The Spin | Ashes has lost focus with scandals engulfing ECB and Cricket Australia

After months of scandal, two already ordinary teams now look like something more tawdry and tarnished

The Ashes are coming, the Ashes are coming. And yet, if you were paying attention to cricket over the past couple of weeks, you may identify with a lack of enthusiasm. You may identify instead with a weariness, a wariness, a general swirling malaise. Australia and England, that pair, where those leading the game and those leading the teams have been draping themselves in the inverse of glory.

The two captains, as per the pre-series marketing, have dwindled to one captain, meaning that 100% of the remaining captains and 100% of the former captains in this series exist under a cloud. Australia’s anointed repairer of reputation, Tim Paine, resigned his commission via the national tradition of a teary public apology after his homespun erotica attained belated publication. England’s blameless golden child, Joe Root, has always been fiercely claimed as the property of Yorkshire, and thus must remain so, as a teammate who, Azeem Rafiq said in his testimony to a parliamentary hearing, was oblivious to racist chatter.

To describe Cricket Australia as an administration in turmoil may falsely suggest that this is an exception rather than a norm. It would also be overly kind in suggesting the possible visitation of trouble from outside. In reality, the text messages were coming from inside the house. For at least five years CA has been a rolling maul of incompetence, where a high attrition rate of failed executives and directors has been balanced by enough new substitutes joining in to keep the whole mess ploughing relentlessly on in the same direction. There are decent people in the place but so far they have been kept on the sidelines, ignored as they shout directions towards something better.

Nobody needs 1950s prurience about relationships any more. But even if Paine’s is the kind of story that only concerns those within his marriage, the fact remains that Cricket Australia held an investigation into the workplace conduct of their new captain after he had led the team in a total of one Test match. Soon afterwards, in November 2018, at the same time as their hired hands were emblazoning “Elite Honesty” on large placards on the dressing room wall, all parties elected to bury that fact. Despite the ongoing threat of it becoming known, they never got out ahead of the story. They sat quietly and hoped it would do the same.

All of which is before you come to the issue of consent or otherwise. CA this week restated its 2018 findings that the messages were mutually desired, but won’t address why the recipient now disputes this. They also state that the interaction was a one-off, despite the familiarity in the correspondence strongly indicating that this is implausible. As with Yorkshire and Rafiq, conclusions from cricket authorities investigating themselves are not worth the paper that they don’t get printed on.

Azeem Rafiq’s allegations of racism at Yorkshire have left the ECB with plenty of questions to answer.
Azeem Rafiq’s allegations of racism at Yorkshire have left the ECB with plenty of questions to answer. Photograph: Barry Mitchell/Shutterstock

Then you have the England and Wales Cricket Board, claiming shock and dismay at Rafiq’s testimony that they have just spent 15 months not listening to, letting Yorkshire try to run down the clock. All the while, they were asking England players to wear nice T-shirts before each match with slogans about cricket being a game for everyone. They have hosed fortunes on a fortnight’s play in the needlessly divisive Hundred competition, rather than investing those resources and ingenuity to elevate the county T20 tournament, and the top suits this year paid themselves £2.1m in bonuses to congratulate themselves on their wise financial stewardship last year in sacking 62 staff to get through the pandemic.

It all correlates with the English Test captain’s milquetoast response to Rafiq, a smoothie of motivational quotes about moving forward together, in that way that makes Root an ideal study in the Yeats formulation about the best lacking all conviction. When Root carries England with his batting, it only emphasises the contrast. He will need to do plenty of that in the upcoming series.

Teams can come to reflect the failings of their boards, just as the other way around. The Ashes boards along with India are responsible for so much, dominating the International Cricket Council as they do. Their recent schedule announcement gives India five major events in 10 years, including two out of three 50-over World Cups, while Australia and England take three events between them. By season’s end, 14 of Australia’s past 19 Tests will have been against India or England.

Both CA and the ECB will be desperately hoping that come Brisbane, attention will shift on to the field. But they’re hardly set for a 2005 barnstormer. And anyway, some of the heroes of 2005 have recently had a fair bit of gloss taken off. Instead, two already ordinary teams now look like something more tawdry and tarnished, a tired routine relying on too few stars, going through its paces to churn out some more money for the Old Firm. It’s hard to feel inspired. It would really be something to have people leading the game who could manage that.

• This is an extract from the Guardian’s weekly cricket email, The Spin. To subscribe and get the full edition, just visit this page and follow the instructions.


Geoff Lemon

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
England’s creaking bowling attack lets Australia off the Ashes hook | Andy Bull
Having reduced Australia to 12 for three, the tourists ended up using a part-time spinner in ideal conditions for seam bowling

Andy Bull

14, Jan, 2022 @2:48 PM

Article image
The Spin | ‘It’s about time’: proud Tasmania ready to host its first Ashes Test
Australia’s often overlooked smallest state feels it has long earned its chance to host England and wants to make sure it can again

Geoff Lemon in Hobart

12, Jan, 2022 @10:55 AM

Article image
The Spin | Play hard and don’t lose first Test: Lamb’s lessons for England’s Ashes tilt
Former batter recalls the 1986-87 Ashes tour and believes England need a tubthumping approach to win this series

Simon Burnton

07, Dec, 2021 @3:10 PM

Article image
Look beyond a boundary to fix English cricket’s ills | Letters
Letters: Cricket clubs are no longer central to their communities, writes John Claughton; Martin Allen points out that in Australia, the game is still at the heart of youth culture; and Mike Stein raises the issue of inequitable funding


31, Dec, 2021 @5:00 PM

Article image
Giles calls for systemic change in English cricket after Ashes defeat
Ashley Giles, the managing director of the England men’s team, apologised for losing the series but was not drawn on the futures of the coach, Chris Silverwood, and the captain Joe Root

Ali Martin in Sydney

04, Jan, 2022 @6:00 PM

Article image
Ben Stokes takes indefinite break from cricket to ‘prioritise mental wellbeing’
Ben Stokes is taking a immediate break ‘to prioritise his mental wellbeing’, the ECB has announced, as it prepares for talks over players’ families travelling to this winter’s Ashes

Sachin Nakrani and Tony Paley

30, Jul, 2021 @8:46 PM

Article image
Joe Root in touch with Azeem Rafiq but reiterates he did not witness racism
Joe Root said he has exchanged messages with Azeem Rafiq but the England captain maintains he never witnessed any racist behaviour at Yorkshire

Chris Stocks

29, Nov, 2021 @12:49 PM

Article image
Five things England must fix before the second Ashes Test | Tim de Lisle
Mistakes were made in selection as well as batting, bowling and fielding but Australia can be beaten if improvements are made

Tim de Lisle

12, Dec, 2021 @8:00 PM

Article image
ECB and Cricket Australia blundering deeper into crisis with Ashes looming | Andy Bull
The ECB and Cricket Australia’s handling of revelations of racism and sexism could hardly be going worse, and sorry is not going to be enough

Andy Bull

19, Nov, 2021 @8:30 PM

Article image
After awful Ashes defeat, will England ever be good at Test cricket again? | Jonathan Liew
Joe Root and Chris Silverwood will probably pay for the debacle in Australia with their jobs, but what then?

Jonathan Liew

28, Dec, 2021 @10:00 AM