Celebrity boycotts and half-time headaches: is the Super Bowl already in crisis?

Sports and advertising’s biggest night has tried to rise above politics, but has recently been dragged into the culture wars

The Super Bowl is traditionally the biggest night for sports, entertainment and advertising in the US,but in the wake of intense politicisation of the NFL, Super Bowl LIII is shaping up to be a fierce battle, not just of sporting prowess, but in the embittered culture wars.

The event is still three months away but organisers are having trouble securing big name performers, advertisers are unsure whether or not to lean into the politics now surrounding the NFL or eschew the event entirely, and politicians are seizing upon the occasion for partisan squabbling.

“The Super Bowl is really the last water cooler event we have,” said Mark Wenneker, chief creative officer US of MullenLowe, the firm behind the memorable E-Trade spot during last year’s Super Bowl.

“There aren’t a lot of moments we have like that any more. The Oscars is close but it’s not the same.”

Figuring out how to remind people of that shared experience will be a challenge for advertising firms like Wenneker’s. Some may avoid the potential political landmine of aligning their brands with the NFL too closely altogether.

The latest salvo arrived last week when Amy Schumer announced she would refuse to appear in a Super Bowl ad in protest against the league’s treatment of the controversial former quarterback Colin Kaepernick. The one-time star player, who is currently suing the league for collusion in denying him a spot on a team, has not played in a game since the end of the 2016 season, at the beginning of which he began his protest about racial inequality in America.

View this post on Instagram

Friday thought. I wonder why more white players aren’t kneeling. Once you witness the truly deep inequality and endless racism people of color face in our country, not to mention the police brutality and murders. Why not kneel next to your brothers? Otherwise how are you not complicit? I think it would be cool if @maroon5 backed out of super bowl like @badgalriri Did. I personally told my reps I wouldn’t do a Super Bowl commercial this year. I know it must sound like a privilege ass sacrifice but it’s all i got. Hitting the nfl with the advertisers is the only way to really hurt them. I know opposing the nfl is like opposing the nra. Very tough, but don’t you want to be proud of how you’re living? Stand up for your brothers and sisters of color. And the hottest thing a guy can do is get down on one knee. Not to propose but to reject the treatment of his teammates by this country. Anyone who says its disrespectful to our military please read up on the fact that a lot of veterans are proud of what @kaepernick7 is doing and fully support him. What are your thoughts?

A post shared by @ amyschumer on

“I wonder why more white players aren’t kneeling,” Schumer wrote on Instagram. “Once you witness the truly deep inequality and endless racism people of color face in our country, not to mention the police brutality and murders. Why not kneel next to your brothers? Otherwise how are you not complicit?”

Schumer, who appeared in a 2016 Bud Light Super Bowl commercial, said she hoped others would follow the example of Rihanna, who reportedly declined an invitation to perform at the half-time show.

The Los Angeles pop rock band Maroon 5 has reportedly been slated to fill the spot, although the league has yet to announce its plans publicly. Their appearance won’t be devoid of controversy either, however, considering their most recent hit, Girls Like You, features Cardi B, who would be a natural fit for a guest spot at the Super Bowl were she not such a vocal supporter of Kaepernick.

Asked last year whether she would ever take the stage at the Super Bowl the artist said she would refuse until “they hire Colin Kaepernick back”. At the MTV Video Music Awards last year she came out strongly in support of the former quarterback. “Colin Kaepernick, as long as you kneel with us, we’re gonna be standing for you, baby.”

Adding further complications to the performance is the displeasure many music fans, particularly in Atlanta where the game will be held, have expressed over the way the city’s rich musical legacy is being ignored.

A brief list of musicians more fitting for Atlanta's Super Bowl than Maroon 5 pic.twitter.com/TF8oTEkADa

— Jason Kirk (@JasonKirkSBN) September 19, 2018

“The game will be played in Atlanta, the blackest big city in America, a driving force behind modern pop music and home of legends such as OutKast, Usher, Ludacris, T.I. and current supergroup Migos,” Jesse Washington of the Undefeated wrote this week.

“Jermaine Dupri alone has produced enough hits to fill three halftimes. Native son Lil Jon’s ‘Turn Down For What’ is a sports arena classic with more than 800 million YouTube views,” Ludacris himself posted around the time the Maroon 5 rumors surfaced.

Unsurprisingly, Donald Trump has continued to keep his displeasure with the league’s handling of the protest issue front and center, claiming, incorrectly, that TV ratings were down this year.

Wow, NFL first game ratings are way down over an already really bad last year comparison. Viewership declined 13%, the lowest in over a decade. If the players stood proudly for our Flag and Anthem, and it is all shown on broadcast, maybe ratings could come back? Otherwise worse!

— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) September 9, 2018

Ratings had in fact risen 4% over last year through the first six weeks of the season.

In another tweet in September, Trump turned his ire toward Nike, who recently partnered with Kaepernick on an ad campaign.

“Just like the NFL, whose ratings have gone WAY DOWN, Nike is getting absolutely killed with anger and boycotts. I wonder if they had any idea that it would be this way? As far as the NFL is concerned, I just find it hard to watch, and always will, until they stand for the FLAG!” he wrote, also incorrectly. Nike sales reportedly surged after the campaign ran.

Just like the NFL, whose ratings have gone WAY DOWN, Nike is getting absolutely killed with anger and boycotts. I wonder if they had any idea that it would be this way? As far as the NFL is concerned, I just find it hard to watch, and always will, until they stand for the FLAG!

— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) September 5, 2018

Nike did not respond to a request about their intentions of airing Kaepernick spots during the Super Bowl, but the potential for generating further buzz around the brand on advertising’s biggest stage may prove irresistible. Whether or not other brands will follow suit by attempting to leverage the political division in the country over this issue and so many others remains to be seen. Simply advertising with the NFL may be seen by some as support for one side or another experts say.

“All endorsement is support for the NFL and the cultural role the Super Bowl plays in society,” Jonathan Mildenhall of the consultancy TwentyFirstCenturyBrand told the Wall Street Journal recently in a piece titled Just advertising during the Super Bowl could appear political for brands. “It used to be proudly middle America. Now it has a divided narrative.”

“I think we are in a civil war in the culture right now. We’re red versus blue,” said Wenneker, although he doesn’t expect many brands will lean into the controversy this year. “I don’t think we’re going to see a lot of preachy ads from brands that tap into what’s going on out there in the world. I think what we may see is stuff that makes people want to laugh again.”

“I don’t see this being the time for that statement,” Wenneker said. “I may be wrong. I feel like people are so drenched in politics 24 hours a day and football just needs to be football.”

Contributor

Luke O'Neil

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Super Bowl 2019: everything but the football – as it happened
Maroon 5, Travis Scott and Big Boi appear at half-time – plus, see the biggest ads as they air

Benjamin Lee and Jake Nevins

04, Feb, 2019 @3:26 AM

Article image
'I couldn’t be a sellout': Rihanna says she turned down Super Bowl over Kaepernick
Rihanna has confirmed she turned down the chance to headline February’s Super Bowl halftime show in solidarity with Colin Kaepernick

Guardian sport

09, Oct, 2019 @4:30 PM

Article image
Super Bowl: Donald Trump would have 'hard time' letting son play football
In an interview broadcast on the biggest day in the NFL calendar Donald Trump has said he would have a ‘hard time’ letting his son play football

Tom Lutz in Atlanta

03, Feb, 2019 @10:10 PM

Article image
The Joy of Six: Super Bowl scandals | DJ Gallo
From an unfortunate nighttime visit in Miami to Justin Timberlake and Janet Jackson, half a dozen moments the league would rather forget

DJ Gallo

31, Jan, 2017 @10:00 AM

Super Bowl ads the networks rejected

Controversial adverts deemed inappropriate by the US TV networks

Sarah Hughes

25, Jan, 2010 @12:05 AM

Article image
The 10 greatest Super Bowl half-time shows - ranked!
From Beyoncé to Bruce, half-time at the NFL’s big season finale is the 12-minute stadium set that’s become a pop cultural milestone. But whose show was the MVP?

Alexis Petridis

01, Feb, 2018 @1:30 PM

Article image
Danger! 'Avocado hand' is on the rise – here's how to stay safe this Super Bowl
Don’t be a dip lover injured by avocado. To avoid injury, cut lengthways, effect a quarter-turn, cut again, and twist. Voila!

Poppy Noor

30, Jan, 2020 @7:04 PM

Article image
Star names say no to Super Bowl show in support of police brutality protest
Rihanna and Cardi B among those declining to perform at half-time over NFL’s dispute with star Colin Kaepernick

Edward Helmore in New York

06, Jan, 2019 @8:59 AM

Article image
Super Bowl 51: what you need to know
Get up to speed before the biggest night in American football

Sam Morris

31, Jan, 2017 @11:00 AM

Article image
Beyoncé on song in Super Bowl half-time show spectacular

Emma G Keller: The lights went out, Beyoncé stormed onstage to sing live, and shortly after she'd gone the lights went out again

Emma Gilbey Keller

04, Feb, 2013 @2:07 AM