Strength of trans women drops slightly after year of treatment, research claims

  • Loss of lean body mass around 5% after testosterone blockers
  • Study raises questions for sport related to safety and fairness

Men have a greater performance advantage over women in cricket, golf and tennis compared to sports such as running or swimming according to new research, which also finds that testosterone blockers taken by transgender women only minimally reduce the biological advantage underpinning performance.

The study, published in Sports Medicine, found that while elite men are around 10-13% faster than elite women at running and swimming, the gap is between 29% and 52% when it comes to bowling cricket balls, hitting long drives, weightlifting and in sports that generally rely more on muscle mass and explosive strength.

“Performance differences larger than 20% are generally present when considering sports and activities that involve extensive upper body contributions,” the study adds. “The gap between fastest recorded tennis serve is 20%, while the gaps between fastest recorded baseball pitches and field hockey drag flicks exceed 50%.”

However when transgender women suppress testosterone for 12 months, researchers found that the loss of lean body mass, muscle area and strength was only around 5%. Therefore, they say, “the muscular advantage enjoyed by transgender women is only minimally reduced when testosterone is suppressed” and “small compared to the baseline differences”.

The results are significant because under the current International Olympic Committee guidelines, transgender women are allowed to compete in female sports categories if they suppress their testosterone below 10 nmol/L for 12 months before and during competition.

Yet even when testosterone was suppressed to around 1 nmol/L it did not “remove the anthropometric and muscle mass/strength advantage in any significant way” – although the authors say the reduced cardiovascular performance may generate smaller retained advantage in endurance sports.

The study raises significant questions for sport, with the paper stating “the IOC may need to reassess” whether its current guidelines for transgender women are fair or safe for female competition. They also ask whether, from a medical-ethical standpoint, it is acceptable for the IOC to ask trans women to significantly reduce their testosterone if it does not deliver on its stated aims.

Meanwhile researchers also found the biological gap between women and men is so great that 10,000 males have personal-best times that are faster than the current Olympic 100m female champion, as does the 14-year-old male schoolboy 100m record holder.

“These data overwhelmingly confirm that testosterone-driven puberty, as the driving force of development of male secondary sex characteristics, underpins sporting advantages that are so large no female could reasonably hope to succeed without sex segregation in most sporting competitions.”

Contributor

Sean Ingle

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Trans women retain 12% edge in tests two years after transitioning, study finds
Trans women retained a 12% advantage and their testosterone levels remained higher even after two years of taking suppressing hormones

Sean Ingle

07, Dec, 2020 @11:30 PM

Article image
Sport’s trans issue is here to stay. But at last, the debate is starting to change | Sean Ingle
Swimming is the latest sport to become embroiled in discord but there are some signs of courteous, informed discussion too

Sean Ingle

13, Dec, 2021 @8:00 AM

Article image
From the Olympics to Euro 2016: how to attend the top sporting events
Whether you fancy a trip to Rio or have your sights on something closer to home, here is our indispensable guide to securing the most sought-after tickets of 2016

Giles Richards

02, Jan, 2016 @10:00 PM

Article image
The sporting year ahead: 18 dates for your diary in 2018
Russia’s ethical World Cup adventure, Nigeria’s bobsleigh stars at the Winter Olympics, and a welcome helping of London 2012 nostalgia

Observer Sport

31, Dec, 2017 @10:00 AM

BBC Sports Personality of the Year 2012 shortlist – in pictures

From Nicola Adams to Bradley Wiggins, a rundown of the nominees for this year's award

Tom Jenkins

26, Nov, 2012 @7:25 PM

Article image
Trans women should not have to reduce testosterone, say new IOC guidelines
The new IOC framework says there is no presumption of advantage for trans women, with the burden placed on individual sports to decide their own rules

Sean Ingle

16, Nov, 2021 @9:32 PM

Article image
BBC Sports Personality of the Year – as it happened!

Bradley Wiggins capped his amazing year by winning the Sports Personality of the Year award

Paul Owen

16, Dec, 2012 @6:18 PM

Article image
IOC’s new transgender guidance criticised as unfair towards female sport
Medical experts have claimed the International Olympic Committee’s new transgender framework ‘is not based on scientific principles’

Sean Ingle

17, Jan, 2022 @11:30 PM

Article image
Semenya’s Cas case and Tiger’s 15th – resolutions and predictions for 2019 | Sean Ingle
Expect English cricket to thrive, women’s football to have a record-breaking year and more controversy surrounding Russia in 2019, says Sean Ingle

Sean Ingle

30, Dec, 2018 @3:03 PM

Article image
Sports prospects of 2019: the women set to shine in the year ahead
From a generational track star to a 19-year-old prop, here are five of the best sporting prospects to look out for

Guardian sport

27, Dec, 2018 @2:19 PM