Vaughan’s lawyers accuse ECB of ‘woefully inadequate’ investigation

  • Former England captain’s counsel accuses ECB of ‘actual bias’
  • ECB team questions Vaughan’s credibility in closing comments

The England and Wales Cricket board conducted a “woefully inadequate investigation” into Michael Vaughan that displayed “actual bias” and was “an affront to fairness”, the final day of the Yorkshire racism hearing was told.

In his closing submission the former England captain’s legal counsel, Christopher Stoner KC, questioned why the ECB had initially withheld a statement from Ajmal Shahzad that backed Vaughan’s claims that he had never uttered the phrase “there are too many of you lot” to four Asian players before a Twenty20 game in 2009.

Stoner also raised concerns to the Cricket Discipline Commission that the ECB had not spoken to the umpires, cameramen or many of the players at the game before charging Vaughan.

“The investigation in this case was woefully inadequate,” he said. “Due process matters and it is the cornerstone of law. But in our submission it was sent on holiday by the ECB. It raises a real question of fairness, which Mr Vaughan has not been afforded.

“Given the nature of the allegation, the minimum requirement for any fair‑minded investigation was to speak to everyone involved. Instead there was a prosecution from the outset,” added Stoner, who said it amounted to “evidence of actual bias”.

Stoner also questioned why Vaughan would ever have used such a phrase when a Sky TV cameraman was next to the Yorkshire team’s huddle. “It is inherently improbable that such serious and unacceptable words were spoken to teammates just as a game was starting, in the presence of a cameraman and almost certainly a microphone,” he said. “And were then not spoken about for a period of 11 years between any of those involved.”

Concluding his case, Stoner told the panel that the case was of considerable importance to Vaughan, adding that “the shape of his life and livelihood are at stake”.

However Jane Mulcahy KC, counsel for the ECB, said Vaughan’s insistence that he had never heard the P-word during an era where Yorkshire have already admitted systemic racism raised doubts about his credibility.

“Matthew Hoggard had admitted to using the words ‘Paki’ and ‘token Black man’ and the phrase ‘you lot’,” she said. “While Gary Ballance had admitted to using a number of discriminatory words, including ‘Paki’ to Azeem Rafiq on numerous occasions.

“Mr Vaughan played in 35 games for Yorkshire in the 2008 and 2009 seasons, 17 of which he played with Mr Hoggard, yet claimed not to have heard any use of the word ‘Paki’. His response was simply not credible, and therefore undermines his credibility generally.”

Mulcahy also alleged that three tweets, sent by Vaughan in 2010 and 2017 which he has since admitted were unacceptable, were indicative of a general pattern. “If a person has a tendency to make racist comments, they have a tendency to make racist comments,” she said.

Mulcahy also told the hearing that Vaughan had been charged on “credible evidence” from Rafiq, corroborated by Adil Rashid and supported by Naved-ul-Hasan, adding there is “no suggestion they have lied or conspired together”. And she denied claims that the ECB had been biased, telling the hearing the claims were “very inappropriate”.

Vaughan is charged with a violation of ECB directive 3.3, related to improper conduct, along with five other players – Hoggard, Tim Bresnan, John Blain, Andrew Gale and Rich Pyrah – who have had charges heard against them in their absence. Tim O’Gorman, chair of the three‑person panel, told the court he hoped to announce a written verdict in the next three weeks.

“These are judgments that need careful consideration,” he said. “We hope to have them by the end of the month. However I hope you understand the panel has considerable professional commitments.”


Sean Ingle

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Alex Hales pictured in blackface as English cricket handed a new blow
English cricket has taken another blow after the Azeem Rafiq revelations with Alex Hales pictured in blackface at a New Year’s Eve party

Sean Ingle

19, Nov, 2021 @12:18 AM

Article image
Yorkshire CCC are institutionally racist. For me there is no other conclusion | Jonathan Liew
The investigation panel may not have found sufficient evidence of racism at the club, but how else can the Azeem Rafiq saga be viewed?

Jonathan Liew

01, Nov, 2021 @10:00 PM

Article image
Headingley allowed to host England matches after ECB lifts suspension
Yorkshire took an important step on the road to staging international matches again when the England and Wales Cricket Board lifted its Headingley suspension on Friday

Tony Paley and agencies

11, Feb, 2022 @3:48 PM

Article image
Tom Harrison calls racism scandal an ‘earthquake’ as ECB unveils action plan
ECB chief executive Tom Harrison has called cricket’s racism scandal the ‘shock’ that can accelerate change in the sport

Chris Stocks

26, Nov, 2021 @3:02 PM

Article image
Cricket has made a start in tackling discrimination – it must see it through | Chris Grant
Though it has shied away from admitting structural racism, English cricket has acknowledged the need for wholesale reform. It’s a start

Chris Grant

26, Nov, 2021 @8:00 PM

Article image
Vaughan rails at ECB after charge of racist language found unproven
The former England captain Michael Vaughan has been cleared of using racist and/or discriminatory language and bringing the game into disrepute by the ECB’s Cricket Discipline Commission

Simon Burnton

31, Mar, 2023 @5:02 PM

Article image
English cricket offers Azeem Rafiq apology and promises action on racism
English cricket issued an unreserved apology to Azeem Rafiq, saying the racism he experienced was a blight on the game

Sean Ingle

19, Nov, 2021 @6:44 PM

Article image
Cut English cricket’s funding over ‘deep-seated racism’, government urged
A parliamentary inquiry into racism in cricket recommends the government should cut the sport’s funding unless the ECB shows it is serious about tackling the matter

Sean Ingle and Simon Burnton

14, Jan, 2022 @12:01 AM

Article image
When it comes to racism in cricket, the ECB is the accused not the judge | Barney Ronay
The ECB does not get to act surprised at this week’s events, to dance away from responsibility – it has failed, repeatedly, to act

Barney Ronay

05, Nov, 2021 @8:30 PM

Article image
How 149 seconds of grainy footage made the case for Michael Vaughan
Over four days in a stuffy Fleet Street room, two and a half minutes of video was spliced and diced, with Michael Vaughan’s career on the line

Sean Ingle

01, Apr, 2023 @7:00 AM