Pivac and Rennie feel the heat as Wales and Australia try to put out fires

Both sides have struggled during the autumn internationals and will need to bolster their walking wounded

The international window has closed, and most people have moved on. How Wales and Australia must feel they could join them. But, no, they must rouse themselves once more – in Australia’s case for a fifth weekend in a row – to satisfy the baying hordes of fans and corporate suits.

Both might feel the poor relations of their respective circles, all the more so in their battered and weakened states – and a cursory glance at their walking wounded and positions on the rankings ladder will supply ample reason for them to feel that way. Wales are coming off the fresh indignity of a home defeat to Georgia, while Australia were hardly any more enamoured of their first defeat to Italy in Florence the weekend before that.

It goes without saying, both sides have made changes, although Australia’s are to the side that lost with honour to Ireland last weekend. Their three-point defeat in Dublin was their heaviest of this tour, every other match on it having been decided by a single point. The first was their only win, against Scotland at Murrayfield, a week before that international window had creaked open, but since then they have lost to France, with honour, to Italy, with opprobrium, and to Ireland.

Wales have a win over Argentina in their credit column this autumn, albeit hardly inspiring, but their defeats by New Zealand (comprehensive) and Georgia (humiliating) put them firmly in the red, not only for November but the entire calendar year, in which they have won three of 11, taking in a defeat to Italy all of their own.

Inevitably, there are changes for both teams. Each coach is under pressure, each a New Zealander. Wayne Pivac and Dave Rennie have not quite sprinkled the magic of those far-off isles on these two, certainly if results are anything to go by. Both will claim the mitigation of works in progress.

Pivac’s case may be harder to argue, given he includes six players with 626 Wales caps between them, 200 more than Australia’s starting lineup. Alun Wyn Jones, Leigh Halfpenny and Taulupe Faletau are among six changes to the side that lost to Georgia, and they supply 345 of those caps between them.

Wayne Pivac presides over training
Wayne Pivac finds himself under intense scrutiny. Photograph: Ben Evans/Huw Evans/Shutterstock

On the work-in-progress front, though, Pivac awards a first cap to the 20-year-old Ospreys centre Joe Hawkins, who will line up alongside his club-mate Gareth Anscombe, another returnee to the side. Rio Dyer, the winger who scored on his debut against the All Blacks this month, is the sixth change. He is 22 and wins his second cap. Several of the players Pivac has used this autumn have returned to their English clubs, given the game’s status outside the window, including Louis Rees-Zammit and Nick Tompkins.

Rennie’s touring party, meanwhile, has been reduced to 25 fit players. Nic White returned to the field in Dublin under controversial circumstances, having suffered an evident brain injury, but he sits this out, alongside Michael Hooper and Dave Porecki, who are suffering from the same. Taniela Tupou, the mighty Tongan Thor, was felled in the same match by his own achilles. He will be out for seven months.

Wales Halfpenny; Cuthbert, North, Hawkins, Dyer; Anscombe, T Williams; Thomas, Owens, Lewis, Beard, AW Jones, Morgan, Tipuric (capt), Faletau

Replacements Elias, R Jones, Francis, Carter, Macleod, Hardy, Priestland, Adams

Australia Wright; Petaia, Ikitau, Hodge, Nawaqanitawase; Donaldson, Gordon; Slipper (capt), Fainga’a, Alaalatoa, Frost, Neville, Holloway, McReight, Gleeson

Replacements Lonergan, Robertson, Talakai, Hanigan, Samu, McDermott, Lolesio, Campbell

There are first starts in a Test for Ben Donaldson at fly-half and the wrecking ball at No 8, Langi Gleeson. They are among seven changes to the Wallabies. Jake Gordon replaces White to pair up with his Waratahs teammate at half-back, while Folau Fainga’a replaces Porecki, and Fraser McReight steps in for Hooper. Gleeson is a replacement for another casualty Rob Valetini, while further absentees are replaced by Reece Hodge at inside-centre and Jordan Petaia, who came on in the fourth minute last weekend, on the wing. Tom Wright switches to full-back.

It is hard to see which team has the most to gain – or rather the most not to lose. The losers will equal their record for most defeats in a calendar year. Australia are eighth and Wales ninth in the world rankings. If Italy continue their recent form, Wales would soon be in danger of becoming the lowest ranked team of the Six Nations. Otherwise, every other tier one nation is ahead of both of them. Well might Wales and Australia yearn for the creaking shut of that window.


Michael Aylwin

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Wayne Pivac defiant over future after Wales blow huge lead to lose again
Wayne Pivac remains defiant about his position as Wales coach after a dramatic match ended in a ninth defeat of the year

Michael Aylwin at the Principality Stadium

26, Nov, 2022 @7:00 PM

Article image
Australia overturn 21-point deficit to complete wild comeback over Wales
Mark Nawaqanitawase scored twice as the Wallabies rallied from 34-13 down to win 39-34 and add to Wales’s woes

Michael Aylwin at the Principality Stadium

26, Nov, 2022 @5:46 PM

Article image
Blair Kinghorn misses vital late penalty as Australia narrowly sink Scotland
Bernard Foley’s accuracy helped Australia to a 16-15 victory in Scotland, fly-half Blair Kinghorn missing a penalty at the very end for the hosts

Michael Aylwin

29, Oct, 2022 @6:42 PM

Article image
Ireland chasing southern-hemisphere hat-trick against Australia
Ireland will complete a clean sweep of southern-hemisphere giants in a calendar year if they beat Australia in Dublin

Michael Aylwin

18, Nov, 2022 @2:42 PM

Article image
Anscombe eager to help Wales end painful history against All Blacks
Gareth Anscombe believes Wales can take heart from the recent South Africa scalp on Saturday as they seek a first win over the All Blacks for 69 years

Andy Bull

04, Nov, 2022 @6:00 PM

Article image
Wales 34-39 Australia: Autumn Nations Series – as it happened
Wales were left stunned after Lachlan Lonergan completed a wild comeback win for Australia

Lee Calvert

26, Nov, 2022 @5:48 PM

Article image
The Breakdown | Borthwick, Gatland and Jones have to pedal hard in new jobs – and quickly
The coaching trio have no time to experiment as the race towards this year’s Rugby World Cup enters its final stages

Robert Kitson

17, Jan, 2023 @10:00 AM

Article image
Australia expect physical battle despite Wales dropping Jamie Roberts
Australia, who have won their past 12 matches against Wales, are expecting the usual physical encounter in Cardiff despite Warren Gatland dropping Jamie Roberts

Paul Rees

07, Nov, 2017 @6:30 PM

Article image
Rejigged Scotland bid to strike fresh blow against ailing Australia
Gregor Townsend has omitted notable names but Scotland have the chance to highlight the reorientation of rugby’s power base with another victory over Australia

Michael Aylwin

28, Oct, 2022 @11:59 AM

Article image
Australia 25-29 Wales: Rugby World Cup player ratings | Michael Aylwin
Australia’s Samu Kerevi and Marika Koroibete charged ferociously but the Welsh, led by an inspirational Alun Wyn Jones, defended magnificently

Michael Aylwin at Tokyo Stadium

29, Sep, 2019 @3:28 PM