Eddie Jones rings the changes as England try to cast off fear of failure

Manu Tuilagi and Billy Vunipola will be rested against Japan on Saturday as coach keeps one eye on the future

As much as Eddie Jones’s team selection to face Japan on Saturday reveals about how he wants England to play, how he wants to inject pace into a side that spluttered along in the low gears last weekend, it also shows he does not consider his job to be on the line. Defeat would be a sixth Test loss of the year and turn the pressure up a couple more notches but Jones would never leave a fit Manu Tuilagi on the bench for a match England have to win, however much his workload must be managed.

If Jones is not weighed down by a fear of failure, however, the same cannot be said of his players. The post-match message after last Sunday’s defeat by Argentina was clear: individual mistakes rather than underlying structural issues were to blame; cohesion always takes time when players are coming from so many different clubs. But as the week has worn on, there has been a willingness to acknowledge a fear of making mistakes has been holding England back.

It hardly helps that Japan are Saturday’s opponents – this fixture four years ago is known by players as the “Black Hole” game, given a number of Test careers vanished into it – and the captain, Owen Farrell, identified the problem when saying: “We don’t want to be a team that can’t make mistakes but we want to be a team that reacts well to them. We don’t want to overthink going into this [match] which maybe we were guilty of a little bit at the weekend. We want to free ourselves up.”

England will go a long way to achieving that if they can get the Twickenham crowd onside early. The rain did not help last Sunday, nor the stop-start nature of the first half, but there were times when the atmosphere was alarmingly flat. As Jones acknowledges: “It always comes down to the quality of rugby. If we play well enough this week there won’t be any Mexican waves.”

A fast start would help, and that goes some way to explaining the five changes Jones has made with Jonny May returning on the wing three weeks after dislocating his elbow, Sam Simmonds adding more pace from No 8 in place of Billy Vunipola, who drops to the bench after an error-strewn performance last week, and Jack van Poortvliet starting at scrum-half to add tempo. David Ribbans also makes a debut at lock, coming in for Northampton clubmate Alex Coles, while Guy Porter replaces Tuilagi but the aforementioned three changes are clearly designed to encourage England to express themselves.

The England captain, Owen Farrell, with Eddie Jones before the Argentina Test.
The England captain, Owen Farrell, with Eddie Jones before the Argentina Test. ‘We want to free ourselves up,’ says Farrell of Saturday’s match against Japan. Photograph: Adrian Dennis/AFP/Getty Images

“He’s quicker,” said Jones of the decision to select Van Poortvliet over Ben Youngs. On Simmonds, it was a similar story: “He’s got good pace.” And May? “He adds a bit of pace to us.”

Jones, however, has identified another problem. Those who have grown tired of his reasons for why England are not hitting their straps may not want to hear it, but a clutch of his players have played too few matches for their clubs in the run-up to the autumn for his liking.

Van Poortvliet is among them; so too Simmonds, Porter and May. Some of it is down to injuries and some to mandatory rest, while the fallout from Wasps and Worcester being suspended from the Premiership – thereby forcing other teams to go weeks without matches – is also having an effect.

“We’ve got this intriguing problem, a lot of our players aren’t playing a lot of rugby. We usually have the opposite. We’ve got some boys coming into camp and they haven’t played for four weeks. It’s nothing I can control, it’s not in my jurisdiction – so I’m hoping the new prime minister might sort it out, if he hasn’t got enough on his plate!”

England Steward; Nowell, Porter, Farrell (capt), May; Smith, Van Poortvliet; Genge, Cowan-Dickie, Sinckler, Ribbans, Hill, Itoje, Curry, Simmonds
Replacements George, M Vunipola, Heyes, Coles, B Vunipola, Youngs, Slade, Tuilagi

Japan Yamanaka; Matsushima, Riley, Nakamura, Van den Heever; Yamasawa, Nagare; Inagaki, Sakate (capt), Gu, Dearns, Cornelsen, Leith, Himeno, Tatafu
Replacements Norikoshi, Millar, Kizu, Van der Walt, Labuschagne, Saito, Lee, Fifita

Saturday 3.15pm, Twickenham

The hope is that, with another week’s training under the belt and minds sharpened by the disappointment of defeat, lack of game-time will be less of a problem and England can find the necessary intensity from the off, even if Jones could offer no guarantees.

“We had a joint coaching meeting about how you get teams to play with intensity, always at that top intensity, and no one knows. If I knew I’d be sitting here with a 100% record but no coach in the world has [that]. You can give too much information and sometimes you’re making it too simple. It’s finding the right balance. We’ve just tried to get the messaging more about ourselves and about where we are now rather than where we want to go.”

Louis Rees-Zammit will start at full-back in Wales’ Autumn Nations Series clash with Argentina on Saturday. He switches from the wing to fill a problem position for Wales, with Liam Williams and Leigh Halfpenny both injured. Alex Cuthbert, who has recovered from injury, completes the back three alongside Rio Dyer, a try-scorer on his Test debut when New Zealand beat Wales 55-23 last weekend.

Gareth Anscombe, who deputised for Halfpenny five days ago, reverts to fly-half, replacing Rhys Priestland. Elsewhere, prop Dillon Lewis starts instead of Tomas Francis and experienced Ospreys flanker Dan Lydiate features in the back row.

With the Leicester flanker Tommy Reffell sidelined because of a rib injury, captain Justin Tipuric moves across to openside, packing down with No 8 Taulupe Faletau in a back row trio boasting 246 caps. There is no place in the matchday 23 for Wales’ record cap holder Alun Wyn Jones, as Ben Carter provides second-row cover, with other bench changes seeing props Rhodri Jones and Sam Wainwright selected, plus Priestland and the Ospreys flanker Jac Morgan. PA Media

That may be so but the decision to bench Tuilagi has been made with an eye on the visits of New Zealand and South Africa in the coming weeks. Here Jones is again, striking the balance between the present and the future, England walking the tightrope between delivering results now and preparing for what lies ahead.

There are few more dangerous opponents to be facing than Japan if they fall.


Gerard Meagher

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Eddie Jones rouses England to purge 2019 demons against Springboks
The World Cup final defeat in Japan still haunts England’s coach who has challenged his side to gain revenge at Twickenham

Robert Kitson

25, Nov, 2022 @6:00 PM

Article image
‘Not good enough’: Eddie Jones says ‘silly’ mistakes cost England victory
The England coach said his players will hold ‘uncomfortable conversations’ this week after a shock 30-29 defeat by Argentina at Twickenham

Gerard Meagher at Twickenham

06, Nov, 2022 @7:05 PM

Article image
Eddie Jones wants England to ignite crowd and expose All Black weaknesses
Jones has likened the challenge of achieving a first home win over New Zealand at Twickenham on Saturday to ‘climbing Mount Everest’

Gerard Meagher

17, Nov, 2022 @7:40 PM

Article image
Eddie Jones facing review amid RFU concern over England’s autumn results
The RFU described England’s campaign as ‘really disappointing’ and the head coach should learn his fate within the next two weeks

Gerard Meagher

27, Nov, 2022 @6:00 PM

Article image
Eddie Jones’s England suffer familiar failings after another slow start | Gerard Meagher
Defeat by Argentina means another campaign begins on the wrong foot as coach’s charges struggle to find cohesion

Gerard Meagher

07, Nov, 2022 @8:00 PM

Article image
Jones banking on Farrell to provide England authority amid uncertainty
With the international landscape more volatile than ever England’s head coach Eddie Jones is taking a calculated risk in building his leadership group

Gerard Meagher

05, Nov, 2022 @8:00 AM

Article image
Jones worried about Lawes’ health with player likely to be out until Six Nations
England head coach, Eddie Jones, says Courtney Lawes might not play for his country again until next year’s Six Nations due to a head injury

Gerard Meagher

08, Nov, 2022 @6:00 PM

Article image
‘We have to respect referees’: Jones teases Erasmus over officials criticism
With South Africa’s Rassie Erasmus banned from Saturday’s match by World Rugby, England’s Eddie Jones said: ‘The referee’s in charge, if he makes mistakes let’s accept it’

Gerard Meagher

24, Nov, 2022 @6:00 PM

Article image
Billy Vunipola put England future before lucrative speaking engagements
England No 8 turned down speaking gigs during his spell on the sidelines, explaining that he did not want to be ‘with 100 drunk people asking about Eddie’

Gerard Meagher

03, Nov, 2022 @6:00 PM

Article image
Jones’s England face challenge to liberate themselves against Japan
Japan have the perfect armoury to exploit any overeagerness from wounded hosts England at Twickenham

Gerard Meagher

11, Nov, 2022 @6:00 PM