Gender identity treatment needs greater caution | Letter

Dr David Bell, former staff governor at the Tavistock and Portman NHS foundation trust, on its Gender Identity Development Service

When considering the interim report by Dr Hilary Cass on gender identity services for children and young people, your article overemphasises the long waiting list and underemphasises that it was a waiting list for the wrong treatment, as Cass makes clear (‘A contentious place’: the inside story of Tavistock’s NHS gender identity clinic, 19 January).

A clinician you quote says some staff left the Gender Identity Development Service (Gids) “in a destructive way”. They did not – they raised serious concerns with their managers which resulted in their intimidation. These concerns were borne out by the Cass review – particularly that as a result of the ideological penetration of Gids, it abandoned clinical neutrality and downplayed the significance of other serious conditions in this patient group. The Cass report makes clear that these children have been disadvantaged and that there is a lack of evidence for the “Dutch Approach” to treating them, involving puberty blockers.

Almost all children on puberty blockers continue to opposite-sex hormones; an unknown number progress to major surgery. The ethical weight of the decision to commence the medical pathway is freighted with that knowledge.

The employment tribunal case brought by Sonia Appleby, child safeguarding lead for the Tavistock, revealed an intimidating culture dismissive of risk. And Keira Bell did not “sue” the Tavistock, but won a judicial review on the issue of consent. While this was overturned, serious concerns raised by the judges on clinical governance – record-keeping, complete absence of follow-up etc – still stand. The CQC found Gids “inadequate”.

Your article makes no reference to the growing group of detransitioners – those who regret the irreversible damage done and feel that their “treatment” was based on ideology, not appropriate clinical concern. Many suffered from confusion in relation to same-sex attraction; when I investigated Gids, this was largely ignored.

A child’s wishes must be taken seriously, but can be only one factor in reaching an overall decision about their best interests, in a highly charged and complex situation. Given the uncertainty surrounding diagnosis and treatment of gender dysphoria, the UK should, like Finland, Sweden and France, follow a more cautious path; we should end medication and medical transition for children and adolescents now.
David Bell
Former staff governor, Tavistock and Portman NHS foundation trust

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
A full exploration of the rise in gender-questioning girls is much needed | Letters
Letters: Readers respond to an article on the huge rise in the number of adolescent biological girls seeking referrals to gender clinics in recent years. Plus, the gender-neutral pronoun ‘per’

30, Nov, 2022 @5:42 PM

Article image
Why gender identity should be left out of the ‘conversion therapy’ ban | Letter
Letter: Evidence shows that the majority of gender-distressed children who are not ‘affirmed’ in their cross-sex identification outgrow those feelings, write Maya Forstater and Helen Joyce


20, Apr, 2022 @4:57 PM

Article image
‘A contentious place’: the inside story of Tavistock’s NHS gender identity clinic
Clinicians and young people speak about the pioneering and controversial London facility now facing closure

Libby Brooks

19, Jan, 2023 @3:00 PM

Article image
Puberty blocker ruling will not help trans teens | Letters
Letters: There is already a suitable competency test in medical law for children under the age of 16, writes Steven Walker, while the mother of a transgender child fears the impact the court decision will have on her daughter


02, Dec, 2020 @5:38 PM

Article image
Divisions that remain on transgender issues | Letters
Letters: Dr Eve Jeffrey on the power dynamics in any discussion of trans rights and Claire Loneragan on women’s sex-based rights


23, Jun, 2022 @5:01 PM

Article image
Transgender rights are not a threat to feminism | Letters
Letters: Readers Readers respond to the Guardian’s editorial, a recent letter, and other media coverage of the debate surrounding the consultation on reform of the Gender Recognition Act


18, Oct, 2018 @5:39 PM

Article image
Differing perspectives on transgender rights | Letters
Letters: Readers respond to an article by Suzanne Moore


04, Mar, 2020 @6:30 PM

Article image
A non-binary Joan of Arc? Great. Now theatre should take the next step | Letter
Letter: Louise Branch calls for playwrights to portray male historical figures such as Henry V as non-binary or trans


05, Sep, 2022 @5:08 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on banning 'conversion therapy': protect everyone | Editorial
Editorial: These cruel, stigmatising practices should be comprehensively proscribed


17, Apr, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
I fear for my trans daughter’s future in the UK | Letter
Letter: The father of an 11-year-old fears that removing all hope of being medicated will lead to needless suffering for her and other young trans people

31, Jan, 2023 @6:25 PM