Are we right to demonise drink? | Letters

Doctors should focus more on unhealthy diets than alcohol, says David Roberts. But Dr Sheila Gilheany argues for greater awareness of the risks of drinking

I often have this fantasy that I enter a supermarket where the only products available for purchase are those that are good for us. Imagine the gaps – no cakes, no crisps, no sweets, no processed food full of additives and E numbers, no fizzy drinks full of sugar or dangerous additives (Health Canada recommends limiting alcohol to just 2 drinks per week, 18 January).

I enjoy alcohol, though I’m currently also enjoying dry January. I can’t remember the last time a doctor or a dental survey asked me how many units of burgers, crisps or cakes I normally consume in a week.

I exercise regularly, and normally drink sensibly, with several non-drink days a week. I am a fairly strong and fit 72-year-old who, up to now, has not bothered our beleaguered NHS much. I resent being given warnings about how much to drink while feeling that too little notice is given to obesity and poor diet in our society. Have we really got this one right?
David Roberts

• Alcohol is responsible for at least 1,000 cancer cases every year in Ireland, with one in eight breast cancer cases arising from alcohol use. Even one to two drinks per day increases the risk of developing cancer, and that risk is the same whether those drinks are wine, spirits or beer. Unfortunately, there is a very low level of public awareness that alcohol has been classed as a Group 1 carcinogen, meaning it is carcinogenic to humans. That is why Ireland has passed legislation that provides for health information labels on alcohol products, including warnings about cancer, liver disease and the danger of drinking in pregnancy. It is unsurprising that the alcohol industry, which promotes its products with carefully crafted myths of good times for all, is objecting to the mandatory provision of facts (Anger brews in Italy over Ireland’s plans for alcohol health warnings, 12 January).
Dr Sheila Gilheany
CEO, Alcohol Action Ireland

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Cut alcohol intake to just a quarter pint of beer a day, experts advise

Researchers say in report that drastic reduction in guideline amounts could save 4,600 lives a year in England

Denis Campbell, health correspondent

30, May, 2012 @10:30 PM

Article image
Put calorie labels on beer, wine and spirits, say public health experts
Alcoholic drinks are fuelling obesity epidemic and most have no idea how many calories their drinks contain

Sarah Boseley, health editor

31, Oct, 2014 @5:59 AM

Article image
Do professionals who drink need to admit they have a problem?
Higher earners drink more than people in routine jobs and could be harming themselves despite boozing at levels considered socially acceptable

Emine Saner

02, May, 2018 @4:19 PM

Article image
‘I feel so good I may never drink again!’ Readers on their success – or failure – during dry January
Readers explain whether they looked, felt and slept better – or if they turned back to alcohol to cheer up a miserable month

Guardian readers

01, Feb, 2021 @11:40 AM

Article image
Bigger wine glasses make us drink too much, says researcher
Today’s glasses, 450ml compared with 65ml 300 years ago, encourage consumption, Cambridge scientist tells Hay festival

Mark Brown Arts correspondent

28, May, 2017 @3:42 PM

Article image
No icy lager, no sundowners: could you handle a sober holiday?
For many of us, a getaway means sun, sea, sand and… alcohol. But what if you drink so much at home that a break is a chance to go booze-free?

Ed Cumming

21, Aug, 2021 @10:00 AM

Article image
Wine and spirits firms warn of Christmas alcohol shortage in UK
Group of 48 companies say transport secretary must do more to resolve HGV driver crisis

Rob Davies

24, Nov, 2021 @11:13 AM

Article image
'Low and no' to extreme craft: the drink trends for 2019
Sober millennials mean the alcohol industry has to innovate to tempt consumers to the bar

Rob Davies

04, Jan, 2019 @1:53 PM

Article image
Hospital admissions linked to alcohol rise to more than a million in year
Doctors repeat call for alcohol pricing rule to deter heavy drinkers as Alcohol Concern warns of lack of help for addiction

James Meikle

30, May, 2013 @5:32 PM

Article image
UK alcohol sales fall despite rise in home drinking
Beer down 10% and wine 5% as increased online and supermarket sales fail to offset pub revenue collapse

Rob Davies

19, Dec, 2020 @6:00 AM