UK Sport failed to act on Shane Sutton 'corruption' allegations, emails suggest

  • Leaked emails seen from British Cycling whistleblower
  • Anonymous note contains claims about Sutton’s behaviour

UK Sport failed to investigate detailed claims from a British Cycling whistleblower who also alleged that “Shane Sutton is corrupt”, leaked emails to the Guardian suggest.

The anonymous email, which was titled “Confidential British Cycling Whistle Blower”, also contained several other claims about Sutton’s behaviour, nepotism and misappropriation of resources.

It was sent in February 2016 when Sutton ran British Cycling’s world‑class programme. Instead of looking into the allegations, UK Sport told the whistleblower to direct them to British Cycling.

The Guardian has also seen an email from UK Sport’s legal adviser to a member of its governance team and the performance adviser responsible for British Cycling, which recommended the whistleblower be given a “standard response” back.

“Hi guys, if Shane Sutton is still employed by British Cycling can you liaise with the sport on this one,” read the email. “I’ll send the UKS standard response – ie ‘queries like this should be addressed to the sport in the first instance, UK Sport is not a regulator …’”

The revelations will raise new questions about how UK Sport deals with whistleblowers and whether its policy of relying largely on sports to investigate complaints internally is right.

UK Sport insiders have said they were surprised the email was given to the British Cycling chief executive, Ian Drake, who then gave it to Sutton, as it potentially risked identifying the whistleblower.

In October , the whistleblower email was also revealed to have been a key part of the breakdown in relations between Sutton and the former British Cycling chief doctor Richard Freeman.

Freeman told his fitness-to-practice medical tribunal: “A whistleblower had written to UK Sport describing Shane Sutton’s behaviour, mainly about misappropriation of resources. These abuses were common knowledge to the staff … but we all felt powerless to stop it. Many staff in favour would receive sponsors’ road bikes for personal use, as did relatives and business associates of Shane Sutton.

“Shane Sutton burst into my room accusing Phil Burt and myself of being the author of the email, which he summarised to us. He demanded we hand over our phones and computers. We refused. Later he said to me it was either me or I was covering for Phil Burt and I had to tell him. I refused and he said that was it, ‘you’re finished’.”

Sutton, who left British Cycling in April 2016 after telling Jess Varnish “to go and have a baby” and other cyclists alleged a culture of fear at the velodrome, has strongly denied the version of events Freeman has given in evidence to the tribunal. In an interview with the Daily Telegraph in October, he accused Freeman of being a liar, adding: “He has got himself into something deep here and seen me as a way out.”

When giving evidence to the Freeman tribunal last year, Sutton also denied being a “habitual and serial liar” and “a doper with a doping history” and strenuously defended his behaviour during his time at British Cycling.

In a statement to the Guardian, UK Sport said: “On Friday 26 February 2016 we received an anonymous email which listed a number of complaints directed at the conduct of an employee at British Cycling. As the matter related to an employee of British Cycling, over whom UK Sport has no jurisdiction, and as it was received from an anonymous source, the matter was brought to the attention of British Cycling’s CEO to take appropriate action.”

Sign up to The Recap, our weekly email of editors’ picks.

When asked whether it was an error to not investigate further, UK Sport said its powers were limited. “UK Sport takes very seriously any complaint it receives about the behaviour of staff employed within the World Class System. It is, however, important to be clear that … we do not have regulatory or investigatory powers regarding internal sporting disputes or the affairs of sports governing bodies.”

UK Sport said it now had an integrity unit that could monitor whistleblower complaints, even though they would still go to the CEO of the sport in question. However, the recent British Gymnastics abuse scandal has also suggested many athletes are still scared to speak out against their sports for fear of the consequences.

In August, a government-backed Sport Integrity Forum was launched “to mend the cracks in the system” after the gymnastics abuse scandal and other concerns around bullying, discrimination and corruption in British sport. Tanni Grey-Thompson has called for an independent sports ombudsman to hold governing bodies to account and to protect athletes.

A British Cycling spokesman acknowledged mistakes had been made in 2016 but said things were very different now. “The independent cycling review was published in June 2017 with British Cycling immediately implementing a 39-point plan to address its findings and recommendations,” he said. “As part of this process we have substantially strengthened our whistle-blowing process.”

Contributor

Exclusive by Sean Ingle

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Andy Tennant backs Shane Sutton and culture of British Cycling before review
The Great Britain team pursuiter Andy Tennant has defended British Cycling’s medal-or-nothing culture, saying it should not be about being ‘all cuddly and care bears’

William Fotheringham

03, Apr, 2017 @9:30 PM

Article image
Sir Bradley Wiggins backs suspended coach Shane Sutton
Sir Bradley Wiggins denied any knowledge of a culture of discrimination in British Cycling and thinks Shane Sutton will be cleared of allegations of sexism and bullying

Barry Glendenning in Rio de Janeiro

14, Aug, 2016 @9:30 PM

Article image
Shane Sutton resigns as technical director of British Cycling
Shane Sutton has resigned as technical director of British Cycling, with the programmes director Andy Harrison taking temporary charge

Sean Ingle

27, Apr, 2016 @2:40 PM

Article image
Jess Varnish demands that British Cycling releases Shane Sutton data
Jess Varnish has made a formal request to see every text and email message sent about her by the former technical director Shane Sutton and fellow coaches Iain Dyer, Justin Grace and Jan van Eijden

Sean Ingle

14, Dec, 2016 @6:58 PM

Article image
British Cycling upholds complaint against Shane Sutton by Jess Varnish
British Cycling has upheld an allegation of discrimination made against the former technical director Shane Sutton by Jessica Varnish

Paul MacInnes

28, Oct, 2016 @4:15 PM

Article image
British Cycling’s Shane Sutton suspended over alleged comments on Paralympians
British Cycling’s technical director, Shane Sutton, faces being suspended pending a formal investigation into accusations that he called Paralympic cyclists ‘gimps’ and ‘wobblies’

Sean Ingle

26, Apr, 2016 @11:03 PM

Article image
Shane Sutton testimony at Freeman tribunal delayed by legal arguments
Shane Sutton’s testimony at the Dr Richard Freeman medical tribunal was delayed by hours of legal argument

Sean Ingle in Manchester

11, Nov, 2019 @5:29 PM

Article image
Jess Varnish ‘shocked’ by British Cycling’s verdict on Shane Sutton
Jess Varnish said she was ‘shocked and upset’ and would appeal against findings of internal investigation by British Cycling into former technical director Shane Sutton

Sean Ingle

07, Dec, 2016 @10:59 PM

Article image
Shane Sutton defends Bradley Wiggins’s use of TUEs for ‘marginal gains’
Bradley Wiggins’s former coach, Shane Sutton, has told a BBC documentary he regarded therapeutic use exemptions (TUEs) as a legitimate way of finding ‘marginal gains’

William Fotheringham

18, Nov, 2017 @12:07 AM

Article image
British Cycling must come clean over Shane Sutton and Jess Varnish
British Cycling’s latest mishap over Shane Sutton and Jess Varnish is yet another example of its lack of openness and transparency

Sean Ingle

08, Dec, 2016 @9:13 PM