Concussion in sport: CTE found in more than half of sportspeople who donated brains

Groundbreaking findings by Australian Sports Brain Bank reveal prevalence of chronic traumatic encephalopathy, including in younger players

Groundbreaking research into the long-term ramifications of concussion in sport has found chronic traumatic encephalopathy in the brains of more than half of a cohort of donors, including three under the age of 35.

The Australian Sports Brain Bank on Monday reported its preliminary findings after examining the 21 brains posthumously donated by sportspeople since the centre’s inception in 2018.

Of those – all of whom had played sports with risks of repetitive head injury, including 17 in football codes – 12 donors were found to have CTE lesions, while all but one exhibited some form of neurodegeneration.

CTE, which can only be definitively diagnosed at autopsy, is a neurodegenerative condition linked to repeated head traumas. Symptoms experienced during life include cognitive impairment, impulsive behaviour, depression, suicidal thoughts, short-term memory loss and emotional instability.

Among the group with CTE are the already-reported cases of high-profile Australian rules footballers Danny Frawley, Shane Tuck and Polly Farmer, along with two anonymous former professional rugby league players. Both Frawley and Tuck took their own lives, while Farmer had Alzheimer’s – another condition linked to head injuries.

But the additional findings made by Associate Professor Michael Buckland, a neuropathologist at the Royal Prince Alfred hospital and the University of Sydney, and his brain bank colleagues, underlined the prevalence and severity of traumatic brain injury across all age groups and levels of collision-based sport.

“CTE was identified in the brains of older former professionals with long playing careers, but also in younger, nonprofessional sportsmen and in recent professionals who had played under modern concussion guidelines,” wrote Buckland and his fellow researchers in the paper published by the Medical Journal of Australia.

“Three donors with CTE were under 35 years of age. Six of the 12 donors with CTE and one of nine without CTE had died by suicide, suggesting CTE may be a suicide risk factor.

“Screening for CTE in all deaths by suicide is probably impractical, but our finding suggests it should be undertaken if a history of repetitive head injury is known or suspected.”

Clinical Associate Professor Michael Buckland.
Associate Professor Michael Buckland, a neuropathologist at the Royal Prince Alfred hospital and the University of Sydney. Photograph: Joel Carrett/AAP

The conversation around the link between concussion – and subclinical concussion – and irreversible brain injury have engulfed collision-based sports globally.

In Australia, class actions against the governing bodies of football codes in particular are attracting more and more present and former players, increasing the pressure on sporting institutions to act in a manner commensurate with this unfolding epidemic.

The less frequently reported victims are amateur athletes, whom this research has concluded are no less at risk than their professional counterparts.

The researchers acknowledged that “ascertainment bias for abnormal neuropathology was inevitable” given brain donations were motivated by either clinical diagnoses or the concerns of family members.

But they also stated it was “remarkable that CTE was found in more than half of these cases”.

“Moreover,” they wrote, “in half of the donor brains with CTE, it was the sole neurodegenerative pathology … our findings should encourage clinicians and policymakers to develop measures that further mitigate the risk of sport-related repetitive head injury.”

Since 2018 the brain has received more than 600 donation pledges from amateur and professional sportspeople.


Emma Kemp

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘So full of life and love, so sad inside’: how Jacinda Barclay’s death could help us understand concussion in sport
When the fearless, open-hearted athlete took her own life in October, the shock was immense. Now her family is determined to find out why

Stephanie Convery in Perth

30, Apr, 2021 @2:57 AM

Article image
Wearing headgear for sport does not protect against concussion, Australian experts warn
Scientists to tell Senate inquiry that protective headwear does not stop the brain from moving inside the skull which causes concussion

Donna Lu Science writer

25, Apr, 2023 @3:00 PM

Article image
New plagiarism claims against sport concussion guru Paul McCrory
Exclusive: Expert who has downplayed link between concussion and traumatic brain injury is accused of 10 more cases of plagiarism

Melissa Davey, Stephanie Convery and Emma Kemp

22, Sep, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
New investigation into allegations of plagiarism against concussion expert Paul McCrory
British Journal of Sports Medicine says it is investigating a body of work published by McCrory, its former editor-in-chief

Emma Kemp and Melissa Davey

28, Apr, 2022 @9:45 AM

Article image
Prestigious medical journal retracts nine more articles authored by concussion expert Paul McCrory
British Journal of Sports Medicine says investigation ‘revealed a pattern of publication misconduct’ by McCrory, has concerns over 38 other articles

Stephanie Convery

11, Oct, 2022 @5:00 AM

Article image
Concussion researcher claims AFL hindered two-year research project into players’ health
Associate Prof Alan Pearce says he signed a $60,000 contract with league for tests on retired players but believes the AFL hindered his research’s progress for nearly 18 months

Melissa Davey, Stephanie Convery and Emma Kemp

05, Apr, 2022 @3:20 AM

Article image
Damage found after late AFLW player Jacinda Barclay’s brain donated for concussion research
Exclusive: Researchers at the Australian Sports Brain Bank have uncovered neurological damage they describe as a ‘ticking time bomb’

Exclusive by Stephanie Convery

29, Apr, 2021 @5:30 PM

Article image
AFL trying to ‘divide and conquer’ over brain bank endorsement, concussion expert says
Dr Adrian Cohen says league’s hesitation to choose Australian Sports Brain Bank shows it is overlooking its ‘specific expertise’

Emma Kemp, Stephanie Convery and Melissa Davey

07, May, 2022 @8:00 PM

Article image
Concussion and head trauma in contact sports to be examined by parliamentary inquiry
Lidia Thorpe’s proposal receives unanimous support, with the Greens senator saying ‘sports organisations need to be transparent about evidence’

Melissa Davey Medical editor

01, Dec, 2022 @5:50 AM

Article image
Base of the iceberg: the tragic cost of concussion in amateur sport | Emma Kemp
Former footy player Paul Wheatley is serving a prison sentence – the culmination of a chain of events that could be traced back to numerous on-field head knocks

Emma Kemp

22, Nov, 2021 @4:30 PM