Punishing Lewis Hamilton for Abu Dhabi antics could end up hurting Mercedes

Fallen champion could have been more gracious to Nico Rosberg but should not be censured for his tactics on the track in F1’s absorbing climax

There was only one instance when Lewis Hamilton disappointed in Abu Dhabi as he lost his Formula One world championship to his Mercedes team-mate Nico Rosberg.

It was not when he slowed down to back Rosberg into the jaws of the Ferrari and the Red Bull that followed them. It was not even when he twice ignored rather optimistic team orders to pick up his pace.

Hamilton was at fault only in the race’s aftermath. On the podium and in the press conference, he was less than gracious to the man who had supplanted him, the driver who had dedicated his sporting life to this one moment – Rosberg, his once close friend.

So mealy-mouthed was Hamilton as he “congratulated” Rosberg that the title winner’s fellow German Sebastian Vettel had to step in and declare the Mercedes man a worthy champion.

Finally, and appropriately, the British driver looked a little embarrassed but he failed to display a champion’s style when it was most required.

For backing up Rosberg, as he took the slow road to his 53rd grand prix win, he should not be admonished. It is what not only more ruthless champions such as Ayrton Senna and Michael Schumacher would have done but also how most drivers would have reacted, especially when defending a title.

There are those who argue it would have been a nobler thing if Hamilton had sprinted into the distance, to have won the race by the biggest possible margin, to have proved once again he was the fastest and best driver in the world. That would also have shown he did not care that much about this world championship. He had won it three times, after all, and a fourth did not really bother him that much.

Hamilton cares a great deal. His natural talent disguises a fierce competitive spirit. He desperately wanted that fourth crown, and he showed everyone just how much on Sunday. There was nothing underhanded about his tactics – they were perfectly legitimate, as he attempted to deny Rosberg the top three finish he needed to guarantee the title. Unlike Rosberg, Hamilton has never been penalised for causing a collision.

As for Mercedes they have handled the situation well over the past four years and in particular since 2014 when the relationship between their drivers changed from friendship to bitter rivalry.

Following two crashes earlier this season, in Spain and Austria, the team set down strict terms of engagement, suggesting the drivers could be fined or banned if they broke the rules. With so much at stake, they should have left Hamilton alone and not instructed him to pick up his speed. As a senior paddock figure told me after the race, that can have only fed Hamilton’s paranoia that someone out there doesn’t want him to be champion.

Toto Wolff, the head of motorsport at Mercedes, argued they were worried they might lose the race. But although Vettel might have passed Rosberg for a second-placed finish – a move that would not have stopped Roseberg winning the title – he was never likely to take Hamilton to win the race.

The Red Bull team principal, Christian Horner, had a point when he said: “It was only ever going to be that kind of battle between the two of them. Hamilton won the race as slowly as he could. It’s like in a football game where the team might protect from the opposition by kicking the ball around and not enabling the opposition to get hold of the ball. I didn’t see that he did anything wrong.”

So what do Mercedes do now? If they are sensible, very little. When the sand has settled over Abu Dhabi it will be perfectly clear the team had another stupendously successful weekend, with another one-two result and the clinching of the drivers’ championship to add to the constructors’ title.

Hamilton is already licking his considerable wounds. Rubbing salt into them at this stage may not be the right thing to do if they are looking forward to an equally successful 2017.

But the difficulty is that Wolff has made something of a rod for his own back. He came out with some pretty strong stuff after the race, when he said about Hamilton: “Undermining a structure in public means you are putting yourself before the team. It is very simple. Anarchy does not work in any team and in any company. It is about finding a solution as to how to solve that in the future because a precedent has been set.”

Wolff said he would have to sleep on it before deciding what to do. Hamilton is likely to escape harsh punishment but after such strong words from the top man little or no action might be perceived as a sign of weakness.


Paul Weaver

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Lewis Hamilton escapes punishment by Mercedes after Abu Dhabi row
Mercedes’ team chief, Toto Wolff, admits they got things wrong in Abu Dhabi regarding Lewis Hamilton and say Fernando Alonso will not be replacing Nico Rosberg

Mark Dobson

09, Dec, 2016 @8:09 PM

Article image
Mercedes dismiss ‘lunatic’ conspiracy theories after Lewis Hamilton beaten
‘The last thing we would do is sabotage Lewis Hamilton,’ said Mercedes’ Toto Wolff while the British driver insisted he was ‘really proud’ of his F1 team despite mechanical problems

Giles Richards in Sochi

01, May, 2016 @7:55 PM

Article image
Lewis Hamilton and Toto Wolff reheat Mercedes partnership in kitchen
Lewis Hamilton says Mercedes are going to be the ‘strongest’ partnership as they make Valtteri Bottas their No1 target to replace Nico Rosberg

Mark Dobson

11, Dec, 2016 @10:49 PM

Article image
Lewis Hamilton holds fire on Mercedes’ decision to swap mechanics
The defending F1 champion has said he will reveal his true feelings in 10 years’ time about his mechanics being swapped with Nico Rosberg

Paul Weaver in Abu Dhabi

24, Nov, 2016 @5:36 PM

Article image
F1: Mercedes may suspend Lewis Hamilton for flouting team instructions
Lewis Hamilton defied Mercedes team orders to drive faster in Abu Dhabi Grand Prix in an attempt to scramble Nico Rosberg but Toto Wolff said: ‘Anarchy does not work in any team’

Paul Weaver in Abu Dhabi

27, Nov, 2016 @6:13 PM

Article image
Niki Lauda blames Lewis Hamilton for accident that costs Mercedes dear
Lewis Hamilton was blamed by Niki Lauda for the first-lap accident that put both the Briton and his Mercedes team-mate, Nico Rosberg, out of the Spanish Grand Prix

Paul Weaver in Barcelona

15, May, 2016 @7:16 PM

Article image
Jackie Stewart: Mercedes should fine Lewis Hamilton for crash with Rosberg
Mercedes should fine Lewis Hamilton for the first-lap collision that put him and his team-mate Nico Rosberg out of the Spanish Grand Prix, according to the three-time world champion Sir Jackie Stewart

Paul Weaver

16, May, 2016 @5:34 PM

Article image
Lewis Hamilton: Mercedes do not owe me despite 2015 Monaco miscalculation
F1’s reigning champion bears no grudges after a team error cost him victory in Monte Carlo last year and, despite other mishaps at the circuit, insists he has zero frustrations and no doubts about his ability

Paul Weaver in Monte Carlo

27, May, 2016 @8:59 PM

Article image
Lewis Hamilton blames ‘higher power’ not Mercedes for F1 engine failures
Any conspiracy theorist who felt Mercedes wanted Nico Rosberg, not Lewis Hamilton, to win the F1 drivers’ title was given plenty of ammunition by the world champion after Malaysian GP

Paul Weaver in Kuala Lumpur

02, Oct, 2016 @2:13 PM

Article image
Lewis Hamilton the rock star connects with his adoring fans | Giles Richards
Lewis Hamilton revelled in his moment after winning his third successive British Grand Prix as Silverstone was consumed by an outbreak of genuine emotion on both sides

Giles Richards at Silverstone

10, Jul, 2016 @5:20 PM