Careful management required with Rugby Australia’s Giteau Law now effectively defunct | Bret Harris

The right balance must be found between making the Wallabies strong again and keeping sufficient talent for Super Rugby sides

The selection of six overseas-based Australian players in the Wallabies’ Spring tour squad suggests the Giteau Law is about to become a dead letter. It is the highest representation of overseas-based players since the introduction of the rule in 2015, which was essentially designed to make inside back Matt Giteau eligible for the World Cup that year.

In fact, the overseas contingent was the same as the number of players supplied to the 37-man squad by the Melbourne Rebels, NSW Waratahs and Queensland Reds, and twice as many as the Western Force. Only the Brumbies (10) provided more players.

Of the six overseas-based players in the squad, only five-eighth Quade Cooper (75 caps) qualified under the original Giteau Law, which allowed players with 60 Test caps to be eligible for the Wallabies.

The Giteau Law was subsequently amended to permit the selection of two players who did not meet the 60-cap threshold. But five players – Rory Arnold (22 caps), Samu Kerevi (36), Tolu Latu (15), Sean McMahon (26) and Will Skelton (18) – were given exemptions under the amendment to make the upcoming Spring tour.

Some restraint was shown with the omission of France-based utility back Kurtley Beale, possibly because of the plan to develop outside back Jordan Petaia as a fullback on tour.

Rugby Australia will clarify its position after the Spring tour and has indicated that some cap will remain, but it seems likely that the number of players required will determine the limit, particularly for the 2023 World Cup in France.

With the Wallabies’ ordinary results since the 2015 World Cup, RA had no choice but to head in this direction, something which the national governing body has strongly resisted previously.

Rory Arnold in action for Toulouse.
Rory Arnold in action for Toulouse. Photograph: Adrian Dennis/AFP/Getty Images

After an unconvincing 2-1 series win against a second-string France side in the winter, the Wallabies were thrashed 3-0 by the All Blacks in the Bledisloe Cup. Then, with Cooper, Kerevi and McMahon recalled from Japan, the Wallabies won four Tests in a row for the first time since 2017, upsetting the world champion Springboks twice and defeating Argentina twice in the Rugby Championship.

The influence of Cooper and Kerevi, in particular, was profound, highlighting the need for the Wallabies to select Australia’s best players no matter where they played club or provincial rugby.

The Wallabies’ success in the Rugby Championship made it more palatable to bring in the likes of France-based Arnold, Skelton and Latu for the British leg of the Spring tour. World-class second-rowers, Arnold and Skelton have the potential to transform the team’s forward play in the same way Cooper and Kerevi improved their back play, while Latu would add much-needed depth to the hooking position.

The availability of all required overseas-based players would certainly make the Wallabies a competitive force in world rugby again, but RA must manage the process carefully. In the past the nation’s Super Rugby franchises opposed the loosening of the Giteau Law because they feared it would exacerbate the exodus of players to rich overseas clubs in Europe and Japan.

You could argue that the Socceroos have no restrictions on selecting overseas-based players and there is still enough local talent in Australia to support the domestic A-League Men. But comparing Australian rugby and football is like comparing oval balls with round balls. With the exception of Wellington Phoenix, the A-League Men is an Australia-only competition, but Australia’s Super Rugby teams compete against five New Zealand sides, among the best regional outfits in the world.

Australia’s Super Rugby teams have struggled to beat the Kiwis over the last seven years and a continuation of the player drain overseas would widen the trans-Tasman gap further, eroding support for the provincial game here. So it is understandable RA and the club franchises would want to maintain some vestige of the Giteau Law to try to deter players from leaving.

But the bottom line in Australian rugby is that the Wallabies are the main money-makers. If the men in gold are unsuccessful, the whole game suffers, including the Super Rugby franchises, which derive 30% to 40% of their income from annual RA grants.

RA must find the right balance between making the Wallabies strong again and keeping sufficient talent in Australia to ensure the Super Rugby sides can compete with the New Zealanders. That is much easier said than done.

Since its inception the Giteau Law has been tweaked a few times and this practice is likely to continue in the lead up to the World Cup. It has to be sufficiently flexible to ensure required overseas-based players are eligible for selection, while at the same time RA and the Super Rugby franchises must work harder to keep marquee players in the country.

The rule is unlikely to be repealed, but it is almost certain for all intents and purposes to become defunct in practice.


Bret Harris

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Australia’s Nic White plays down praise from ‘king of mind games’ Eddie Jones
Australia’s Nic White has insisted he will not fall for Eddie Jones’s mind games after the England head coach singled him out for praise

Gerard Meagher

10, Nov, 2021 @2:00 AM

Article image
Australia’s future rugby landscape to be shaped by pay cut talks | Bret Harris
Rugby Australia’s plan is to survive for the next three months, but there is no certainty about what happens after that

Bret Harris

30, Mar, 2020 @11:25 PM

Article image
Rugby Australia’s mega-bucks swoop for teenager comes loaded with potential problems | Bret Harris
No 16-year-old is worth even close to $3m and Joseph Suaalii certainly should not be rushed into Super Rugby or Tests before he is ready

Bret Harris

23, Jul, 2020 @8:03 AM

Article image
Positional switch the key in Australia's Rugby World Cup win over Fiji
The subtle shift of James O’Connor to inside-centre gave the Wallabies the ball-playing style they needed to overcome a determined Fijian side

Bret Harris

21, Sep, 2019 @8:00 PM

Article image
Israel Folau offered to issue apology, Rugby Australia alleges in court documents
Prior to suing Rugby Australia over his firing, Folau allegedly agreed the posts had breached his contract

Guardian sport

25, Sep, 2019 @7:45 AM

Article image
Michael Cheika survives as Scott Johnson is named Wallabies' director of rugby
Michael Cheika will lead the Wallabies to Japan next year but he will report to a director of rugby after a new role was created

Guardian sport

17, Dec, 2018 @1:11 AM

Article image
Australian Rugby Union relief after man charged over All Blacks listening device
Man believed to have been employed as a security consultant to appear in court in in March

Mike Hytner

07, Feb, 2017 @7:53 AM

Article image
Rugby Australia left with mess to clear up after withdrawal of Wallabies trio | Bret Harris
Whether Quade Cooper, Samu Kerevi and Sean McMahon are a coalition of the unwilling or victims of circumstance, decisive yet prudent action must be taken

Bret Harris

28, Oct, 2021 @5:09 AM

Article image
Wallabies’ Bledisloe battering highlights urgent need to scrap Giteau Law | Bret Harris
Having access to all Australia’s best players would make them more competitive against the All Blacks

Bret Harris

15, Aug, 2021 @5:30 PM

Article image
Israel Folau and Rugby Australia settle unfair dismissal claim over social media post
Former Wallabies star had sought $14m in compensation saying he was wrongfully dismissed over anti-gay Instagram post

Mike Hytner

04, Dec, 2019 @3:20 AM