Rugby league players planning dementia case face battle, lawyer warns

  • Lawyer Richard Cramer says: ‘There is no clearcut favourite’
  • Significant payouts ‘could be final straw’ financially for the sport

A sports lawyer has warned of the “significant hurdles” a group of former rugby league players will need to overcome to mount a successful legal challenge against the sport’s authorities over a failure to protect them against neurodegenerative disease. He also said the game may struggle to survive if the challenge succeeds.

Up to 10 retired players are understood to have approached Rylands Law, the firm that has launched action on behalf of a number of former rugby union players diagnosed with brain injuries, including the former World Cup winner, Steve Thompson.

Some of the league players in question, who it is understood have been retired for a number of years, are believed to be showing symptoms of dementia.

Richard Cramer, of Front Row Legal based in Leeds, said there are numerous obstacles to clear before it can be proved rugby league acted in a negligent manner towards its players. “It’s certainly not going to be an easy case: there are significant hurdles for the claimants to overcome but it’s not insurmountable,” Cramer said.

“The most obvious defence would be ‘Volenti non fit injuria’, which means that when a player goes out on the field, they’re aware of the physical nature of the sport they’re playing and they consent to playing with the risks associated to it. But if there is medical evidence to show these issues and injuries have been caused by playing the game, that’s something that cannot be ignored.”

Cramer warned it is by no means a straightforward decision if the action reaches the courts. “There is no clearcut favourite here; I can certainly see it from the claimants’ point of view,” he said. “The RFL have treated concussion a lot more seriously over the last few years but the real test is whether any governing body in any sport were always aware of the risks associated with head injuries.

Sign up to The Recap, our weekly email of editors’ picks.

“If they chose to ignore them at any stage, there’s a duty of care issue for sure. This is a very real issue and while any challenge will be vigorously defended by the authorities, if it can be proven there has been some sort of negligence, there is certainly a chance the claims could succeed.”

Cramer believes any successful challenge could produce significant payouts for a sport which is already struggling financially, and as such, could be catastrophic.

“It may not be able to survive claims of this nature, because it can run into thousands and thousands of pounds,” he said. “This isn’t good news financially for the sport and could be the final straw but it clearly can’t be brushed aside because of the issues facing the players.”

The RFL said: “The RFL are noting and monitoring developments, but have received no formal contact.”

Contributor

Aaron Bower

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Modern-day rugby league players at equal risk of brain injuries, says lawyer
A lawyer representing ten former rugby league players in action against the sport’s governing body says today’s players are equally at risk of sustaining brain injuries

Aaron Bower

27, Oct, 2021 @4:18 PM

Article image
Landmark study reveals link between football and dementia
Former professional footballers are three and a half times more likely to die of dementia than the general population, a landmark study has found

Sean Ingle

21, Oct, 2019 @11:05 PM

Article image
Football should consider eliminating heading, dementia expert says
Football needs to come with a health warning and should consider eliminating heading, the leading researcher into dementia in the sport Dr Willie Stewart has said

Paul MacInnes

02, Aug, 2021 @3:00 PM

Article image
RFL approves concussion-detecting mouthguards across rugby league
The initial plan was for the mouthguards to be used in Super League only from 2022 but they will also now be adopted in the Women’s Super League and at academy and community level

Aaron Bower

18, Nov, 2021 @1:06 PM

Article image
Families of former football and rugby players launch dementia charity
The family of Nobby Stiles have become ambassadors for a new charity launched by the families of former football and rugby players who have been diagnosed with dementia

Michael Aylwin and Andy Bull

14, Jan, 2021 @1:45 PM

Article image
Rugby league players' chief warns clubs not to blacklist players
Garreth Carvell, the head of the players’ union, is concerned clubs could punish players who resist pay cuts

Aaron Bower

03, May, 2020 @12:56 PM

Article image
Expert warns of 'hugely worrying' number of headers in football matches
Professional players are heading the ball in league matches with a frequency that is ‘hugely worrying’, according to a leading academic

Paul MacInnes

22, Nov, 2020 @11:44 AM

Article image
Haskell and Cudmore launch new lobby group with letter to World Rugby
Jamie Cudmore and James Haskell are at the head of a new lobby group called Progressive Rugby, which has launched with an open letter to Sir Bill Beaumont, chairman of World Rugby calling for urgent reforms to the sport

Michael Aylwin

18, Feb, 2021 @12:01 AM

Article image
World Rugby’s cynical deflection over brain injuries is an insult to the players | Michael Aylwin
Governing body’s posturing over the cause of early onset dementia among ex-players is extraordinarily insensitive

Michael Aylwin

17, Nov, 2021 @7:12 PM

Article image
Why has rugby taken so long to wake up to what boxing has long known?
New research points to small, repetitive blows damaging rugby players’ brains, but boxing established this decades ago

Andy Bull

02, Sep, 2021 @7:00 AM