Wes Streeting’s plan to turn GPs into salaried NHS staff is misguided | Letters

Salaried GP Joe McFarlane says the Labour proposal is shortsighted and raises several big questions, but Dr Jeremy Bending thinks it would improve quality of care

As a salaried GP and Labour voter, I was alarmed to read Wes Streeting’s comments that he would “tear up the contract” to make all GPs salaried employees (Report, 7 January). Some of his proposals are sensible – increasing the number of medical school places, reforming pension rules, and having more nurses and physiotherapists in surgeries. However, at a time when record numbers of GPs are leaving the profession, and a third of current GPs are considering doing so, it seems bizarre to set up this confrontation.

Mr Streeting is right that increased investment should be met with improvements in standards of care, but this proposal is shortsighted and raises several big questions. With partners going above and beyond, how will their goodwill and hard work be replaced if they are essentially demoted to being employees? Furthermore, how will the managerial, educational and clinical expertise of partners be replaced when they inevitably leave medicine earlier than they would have done?

With a limited budget, how does the government plan to compensate GP partners, some of whom have invested tens of thousands of pounds of their own money into their surgeries? Lastly, who will make decisions about hiring, practice policies, quality improvement and much more in the absence of partners? Will it be externally hired managers with no stake in the surgery or awareness of its needs?

Mr Streeting has spoken of his own experience as a patient, and these experiences are invaluable in improving standards of care. However, his words here, alongside statements like “vaccinations are money for old rope and a good money spinner” (which is false) make it obvious that he has never worked in the health service, that he misunderstands some of the big issues facing general practice, and that he vastly underestimates the value of partnerships. We need politicians who understand (or are willing to learn to understand) the reality of problems facing general practice. Mr Streeting may paint statements like this as obstructive and resistant, but his is a misguided and flawed plan.
Joe McFarlane

• The statement from the shadow health secretary, Wes Streeting, that a Labour government would make GPs salaried NHS staff is excellent news. In one move, this would improve the access to and quality of care: for their patients (most of whom are unaware that GP practices are run as a business); those GPs who are already salaried by the practices but not partners (the great majority of whom are female GPs); the practice nurses (who bear a huge amount of the practice work); and receptionists, secretarial staff and many others who contribute to the work of a practice. Labour should then consider more effective policing of time spent by hospital consultants engaged in private practice compared with their NHS contract.
Dr Jeremy Bending
Retired consultant physician, Amble, Northumberland

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Labour ‘would tear up contract with GPs’ and make them salaried NHS staff
Planned overhaul for GP surgeries puts party on collision course with British Medical Association

Harry Taylor

07, Jan, 2023 @10:30 AM

Article image
Labour’s reforms will save the struggling NHS from its current crisis | Letter
Letter: To prevent millions of working-class patients being left behind in a two-tier healthcare system, we need a change from the status quo, says shadow health secretary Wes Streeting

22, Feb, 2023 @6:08 PM

Article image
Wes Streeting claims BMA ‘hostile’ towards Labour’s NHS plans
Doctors’ union criticises shadow health secretary for ‘incredibly disappointing’ comments over funding and primary care

Peter Walker

11, Dec, 2022 @11:18 AM

Article image
If patients could bypass GPs to see specialists, the NHS would grind to a halt | Letters
Letter: NHS psychiatrist Dr Melanie Knowles agrees that the current system is flawed, but says the answer is not to dispense with referrals from GPs, who are experts in diagnosis and triage

16, Jan, 2023 @12:05 PM

Article image
NHS operations cancelled in England due to staff shortages double in three years
Labour highlights issue to back up pledge to invest heavily in addressing shortages

Jessica Elgot Deputy political editor

12, Dec, 2022 @10:30 PM

Article image
Doctors’ pensions: Labour would abolish cap, says Wes Streeting
Scrapping of ‘crazy’ cap that leads to early retirements would ‘inevitably save lives’, says shadow health secretary

Nadeem Badshah

02, Sep, 2022 @11:05 PM

Article image
Misguided goals as the NHS becomes a political football | @guardianletters
Letters: When will politicians stop acting like little princes whose ideas have to be better than anyone’s have been before?

02, Oct, 2014 @6:58 PM

Article image
We medical staff are doing our best despite the waste | Letters
Letters from GP Dr Paul Rybinski and registered nurse Gay Lee


08, Jan, 2018 @7:08 PM

Article image
NHS being hit by cuts to beds as well as to social care | Letters
Letters: One can only conclude that Hunt’s cuts to staff and resources to support the beds is deliberate policy to run down the NHS ready for privatisation as an insurance-funded two-tier system


03, Mar, 2017 @5:53 PM

Article image
NHS crisis grows as young Britons turn their backs on family doctors
Growing number of 18- to 34-year-olds ‘head straight to A&E’ as health service fails to match new lifestyles

Toby Helm, Daniel Boffey and Jamie Doward

20, Dec, 2014 @9:23 PM