Eddie Jones facing review amid RFU concern over England’s autumn results

  • RFU describes England’s campaign as ‘really disappointing’
  • Head coach to learn his fate within the next two weeks

Eddie Jones is poised to learn his fate as the England head coach in the next fortnight with the Rugby Football Union conducting a review into the “really disappointing” autumn campaign, stating that results have not been good enough.

Bill Sweeney, the RFU chief executive, will lead the review, holding a series of meetings with board and executive members as well as former players and coaches, whose participation is on the condition of anonymity, over the next two weeks and deciding whether to back Jones through to the 2023 World Cup or replace him with barely 10 months to go.

In a short statement on Sunday, the union expressed its dismay at an autumn campaign with just one win from four matches, and opted against giving its public backing to Jones.

Removing Jones at this stage is a nuclear option but while he was given the RFU’s full support after another torrid Six Nations campaign this year, the statement on Sunday was more circumspect with well‑placed sources pointing to a reluctance to pre‑empt the review. Sweeney is also under pressure to be proactive after he was accused of being “asleep on the job”, at parliamentary inquiry last week over the plights of Worcester and Wasps, with the World Cup‑winning coach Sir Clive Woodward expressing his dismay at the union’s leadership.

The wretched defeat against South Africa on Saturday ensured England finish 2022 with just five wins from 12 matches, bookending their worst run of results across a calendar year since 2008, with Jones braced for an “uncomfortable” review. He is likely to be grilled on his players’ discipline, the quality of his coaching staff and his leadership group, having emphasised the importance of those aspects during a presentation he gave to the RFU council shortly before the autumn campaign. Players may also give feedback amid reports of discontent in some quarters.

It is understood that at the beginning of the season the RFU’s target for the 2022-23 campaign was for Jones’s side to be ranked in the top two or three in the world. That in itself was a tempering of expectations – the previous year the goal was to be ranked first or second – but Jones’s side sit fifth and the gulf between England and the leading contenders for the World Cup has been laid bare throughout 2022.

Owen Farrell reflects on England’s defeat to South Africa
England set themselves the target of being in the top two or three in the world rankings in 2022-23 but have sunk to fifth. Photograph: Andrew Boyers/Action Images/Reuters

At full-time on Saturday a chorus of boos rang out at Twickenham and, though Jones said he did not hear it, Sweeney made pointed reference to the views of supporters.

“We would like to thank England fans for their patience and support, it matters to us how they feel,” Sweeney said. “Like them we are really disappointed with the results of the Autumn Nations Series. Despite strong individual performances and some great new talent coming into the team, the overall results are not where we expect them to be.”

Jones acknowledged the review will be painful but he remains convinced he has a plan in place for England to win the World Cup. “[Reviews] are always uncomfortable when you’re not winning,” Jones said.

“I haven’t found the review comfortable when you’re not winning. [Bill will] have his opinion, based on what you guys write, and I’ll have my opinion. And we’ll share it. We’ve always got a plan. I’ve got a plan for how England can win the World Cup, but it doesn’t go in a perfect line.”

Jones was due to hold meetings with all of his squad on Sunday and said he intends to largely stick by his current crop of players as well as a handful of those out injured such as Courtney Lawes. “This will be the base of [the squad],” he said. “And there’ll be other players to come back in when they’re fit and ready. We’ve picked everyone who we think are the best players, fit and ready, for this campaign, and we’ll do the same thing for the Six Nations, then we’ll do the same for the World Cup.”

After England’s two defeats this autumn, Jones has blamed individual errors, specific areas of the game or circumstances such as how his side begin campaigns slowly because, coming from so many different clubs, they lack the cohesion of their rivals. After South Africa’s victory Jones expressed his disapproval at how Angus Gardner refereed the scrum.

“I have grave concerns about how the scrum was refereed,” he said. “But that’s part of the deal isn’t it? You’ve got to live with that. One of the things I have learned about coaching is you have to find the major problem, and the major problem was the scrum.”


Gerard Meagher

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘We have to respect referees’: Jones teases Erasmus over officials criticism
With South Africa’s Rassie Erasmus banned from Saturday’s match by World Rugby, England’s Eddie Jones said: ‘The referee’s in charge, if he makes mistakes let’s accept it’

Gerard Meagher

24, Nov, 2022 @6:00 PM

Article image
Defeat by South Africa lays bare the deeper problems facing England | Robert Kitson
With a World Cup approaching Eddie Jones needs to arrest an alarming slide with six defeats and a draw from 12 Tests in 2022

Robert Kitson at Twickenham

27, Nov, 2022 @6:00 PM

Article image
Pressure mounts on England’s Eddie Jones to rediscover his touch | Robert Kitson
In the wake of the first Test defeat in South Africa, questions arise over the England coach’s selectorial touch and autocratic style

Robert Kitson in Johannesburg

11, Jun, 2018 @7:15 AM

Article image
‘Not good enough’: Eddie Jones says ‘silly’ mistakes cost England victory
The England coach said his players will hold ‘uncomfortable conversations’ this week after a shock 30-29 defeat by Argentina at Twickenham

Gerard Meagher at Twickenham

06, Nov, 2022 @7:05 PM

Article image
Eddie Jones adamant England are still ‘moving in the right direction’
The England head coach has accepted full responsibility for the 27-13 defeat to South Africa but insisted his team remain on course for the World Cup

Gerard Meagher at Twickenham

26, Nov, 2022 @9:47 PM

Article image
Eddie Jones rouses England to purge 2019 demons against Springboks
The World Cup final defeat in Japan still haunts England’s coach who has challenged his side to gain revenge at Twickenham

Robert Kitson

25, Nov, 2022 @6:00 PM

Article image
Eddie Jones given no guarantee he will be England’s World Cup coach
The Rugby Football Union declined to endorse Eddie Jones as England’s World Cup coach after his side beat South Africa in their final Test in South Africa to end a long losing run

Robert Kitson in Cape Town

24, Jun, 2018 @9:00 PM

Article image
Jones banking on Farrell to provide England authority amid uncertainty
With the international landscape more volatile than ever England’s head coach Eddie Jones is taking a calculated risk in building his leadership group

Gerard Meagher

05, Nov, 2022 @8:00 AM

Article image
From magician to misfit: where it all went wrong for Eddie Jones | Robert Kitson
The wizard from Oz’s early highs seem a long time ago, with staff worn down and stodgy rugby failing to appease fans

Robert Kitson

06, Dec, 2022 @6:00 PM

Article image
Borthwick set to be named England head coach after RFU sacks Eddie Jones
Steve Borthwick is expected to be confirmed as England head coach this week following the sacking of Eddie Jones, nine months before the 2023 Rugby World Cup

Robert Kitson

06, Dec, 2022 @11:30 AM