Rugby World Cup 2015: which hemisphere will rule the quarter-finals?

Can France repeat their Cardiff heroics of 2007? Will Argentina take advantage of a depleted Ireland? It’s the northern v southern hemisphere in the last eight

It has been a gripping World Cup so far, a compelling mix of antipodean skill and grit, Celtic heart and soul, Latin gusto, Asian pride and Anglo-Saxon dismay. This weekend’s quarter-finals will boil all those ingredients down to one time-honoured question: does the balance of union power reside in the northern or southern hemisphere?

The collective outcome of the four games – two in London, two in Cardiff – could settle that debate for the foreseeable future. This has already been a record-breaking tournament in terms of attendances, revenue and global interest. Might there be further twists in store?

South Africa v Wales

Saturday, 4pm, Twickenham

The mood in the South Africa camp has shifted dramatically since their opening-weekend defeat by Japan in Brighton. That jolt has given the Springboks precisely the reality check every ambitious team needs to prosper in a tournament of increasingly tight margins. Only Argentina scored more points in the pool stages than the supposedly long-in-the-tooth South Africans and the Japan result has clarified one or two of Heyneke Meyer’s selection posers.

Jean de Villiers’ injury withdrawal has deprived the Boks of their captain but simplified the midfield equation, while the influential Fourie du Preez will surely start at scrum-half.

Wales? It is becoming a case of mind over matter as Warren Gatland seeks to paper over the injury cracks behind the scrum. Liam Williams is the latest significant loss; how much more optimistic would Welsh supporters be if players such as Leigh Halfpenny, Jonathan Davies, Scott Williams, Rhys Webb and co were still standing? On the other hand there can be no disputing Wales’ spirit in adversity and the battle scars of Pool A will have hardened them up for what lies ahead. Stand firm defensively – and Shaun Edwards is a master motivator on these occasions – and a second successive World Cup semi-final is still attainable.

New Zealand v France

Saturday, 8pm, Cardiff

Dan Carter
Dan Carter and the All Blacks will be keen to eradicate memories of their 2007 quarter-final defeat to France – also in Cardiff – on Saturday. Photograph: Michael Mayhew/Sportsphoto/Allstar

The simple act of writing down the two teams and the venue brings memories of 2007 flooding back. It was at this same stage eight years ago that the All Blacks suffered their most painful defeat this century, stymied by a French side who preyed on their lack of composure when the pressure of knockout rugby began to bite. Could it possibly happen again?

Not on the evidence of France’s defeat by Ireland on the same ground on Sunday evening when Ireland gave a masterly demonstration of how to frustrate and ultimately outplay opponents with high hopes of topping Pool D. There is nothing lily-livered about the French pack, however, and the sight of a black jersey tends to rouse them. The question is whether they can score enough points to fluster the reigning world champions, who possess the consistent ability to score tries out of nothing. Defensively, too, the manner in which Robbie Henshaw and Rob Kearney outmanoeuvred Mathieu Bastareaud and Frédéric Michalak respectively on Sunday will not have escaped the notice of Steve Hansen. France also have a shorter turnaround and possess nothing like the individual craft of New Zealand’s back three. Then again we were saying similar things before Cardiff 2007.

Ireland v Argentina

Sunday, 1pm, Cardiff

The Pumas have been playing some of the best attacking rugby at this tournament without anyone paying them a great deal of attention.

Factor in Ireland’s injury problems and this fixture becomes even more fraught from a green-shirted perspective; Paul O’Connell and Peter O’Mahony will be hugely missed and a nation holds its breath regarding Johnny Sexton’s fitness and the outcome of the citing of Sean O’Brien. On the plus side Ian Madigan did a fine job after Sexton departed and Conor Murray remains the most astute scrum-half in the northern hemisphere.

Henshaw is rapidly emerging as a genuinely top-class centre and the Ireland coach, Joe Schmidt, continues to play a tactical blinder. France’s downfall was not dissimilar to Leinster’s European semi-final against Toulon last season, which the champions won only in extra-time; hold on tight at the scrum, get to Michalak and anything is possible.

Argentina, though, have an outstanding goal-kicker in Nicolas Sánchez and have an ominous track record when it comes to wrecking Irish World Cup campaigns. The Pumas have already rattled New Zealand at this tournament; given a bit of luck they will privately see no reason why they cannot go all the way to the final.

Australia v Scotland

Sunday, 4pm, Twickenham

Bernard Foley of Australia
Bernard Foley puts paid to England’s World Cup hopes at Twickenham, where he and Australia will hope to do the same to Scotland on Sunday. Photograph: Brendan Moran/Sportsfile/Corbis

Having beaten England and Wales on successive weekends, the Wallabies will fancy seeing off a Scotland side who were given a major scare by Samoa in Newcastle on Saturday. Australia will have Michael Hooper available again and the defensive commitment which allowed them to hold out against Wales with only 13 men will merely increase their belief they can now win big games in a variety of ways. The Scots, though, are steadily growing in confidence and Sean Lamont’s belief that this is “by far” his country’s strongest squad in over a decade is hard to dispute, despite their modest recent Six Nations record. “You can take us for granted all you want and you’ll get a bite on the arse,” said Lamont after the 36-33 thriller at St James’ Park. Australia have been forewarned but winning at Twickenham has not been a Scottish speciality down the years.


Robert Kitson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Rugby World Cup: Guardian writers’ predictions for the quarter-finals
Can Wales and Ireland overcome their injury problems and South Africa and Argentina respectively; will New Zealand brush aside previous thorn in their side France and will Scotland stun Michael Cheika’s Australia?

Robert Kitson, Eddie Butler, Paul Rees, Mike Averis, Michael Aylwin

16, Oct, 2015 @8:43 AM

Article image
Rugby World Cup 2015 power rankings: England plummet, Australia climb | Gerard Meagher
England slip five places after defeat to Wales but Wallabies move up to second, while New Zealand stay top and Ireland are upwardly mobile too

Gerard Meagher

02, Oct, 2015 @10:15 AM

Article image
Rugby World Cup 2015 power rankings: Ireland and Argentina climb | Gerard Meagher
The teams who meet in Cardiff on Sunday confirm their status as dark horses while Australia and the All Blacks remain unchanged at the top

Gerard Meagher

16, Oct, 2015 @10:10 AM

Article image
Rugby World Cup 2015: Europe remains poor neighbour in north-south divide | Andy Bull
Gap between northern and southern hemispheres wide as ever as Australia, South Africa and New Zealand are favourites against Scotland, Wales and France

Andy Bull

16, Oct, 2015 @4:18 PM

Article image
The Power List: the 10 sides to fear at Rugby World Cup 2015 | Robert Kitson
Robert Kitson: As the one-year countdown to the Rugby World Cup begins on Thursday, we present our lowdown on the state of the strongest-looking nations

Robert Kitson

17, Sep, 2014 @11:18 AM

Article image
Rugby World Cup 2015 power rankings: New Zealand on top at kick-off | Gerard Meagher
The All Blacks are a surprise early leader, whose greatest threat might be complacency. Australia and England are the sides most likely to challenge them but it looks nasty for Uruguay

Gerard Meagher

18, Sep, 2015 @9:25 AM

2007 France trauma will make New Zealand wary in World Cup quarter-final | Graham Henry
My team’s Cardiff defeat was hell and means Steve Hansen’s side will be aware of the pitfalls, while Wales must avoid dumb penalties against South Africa in Saturday’s other Rugby World Cup quarter-final

Graham Henry

16, Oct, 2015 @11:00 AM

Article image
Rugby World Cup 2015: talking points from the weekend’s action
Wales deserve a rest without recrimination, Scotland are capable of ending their Six Nations drought and New Zealand were simply a privilege to watch

Guardian sport

18, Oct, 2015 @11:29 PM

Article image
Rugby World Cup 2015 power rankings: France up to second, Boks plummet
All Blacks remain top despite vulnerability against Argentina, Les Bleus climb three places after two regulation wins and South Africa fall to ninth after shock loss to Japan

Gerard Meagher

25, Sep, 2015 @11:13 AM

Article image
How are the contenders shaping up for the 2011 Rugby World Cup? | Shaun Edwards
Shaun Edwards: With less than a year to go until New Zealand 2011, here's my take on the world's 10 best teams

Shaun Edwards

05, Nov, 2010 @12:05 AM