British Olympians call for IOC to shelve ‘unfair’ transgender guidelines

• Survey of 15 female athletes finds frustration over current policy
• Group in favour of suspension of rules pending further research

The International Olympic Committee’s guidelines for transgender athletes are unfair on female athletes and should be suspended while more research is carried out, according to a group of former and current Team GB athletes surveyed by an academic.

In the survey of 15 female British Olympians, most of them answering anonymously, 11 also agreed with the view that “it can never be fair for transgender athletes who have been through male puberty to compete in female sport”, with another declining to answer.

Cathy Devine, who conducted the research and will present her findings at a conference at St Mary’s University in southwest London on Wednesday, says it is the first of its kind in this contentious area of sports policy.

Devine said those surveyed have won seven Olympic and 56 world championship medals between them. She defended the small number of athletes in the study, saying it was a starting point as athletes often did not want to speak out for fear of recriminations. She said she had used a standard qualitative research technique in the social sciences called “snowball sampling”, which is used to get information from of hard-to-reach groups and investigate difficult topics, and was not intended to be wholly representative.

Among those questioned – who came from track and field, swimming, rowing and modern pentathlon – were Tessa Sanderson, the 1984 Olympic javelin gold medallist, and Sharron Davies, who won a swimming silver in 1980, both of whom have already made their views known.

Devine also found widespread frustration among athletes with the IOC over a perceived lack of consultation before it published its latest transgender guidelines in 2015. The guidelines allow any transgender athlete to compete as a woman without undergoing surgery provided they have reduced their serum testosterone to 10nmols/L for at least 12 months.

After the guidelines were published the IOC said: “It is necessary to ensure insofar as possible that trans athletes are not excluded from the opportunity to participate in sporting competition. The overriding sporting objective is and remains the guarantee of fair competition. To require surgical anatomical changes as a precondition to participation is not necessary to preserve fair competition and may be inconsistent with developing legislation and notions of human rights.”

Those guidelines have drawn some criticism because they allow higher levels of testosterone for transgender athletes than the usual range for women, which is between 0.06 and 1.68nmols/L. The typical range for men is 7.7 to 29.4nmols/L. The IOC is close to introducing new guidelines requiring transgender athletes to lower their testosterone even further, to 5nmols/L, if they want to compete in women’s sport.

One respondent to Devine’s survey said: “New guidelines do not level the playing field, or protect our human rights to equal opportunities. There was not enough science-based research on elite athletes to make rules. It’s a live experiment where female athletes will lose out until the obvious is proved. Then it will be changed. That’s not fair.”

The transgender academic Joanna Harper, who advises the IOC, accepts more research is needed. However, she argued: “Transgender women after hormone therapy are taller, bigger and stronger on average than cisgender women. But that does not necessarily make it unfair. In high levels of sport, transgender women are substantially underrepresented. That indicates that whatever physical advantages transgender women have – and they certainly exist – they are not nearly as large as the sociological disadvantages.”

Devine also found that 14 out of 15 athletes surveyed wanted more research into the potential competitive advantages that transgender athletes may have – in particular how much of a “legacy effect” remains from the increased strength and bone density that comes with puberty, even if testosterone is later reduced. However, the athletes surveyed were divided on what the IOC should do in the future, with some in favour of a separate category for transgender athletes and others calling for an “open category” alongside a separate female category to ensure no one is excluded. Devine, who was a senior lecturer in the department of medical and sports sciences at the University of Cumbria for 22 years before becoming an independent researcher, said she hoped her research would be the first step of a wider consultation by the IOC, international sports federations and governing bodies.

Contributor

Sean Ingle

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘Conflicting opinions’: IOC’s transgender guidelines delayed again until 2022
IOC has revealed its new transgender guidelines have been delayed again until after Beijing 2022, three years later than planned

Sean Ingle

20, Sep, 2021 @5:29 PM

Article image
IOC’s new transgender guidance criticised as unfair towards female sport
Medical experts have claimed the International Olympic Committee’s new transgender framework ‘is not based on scientific principles’

Sean Ingle

17, Jan, 2022 @11:30 PM

Article image
IOC admits guidelines for transgender athletes are not fit for purpose
The International Olympic Committee has admitted its current guidelines for transgender athletes are not fit for purpose – and says it plans to release a new one within the next two months

Sean Ingle in Tokyo

30, Jul, 2021 @1:39 PM

Article image
Why calls for athletes to compete as a homogenised group should be resisted | Sean Ingle
In response to the impact of transgender athletes some advocate the sexes competing together, a move others argue would banish women from top-level sport

Sean Ingle

10, Dec, 2018 @11:00 AM

Article image
IOC delays new transgender guidelines after scientists fail to agree
Draft proposals by the IOC for transgender athletes have ‘gone around the houses’ and it is thought unlikely a new consensus position will be reached before Tokyo 2020

Exclusive by Sean Ingle

24, Sep, 2019 @6:23 PM

Article image
Mixed reception for new guidelines on transgender inclusion in sport
Some sports governing bodies welcome report, but Stonewall says guidance ‘extremely harmful’

Sean Ingle

30, Sep, 2021 @9:09 PM

Article image
New guidelines for transgender participation unveiled by UK sports councils
There is no magic solution that balances the inclusion of trans women in female sport while guaranteeing competitive fairness and safety, new guidelines for sport across the UK conclude

Exclusive by Sean Ingle Chief sports reporter

29, Sep, 2021 @9:30 PM

Article image
Sport’s trans issue is here to stay. But at last, the debate is starting to change | Sean Ingle
Swimming is the latest sport to become embroiled in discord but there are some signs of courteous, informed discussion too

Sean Ingle

13, Dec, 2021 @8:00 AM

Article image
ECB’s transgender review could result in more medical-driven policy
The England and Wales Cricket Board is reviewing its transgender policy before its £20m semi-professional women’s competition starts next year

Sean Ingle

14, Aug, 2019 @4:18 PM

Article image
Trans women should not have to reduce testosterone, say new IOC guidelines
The new IOC framework says there is no presumption of advantage for trans women, with the burden placed on individual sports to decide their own rules

Sean Ingle

16, Nov, 2021 @9:32 PM