical ability is hardly irrelevant, Spieth’s psychological approach has played a massive part in pulling him to the brink of history: at this week’s US PGA Championship he can become the youngest golfer in history to complete a grand slam of majors.

“The pros and cons of it being so soon? Pros is you believe you’re in form,” says Spieth. “When you feel that way going in, it feels that much easier to get into contention. I’m not really finding any negatives in this. I’ve been asked this a few times and I mean it.

“This PGA … if I’m healthy and playing well, I play in 30 of them, I believe I’ll have plenty of chances to win. If it’s this year and it happens, that’s great, that’s another life-long goal achieved. But I believe that I’ll do it some day.”

Spieth’s approach draws recurring comparisons with players from the past, such as Gary Player, Jack Nicklaus, Tiger Woods et al, but also the present. Does the Spieth mentality set him apart from his peers? If Rory McIlroy, by general consensus the most gifted player of this generation, had the fortitude of Spieth, would his career have yielded more than already is the case?

When Spieth is in his zone, lady luck is his best friend. That is hardly an insult; the finest sportspeople of all time have also been the most fortunate. From the moment Spieth holed out from a bunker in the play-off at the Travelers Championship in June, ending a relatively low-key run of results, his Open Championship destiny looked set to the point of freakishness.

McIlroy is the natural cross-reference in this of all weeks. His grand slam wait dates back to his US PGA success in 2014, with only the Masters eluding the Northern Irishman. While this is hardly a disastrous scenario, bookmakers would not have offered odds on McIlroy sealing the clean sweep before Spieth as he departed Valhalla with what was a second Wanamaker Trophy. Spieth is four years McIlroy’s junior, for starters.

There is a popular perception, as offered again in recent weeks, that Spieth’s mind-set means he is destined to achieve more than McIlroy. Hard work beats talent when talent does not work hard. In reality this notion is unfair, though there are stark differences between the styles of these top golfers.

If McIlroy were soft, he would not have battled back from the horrible position of five over after six Open holes to finish fourth in the event. If McIlroy cared little for his professional legacy and was of a mind to let natural ability solve all conundrums, he would not have switched management firms and equipment so decisively. The 28-year-old’s ruthlessness was illustrated again last week, with confirmation that he had split from his long-time caddie, JP Fitzgerald. There is sufficient evidence from McIlroy’s professional and personal life to draw the conclusion that, when he feels something needs altering, it is duly done. McIlroy is an independent thinker, far more content to solve what puzzles golf throws at him alone than seek a range of external – even high-profile – opinion.

He and Spieth are markedly contrasting characters. Spieth has far more of an analytical mind than McIlroy. The Texan’s willingness to take holidays with fellow players – curiously, perhaps, given he must compete against them – demonstrates an attachment to golf that McIlroy will readily step away from. With McIlroy there is a recurring impression that conversation relating to anything apart from his work would be welcomed.

Inside the ropes, McIlroy may have been prone to lapses in concentration but the spirit epitomised at the last Ryder Cup or when securing the FedEx Cup in Atlanta last September is hardly the stuff of a timid heart. If his 2011 Augusta National capitulation is used against McIlroy, Spieth has far more recent experience of precisely the same.

For a reminder of what Quail Hollow, the venue for the forthcoming major, means to McIlroy, one need only step inside the lounge at his childhood playground of Holywood Golf Club. There an artwork of the North Carolina course hangs in depiction of his maiden PGA Tour success, in 2010. McIlroy sealed that victory with a stunning closing round of 62. He won at Quail Hollow again in 2015, this time by seven.

Spieth played in the Wells Fargo Championship at Quail Hollow four years ago, breaking 70 only once en route to a share of 32nd. The make-up of the course, whereby long and straight driving is heavily favoured, lends itself not only to McIlroy but Jason Day and Dustin Johnson more than Spieth.

The narrative, though, is set between two players. It will be until one of them creates history; and one of them inevitably will.


Ewan Murray

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Masters 2016: Jordan Spieth stands tall despite late slip as Rory McIlroy falters
Jordan Spieth holds a one-shot lead after the third round of the Masters on a day when his rivals were wounded by the heavily-armed Augusta National

Ewan Murray at Augusta National

10, Apr, 2016 @9:26 AM

Article image
Rory McIlroy can defy doubters at US PGA Championship
Rory McIlroy has recently come under fire but his form suggests he’s ready to defy the doubters at the US PGA Championship in Bellerive

Ewan Murray

04, Aug, 2018 @1:51 PM

Article image
Jordan Spieth still on top but course fights back and hurts champion at the last | Andy Bull
Augusta National was at its most unplayable and took its toll on everyone, even the defending champion and leader Jordan Spieth who dropped three shots over his last two holes

Andy Bull at Augusta

10, Apr, 2016 @12:10 AM

Article image
Rory McIlroy marches to WGC Match Play semis but Jordan Spieth goes out
Rory McIlroy was within sight of a WGC Match Play victory that would be perfect preparation for the Masters

Ewan Murray in Austin

26, Mar, 2016 @10:39 PM

Article image
Rory McIlroy remains in contention for US PGA behind leader Brooks Koepka
Rory McIlroy hit a third round 69 at Oak Hill to to stay in contention for the US PGA Championship

Ewan Murray at Oak Hill

20, May, 2023 @11:51 PM

Article image
Rory McIlroy takes lead at US PGA as Tiger Woods struggles with leg pain
Rory McIlroy shot a five-under 65 and said he was happy with ‘a great start’ while Lee Westwood was reported to have lost a sponsor because of his links to the new Saudi LIV golf

Ewan Murray at Southern Hills

19, May, 2022 @8:26 PM

Article image
Rory McIlroy happy to pose under-the-radar threat at Masters | Ewan Murray
The Northern Irishman has had a low-key 2016 but is confident his Augusta performances can continue to improve and retains a talent beyond most of his contemporaries

Ewan Murray

02, Apr, 2016 @8:00 PM

Article image
Rory McIlroy treads water trying to keep his Masters dream alive | Andy Bull
The Northern Irishman still attracts galleries at Augusta but has now adjusted his sights to a top-10 finish going into the final day

Andy Bull at Augusta

09, Apr, 2022 @10:53 PM

Article image
Jordan Spieth rambling his way towards golf’s elite clubhouse in record time | Scott Murray
The Texan is only 24 and may feel like he has run out of worlds to conquer if he completes the career slam on Sunday by winning the US PGA Championship

Scott Murray

07, Aug, 2017 @7:29 AM

Article image
Rory McIlroy takes long and winding Open road but needs leaders to falter | Michael Butler
Northern Irishman, in Beatles shoes, had plenty of chances during round three but failed to make the most of them

Michael Butler at Royal Liverpool

22, Jul, 2023 @7:43 PM