England leave out Willis and have doubt over Mako Vunipola for South Africa

  • Tizard retained as Eddie Jones expands lineout options
  • ‘This will be battle of intent, rather than technique’

England have dropped the flanker Jack Willis for the Test against South Africa on Saturday and also have an injury doubt hanging over the experienced prop Mako Vunipola. Eddie Jones, the head coach, has chosen instead to expand his specialist lineout options by retaining the uncapped Saracens lock Hugh Tizard in a 26-man training squad.

The unlucky Willis came off the bench in the latter stages of the 25-25 draw against New Zealand on Saturday but the breakdown specialist now finds himself surplus to requirements for a game which England’s management regard as a very different tactical challenge.

The highly promising Tizard, and the Northampton pair David Ribbans and Alex Coles are all in the mix, with Sale’s Bevan Rodd included as cover for Vunipola who tweaked his back in a lively training session on Tuesday.

Jones could opt to give a first start to the South African-born Ribbans in the second row, with Maro Itoje moving back to the blindside flank and Coles and Tizard vying for a place on the bench but, whoever plays, England are determined to take the game to the Springboks from the outset and start faster than they managed against the All Blacks.

The scrum coach Matt Proudfoot, part of the South African coaching setup during their triumphant 2019 World Cup campaign, stressed that England would need a different mindset to combat the powerful Springbok set piece.

“Last week was a technical battle [but] this week is a battle of intent, a battle of will,” Proudfoot said. “Put together the nature of the contest and the fact we weren’t at our best last Saturday and the guys are very determined.

The sports law firm representing more than 225 rugby union players suffering from neurological impairments will this week serve proceedings against World Rugby, the Rugby Football Union and Welsh Rugby Union.

Rylands Garth say their claimants “contend that these defendants were negligent in failing to take reasonable action in order to protect players from permanent injury caused by repetitive concussive and sub-concussive blows”.

More than 20 players involved in the litigation – including the England World Cup winner Steve Thompson and the former Wales captain Ryan Jones – have spoken publicly about their brain injuries from playing the sport.

The French sports newspaper L’Equipe has also reported that 15 players plan to take action against the French rugby federation (FFR) and the national league (LNR) for failing to protect them from the effects of head injuries while playing in France. Only two of the 15 are French, with others claimants including those involved in other lawsuits, such as Thompson, Alix Popham, Carl Hayman and Jamie Cudmore, who played for French clubs during their careers. 

PA Media and Guardian sport

“The challenge will be about the heavy engagement whereas with the All Blacks it’s about the speed of engagement. Where the All Blacks try and fracture you, the Springboks have a different philosophy. They try and break you apart. They come at you, look for a weakness and then put all their power into exploiting that weakness.

It’s about the whole English eight doing exactly the same thing. It’s not about individual challenges against South Africa.”

Proudfoot also revealed England’s scrummaging practice had “got a little bit hectic” after he challenged Kyle Sinckler to try and “spice up” the session.

“I asked Kyle to do a specific role for us. You need a bit of spice. It’s a big game. These guys are professionals and they look after each other but they [can] take it up a notch. These guys want to win.

The conclusion after last weekend is that there’s a lot more in the team. To be able to do what we did at the back end of the game shows there’s more in us.”

The back-row forward Sam Simmonds also made clear England are keen to finish their autumn with a bang. “We were probably 5% off in the first half against New Zealand and if you give them opportunities they are too good not to take them,” said Simmonds, who also faced the Boks on the 2021 British & Irish Lions tour and knows what is coming this weekend.

“They [South Africa] want to bully teams … it is very much a case of ‘Why would I run round you when I can run through you?’”


Robert Kitson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Mako Vunipola fired up by World Cup final heartache against Springboks
England prop is preparing to face South Africa on Saturday three years on from the match that will ‘stay with me for the rest of my life’

Robert Kitson

24, Nov, 2022 @7:11 PM

Article image
Defeat by South Africa lays bare the deeper problems facing England | Robert Kitson
With a World Cup approaching Eddie Jones needs to arrest an alarming slide with six defeats and a draw from 12 Tests in 2022

Robert Kitson at Twickenham

27, Nov, 2022 @6:00 PM

Article image
‘We have to respect referees’: Jones teases Erasmus over officials criticism
With South Africa’s Rassie Erasmus banned from Saturday’s match by World Rugby, England’s Eddie Jones said: ‘The referee’s in charge, if he makes mistakes let’s accept it’

Gerard Meagher

24, Nov, 2022 @6:00 PM

Article image
Autumn internationals have shown the value of thinking clearly under pressure | Ugo Monye
Several matches have been decided by players not knowing laws of the game – there’s no excuse for that at this level

Ugo Monye

26, Nov, 2022 @7:30 AM

Article image
Eddie Jones rouses England to purge 2019 demons against Springboks
The World Cup final defeat in Japan still haunts England’s coach who has challenged his side to gain revenge at Twickenham

Robert Kitson

25, Nov, 2022 @6:00 PM

Article image
‘More courage:’ Jamie George calls on England to step up against Springboks
‘We’re hurting from our All Blacks performance,’ said the England hooker Jamie George who added settling for a draw with New Zealand was the right call

Robert Kitson

23, Nov, 2022 @6:00 PM

Article image
Eddie Jones facing review amid RFU concern over England’s autumn results
The RFU described England’s campaign as ‘really disappointing’ and the head coach should learn his fate within the next two weeks

Gerard Meagher

27, Nov, 2022 @6:00 PM

Article image
South Africa pick up cudgel and rapier to bury England | Andy Bull
There was no thrilling Twickenham comeback this time as savvy Springboks come out on top in attritional battle

Andy Bull at Twickenham

26, Nov, 2022 @9:10 PM

Article image
Billy Vunipola put England future before lucrative speaking engagements
England No 8 turned down speaking gigs during his spell on the sidelines, explaining that he did not want to be ‘with 100 drunk people asking about Eddie’

Gerard Meagher

03, Nov, 2022 @6:00 PM

Article image
Ireland’s lead status to face challenge from South Africa in physical epic
Ireland, the No 1 team in the world, will expect a ferocious duel against the world champions South Africa in their first meeting for five years

Michael Aylwin

04, Nov, 2022 @12:42 PM