‘It is so normalised’: community in Yorkshire on cricket racism scandal

Cricket-loving south Asian residents express little surprise but much resigned anger towards a club they see as unwelcoming

The Azeem Rafiq revelations have not come as a great surprise to Yorkshire men and women of south Asian backgrounds, many of whom interviewed by the Guardian believe they reflect the society in which they have lived their lives.

Kamran Abbasi was brought up in Yorkshire, played his cricket there, and felt he experienced racism at every turn. His book Englistan, about the immigrant experience of cricket, explores Yorkshire’s historical struggle with racism.

“I don’t think the existence of racism is in dispute,” he says. “It is so normalised in many settings. As a Black or Asian person, you can fight it every time you hear it or at times choose to just let it pass as the idiotic words of somebody you don’t know and will never see again. What makes it much more upsetting is when it is persistent and it comes from so-called friends, colleagues or teammates.

“In the end it doesn’t matter exactly what Michael Vaughan said, it happened on his watch, he was a senior player and ex-England captain. All the comments that happened in the dressing room or on the field weren’t a one-off. The problem is that nobody at Yorkshire said anything or tried to put an end to it.”

Halima Khan, the founder and managing director of Opening Boundaries, an organisation that uses sporting initiatives as a positive driver of social change, agrees that the problem lies with the inherent structures at the club.

Lord Kamlesh Patel has been appointed as the new Yorkshire chair.
Lord Kamlesh Patel has been appointed as the new Yorkshire chair. Photograph: Allan McKenzie/SWpix.com/Shutterstock

“I’ve done a lot of work with Yorkshire, and there are some really good staff there,” she says. “All three organisations – the Yorkshire cricket board, the Yorkshire foundation and Yorkshire CCC – can be more reflective of the societies that they serve.

“There is a lot of work to do in how they engage personally, structurally and organisationally. They have admitted discrimination, the telling part is that the accountability wasn’t there. Once you get beyond participation level, that’s where the inequality really starts, you have to go beyond the smoke and mirrors.

“Lord Patel [the club’s new chair] has come in and done an amazing job in the time he’s been in post, he’s shown leadership and empathy and kindness, but after 18 months you end up with one person of colour apologising to another person of colour. Where is the accountability for those who have done wrong?”

She thinks there are specific challenges for south Asian women trying to get into the system, that there is a lack of cultural understanding. “I read a Muslim player say they were forced to wear shorts. I just think that is a personal choice, it has no impact on the game and helps them feel safe in an environment doing the sport they love.”

Taj Butt has been involved with Yorkshire cricket most of his adult life and has been the chairman of the Quaid e Azam league for 35 years. He worked for the Yorkshire Cricket Foundation, the official charity and community arm of Yorkshire County Cricket Club (YCCC), for three years, between 2014 and 2017, before resigning.

“I was based at Headingley, and the culture was disappointing to see. When I arrived, there was only one other person of colour. He worked as a cleaner in the car park. It was a white, middle-class, young, laddish culture. I walked into the office and I felt like I’d walked into a youth club. I didn’t feel welcome at all.

“There was a lot of stereotypical language and behaviour in regard to the Asian community. I went into it thinking we needed to have more clubs like mine [Great Horton Church] making more opportunities for young people, but they didn’t want more clubs. They wanted taxi drivers and restaurant workers playing in the park. Some of that came from the ECB and their south Asian strategy.

“I was involved in some of the planning, but when the strategy came out it was totally different from what I had hoped to see. Quite a lot of investment had come from Sport England who want to see a rise in participation rates among adults. But for me it wasn’t about increasing participation, there’s huge participation in the south Asian community, the problem was progress to the next level, whereas Yorkshire saw it as a tick-box exercise about numbers.”

The Spin: sign up and get our weekly cricket email.

He says racism on the pitch is less in your face than it used to be, but it hasn’t gone. He thinks people have just got more crafty, using terms like “Taliban” and “Isis”. He also believes the community itself isn’t listened to – he cites the example of the installation of a number of non-turf pitches in Bradford: “The problem is nobody in Bradford wants to play on them, they want access to grounds to play matches.”

Recreationally, there are still huge problems of marginalisation. “There is a pyramid system, but most of the Asian clubs are not invited to be part of it. Asian teams like mine, we’ve got the expertise, the facilities, to be successful, but when we try and join the system, we simply don’t get accepted. When it goes to a vote at an AGM, we often get no votes at all.”

Yorkshire Cricket Foundation said: “There is no place for racism in cricket. There is no place for racism at the Yorkshire Cricket Foundation. YCF strongly [denies] the claims made by Taj Butt.”

• This article was amended on 12 November 2021 to set out the full name of the Yorkshire Cricket Foundation (YCF), the charitable and community arm of YCCC, and to include a statement from YCF in response to Taj Butt’s claims.


Tanya Aldred

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Sajid Javid says ‘heads should roll’ over Yorkshire cricket racism claims
Cabinet minister demands action by Yorkshire CCC and sponsor Anchor withdraws as pressure escalates

Ali Martin

02, Nov, 2021 @7:44 PM

Article image
ECB demands Yorkshire publish racism report prompted by Rafiq allegations
The England and Wales Cricket Board has intervened to demand the publication of a report into racism at Yorkshire after Azeem Rafiq, whose allegations of abuse prompted the investigation, described the process as ‘a sham’

Simon Burnton

18, Aug, 2021 @7:45 PM

Article image
Yorkshire investigate 'institutional racism' claims made by Azeem Rafiq
Yorkshire have begun an investigation into allegations of ‘institutional racism’ and a review of the club’s culture

Ali Martin

03, Sep, 2020 @6:48 PM

Article image
Second cricketer backs Azeem Rafiq's racism claims against Yorkshire
The former Pakistan bowler Rana Naved-ul-Hasan, who played for Yorkshire from 2008-09, has said there was ‘systematic taunting’ at the county

Andy Martin

16, Sep, 2020 @4:58 PM

Article image
Asian advisory body happy Yorkshire racism inquiry will be serious and fair
The National Asian Cricket Council is confident the inquiry into Azeem Rafiq’s allegations of ‘institutional racism’ at Yorkshire will get to the heart of the matter and that the club will act should wrongdoing be established

Ali Martin

09, Sep, 2020 @3:15 PM

Article image
Tom Harrison facing county revolt over ECB’s handling of racism scandal
Tom Harrison faces the prospect of a county rebellion and possible calls to resign amid growing anger over the England and Wales Cricket Board’s handling of the Yorkshire racism scandal

Ali Martin

17, Nov, 2021 @7:55 PM

Article image
English cricket offers Azeem Rafiq apology and promises action on racism
English cricket issued an unreserved apology to Azeem Rafiq, saying the racism he experienced was a blight on the game

Sean Ingle

19, Nov, 2021 @6:44 PM

Article image
Eoin Morgan says Yorkshire racism allegations must be tackled ‘head-on’
Eoin Morgan, captaining England at the T20 World Cup, said the ECB’s removal of internationals from Headingley showed how seriously the issue was taken

Simon Burnton in Dubai

05, Nov, 2021 @11:37 AM

Article image
Azeem Rafiq’s testimony on racism plunges English cricket into crisis
English cricket has descended into crisis after Azeem Rafiq’s testimony laid bare its failings on racism, bullying and dressing room culture, while also alleging a past drugs cover-up by Yorkshire

Ali Martin Cricket correspondent

16, Nov, 2021 @9:52 PM

Article image
Cack-handed as ever, Yorkshire CCC has been devoured by Azeem Rafiq scandal | Tanya Aldred
Shameful handling of racism allegations is the latest example of the club’s appalling track record at clearing up its own backyard

Tanya Aldred

03, Nov, 2021 @8:28 PM