UK menopause law change rejected as it ‘could discriminate against men’

Ministers block proposal to make menopause a ‘protected characteristic’ under Equality Act

Proposals to change UK legislation to protect the rights of women experiencing menopause have been in part rejected by the government due to fears such a move would discriminate against men.

The cross-party women and equalities committee last July published a report focusing on menopause and the workplace, which included a recommendation to make menopause a “protected characteristic” under the Equality Act.

Protected characteristics are a specific set of characteristics that it is illegal to discriminate against, and include age, disability and race among others.

But in its official response to the report, published on Tuesday, the government rejected the proposal, warning of “unintended consequences which may inadvertently create new forms of discrimination, for example, discrimination risks towards men suffering from long-term medical conditions”.

In its response, the government also rejected calls for a large-scale pilot of menopause leave in England, adding it was not seen as “necessary” and could turn out to be “counterproductive”.

Reacting to the response, the committee chair, the Conservative MP Caroline Nokes, questioned the government’s commitment to the issue of menopause.

In a letter to the health minister Maria Caulfield, Nokes said she was disappointed that “very little new work has been committed to by the government” in response to the committee’s report, as she expressed concern that the government had ignored what she termed the “significant evidence base” for menopause being seen as a “protected characteristic”.

Nokes, who in her letter to Caulfield noted that the reply to the report was three and a half months late, said it was a “missed opportunity to protect vast numbers of talented and experienced women from leaving the workforce, and leaves me unconvinced that menopause is a government priority”.

“The evidence to our inquiry was crystal clear that urgent action was needed across healthcare and work settings to properly address women’s needs, yet government progress has been glacial and its response complacent,” she said in a statement.

“Its refusal to even consult on reforming equalities law doesn’t make sense and we urge it to look again.”

A government spokesperson said: “We recognise that the menopause can be a challenging time for women, which is why we have put women’s health at the top of the agenda as part of the first-ever women’s health strategy for England.

“We are implementing an ambitious programme of work with the NHS to improve menopause care so all women can access the support they need.

“We encourage employers to be compassionate and flexible to the needs of their employees, and are committed to supporting more flexible working patterns – having consulted on making flexible working the default unless employers have good reasons not to.”

The report comes as a poll suggests healthcare for women in the UK is as bad as Kazakhstan and worse than that provided in China. Britain ranked lower than the US, Australia, New Zealand, France and Germany in the 2021 Hologic Global Women’s Health Index.

Inadequate access to preventative care, such as screening for cancer, diabetes and blood pressure, diagnosis of causes of pain and mental health support were cited by analysts as being behind the UK’s poor outcome.

The UK scored 60 out of 100 – three points lower than the previous year – in the index, which is based on a survey of more than 127,000 people by Gallup. The score places it on a par with Kazakhstan, Slovenia, Kosovo, Poland and Ireland.


Jamie Grierson

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
MPs call for menopause health checks at 45 and free HRT in England
All-party group report on menopause also calls for more workplace support and training for health workers

Andrew Gregory and Linda Geddes

12, Oct, 2022 @5:00 AM

Article image
Doctors warn against over-medicalising menopause after UK criticism
Seeing natural event as hormone deficiency requiring treatment could increase women’s anxiety, say medics

Linda Geddes Science correspondent

15, Jun, 2022 @10:30 PM

Article image
Home menopause tests are waste of time and money, say doctors
Urine tests not predictive enough to tell whether a woman is going through the phase, experts warn

Jamie Grierson

10, Jun, 2022 @8:19 AM

Article image
‘I want to give mid-life women a voice’: Labour’s Anneliese Dodds on menopause, careers and the WI
The party chair discusses why Labour wants to attract female voters who are juggling child, parent and health care on top of demanding jobs

Jessica Elgot Deputy political editor

03, Mar, 2023 @2:00 PM

Article image
MPs call for menopause to be protected characteristic in UK Equality Act
Amendment would include duty for employers to provide reasonable adjustments for menopausal employees

Caroline Davies

27, Jul, 2022 @11:01 PM

Article image
Menopause, endometriosis and more: four ways England is failing women
As ministers plan to publish the first women’s health strategy we look at where things are going wrong – and why

Hannah Devlin Science correspondent

02, Jun, 2022 @2:30 PM

Article image
Empower women to manage menopause | Letters
Letters: Educating women is only the first step – employers are also critical, says Eleanor Nouhov. Plus Laura Collins on getting help for her perimenopause struggles and Helen Hucker on the need for more targeted treatment


20, Jun, 2022 @3:39 PM

Article image
It’s the menopause, stupid – why Britain can’t afford to ignore women’s health | Kate Muir
Failing to properly support women through the menopause is disastrous for the UK economy. That’s why we’re calling for change, says author Kate Muir

Kate Muir

17, Oct, 2022 @9:40 AM

Article image
What can I do if I can’t get HRT?
British Menopause Society releases equivalence guide to help women during England’s drug shortage

Hannah Devlin Science correspondent

29, Apr, 2022 @3:54 PM

Article image
Covid vaccinations’ effect on periods and menopause needs more research | Letters
Letters: Rebecca May and Jen Fritz on the menstrual problems that they and their friends have had after having coronavirus jabs


28, Jul, 2022 @4:55 PM