Finn Russell returns as Scotland risk it all against the All Blacks

Gregor Townsend has brought the fly-half in from the cold as the All Blacks await. A stroke of genius, or a looming disaster?

Finn Russell. Discuss. Which is more or less all those in Scottish rugby have been doing for the past couple of weeks. The discussion, mercifully, will pause for 80 minutes on Sunday when the mercurial genius will do his thing at Murrayfield against the All Blacks, reinstated from nowhere at No 10. Then, no doubt, the debate will resume in earnest, the tenor of it determined by whichever way the mercury has flowed.

Only two weeks ago we were speculating over the end of Russell’s international career, dropped from Gregor Townsend’s squad altogether just a year out from the next World Cup. Townsend was a mercurial genius in his own playing days, but it seemed all too clear that when his quicksilver came into contact with Russell’s, the reaction had become toxic. We shall know more on that come four o’clock-ish Sunday afternoon.

When he left Russell out of his squad for the autumn, Townsend cited notions of form and consistency over the more obvious get-out of his unavailability for the first Test against Australia, which was outside the international window. Or indeed the other favoured conspiracy that Russell had not set the right sort of example when he was among a posse of drinkers out after hours in the wake of Scotland’s win over Italy in the Six Nations, a misdemeanour for which he was seemingly dropped to the bench in Scotland’s final match of the championship, against Ireland.

Townsend and Russell have had their run-ins, but the inconvenience of Russell’s excellent form in Paris for Racing 92 has led Townsend to this U-turn at No 10. Adam Hastings has been identified as possessing a more pleasing blend of artistry and discipline, but he was injured in Scotland’s unconvincing win over Fiji last weekend.

Finn Russell with head coach Gregor Townsend at Murrayfield in February.
Finn Russell with head coach Gregor Townsend at Murrayfield in February. They have not always seen eye to eye. Photograph: Jane Barlow/PA

Russell came off the bench for Racing at around the same time and turned a half-time deficit against Perpignan into a 44-20 rout, gathering 16 points in the process. Not to have called him up under those circumstances would have been quite the autumn statement.

But Townsend did not have to catapult him into the starting lineup. Blair Kinghorn’s missed penalty against Australia cost Scotland victory, but the elegant playmaker has otherwise impressed. The path of least resistance might have been to reinstate him to the starting lineup.

Scotland S Hogg (capt); D Graham, C Harris, S Johnson, D van der Merwe; F Russell, A Price; P Schoeman, G Turner, Z Fagerson, S Skinner, G Gilchrist, J Ritchie, H Watson, M Fagerson
Replacements: E Ashman, J Bhatti, O Kebble, J Hodgson, J Bayliss, G Horne, A Hastings, K Steyn

New Zealand J Barrett; M Telea, A Lienhart-Brown, D Havili, C Clarke; B Barrett, F Christie; E de Groot, S Taukei’aho, N Laulala, S Whitelock (capt), S Barrett, A Ioane, D Papali’i, A Savea
Replacements: C Taylor, G Bower, F Newell, T Vaa’i, S Frizell, TJ Perenara, S Perofeta, R Ioane

Instead, Townsend has brought Russell straight in, which has the doubly unsettling effect of making the coach look as if he is contradicting himself and offending the long-suffering Kinghorn. Could be the stuff of genius, could be an implosion waiting to happen. A bit like the relationship between the two. A bit like Scotland.

If the former, a first win for the Scots over the All Blacks is not out of the question. New Zealand do not wield that same aura of yore, having lost four times this year. They won well against Wales last weekend but make a raft of changes, none giving the impression they consider this match the most testing of their tour.

Mark Telea, the winger from Auckland, makes his debut and there is a new pairing in the centre of David Havili and Anton Lienert-Brown. The Barrett brothers, Beauden and Jordie, continue their familiar rotation through the back line, this time lining up at fly-half and full-back respectively. But Scottish eyes will be on the man at scrum-half, Finlay Christie.

After years enduring the apparent barbs of commentators reminding the world that such-and-such a player in blue might not have been born in Scotland – the “big man from Wagga Wagga” syndrome we might call it – the Scots will be expecting multiple allusions to the wee man from Peebles. Christie was born in the Borders but his parents whisked him away to New Zealand when he was seven. Then the pandemic denied him the chance to sign for Glasgow. Since when he has bounded up the ladder of Kiwi scrum-halves and will step out in black at Murrayfield in front of those very Scottish parents.


Michael Aylwin

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Graham and Russell inspire Scotland to punish Argentina after Kremer red
Darcy Graham scored a hat-trick in Scotland’s 52-29 victory at home to Argentina with the visitors losing Marcos Kremer to a first-half red card

Michael Aylwin

19, Nov, 2022 @5:41 PM

Article image
Wales fall short against New Zealand again after Smith and Savea lead rout
Wales’ losing streak against New Zealand continued with a 23-55 defeat as Aaron Smith and Codie Taylor scored two tries apiece for the All Blacks

Andy Bull at the Principality Stadium

05, Nov, 2022 @5:28 PM

Article image
England 25-25 New Zealand: Autumn Nations Series player ratings
Rieko Ioane was unplayable at times but England’s Mako Vunipola was like a man possessed after his introduction

Gerard Meagher at Twickenham

19, Nov, 2022 @8:25 PM

Article image
Twickenham faithful rise to salute a comeback for the ages | Andy Bull
Three England tries in seven late minutes salvaged a 25-25 draw with New Zealand in a match that had appeared lost

Andy Bull at Twickenham

19, Nov, 2022 @10:05 PM

Article image
Will Stuart stuns New Zealand to rescue remarkable draw for England
England completed a remarkable comeback with three tries in the final 10 minutes to rescue a 25-25 draw at home to New Zealand

Robert Kitson at Twickenham

19, Nov, 2022 @7:50 PM

Article image
England ‘right to go for the draw’ with New Zealand, says Owen Farrell
England captain Owen Farrell defended the decision to take a 25-25 draw with New Zealand at Twickenham rather than push for a win

Gerard Meagher at Twickenham

19, Nov, 2022 @9:47 PM

Article image
Scotland denied first ever win over New Zealand as Barretts combine late on
Tries from Scott Barrett and Mark Telea, converted by Jordie Barrett, took New Zealand to a 31-23 win against a Scotland side who led for most of the match

Michael Aylwin at BT Murrayfield

13, Nov, 2022 @4:48 PM

Article image
Russell and Steyn shine as ruthless Scotland flatten Wales in Six Nations
Kyle Steyn scored two tries as Scotland humbled Wales 35-7 in a one-sided Six Nations contest that left the visitors winless in this year’s championship

Michael Aylwin at BT Murrayfield

11, Feb, 2023 @6:53 PM

Article image
Russell holds key for Scotland to topple Ireland and set up title tilt
Finn Russell’s air of maturity suggests it could be his time for Scotland to halt Ireland’s charge to the Six Nations title

Michael Aylwin

11, Mar, 2023 @8:00 PM

Article image
Townsend urges Scotland to improve after momentous win against Wales
Gregor Townsend believes Scotland will have to improve again for their next matches despite crushing Wales to win their opening two Six Nations matches for the first time

Michael Aylwin at BT Murrayfield

11, Feb, 2023 @9:01 PM