Health unions refuse to give evidence to ‘rigged’ NHS pay review system

Officials from 14 health unions want to hold direct talks with ministers to agree pay rises for NHS staff

The system for setting NHS staff pay is under threat after health unions refused to submit evidence to the two bodies that advise ministers on how big annual increases should be.

The role and credibility of both the NHS pay review body (NHSPRB) and the review body on doctors’ and dentists’ remuneration (DDRB) have been brought into question by the move.

Unions representing more than 1 million nurses, ambulance workers and other personnel have refused to submit joint evidence in the usual way to the NHSPRB about the pay for 2023/24 unless ministers first settle the bitter dispute over this year’s salary increase that has triggered a wave of strikes.

The British Medical Association, the main doctors’ trade union, said it was also taking similar action and would not submit evidence to the DDRB because “the process is rigged from the start”.

Health unions’ trust in the pay review system has become strained in recent years as a result of recommendations from the review bodies leading to NHS personnel receiving rises below the level of inflation at the time and thus suffering year-on-year real-terms falls in their income.

But their faith has collapsed in recent weeks. That has coincided with the health secretary, Steve Barclay, repeatedly justifying his refusal to increase his offer of a £1,400-a-head salary rise for 2022/23 by insisting that he cannot go beyond what the NHSPRB recommended, even though it proposed the £1,400 sum before Russia’s invasion of Ukraine sent inflation soaring.

The unions’ break with the longstanding system of setting NHS pay comes as the Labour government in Wales is reportedly preparing to offer health service staff there on Thursday a one-off payment – reportedly of £1,000 – to resolve the row over their 2022/23 pay deal.

Some union officials said privately that £1,000 might be enough to persuade their members to stop striking but others believed that the sum may still be too little to break the deadlock.

The Scottish government has submitted a “best and final” offer to NHS staff of a £2,205 pay rise for 2022/23. However, while some unions have accepted it, others – including the Royal College of Nursing – have rejected it.

The Westminster government is also looking at the idea of a one-off payment, which would be non-consolidated and therefore not added to staff’s baseline salaries, to end the impasse over 2022/23. However, recent reports said that neither the prime minister, Rishi Sunak, nor Jeremy Hunt, the chancellor, were keen on it.

The NHSPRB’s eight members are chosen by ministers and include no union representatives, leading to claims that it is not truly independent of government.

Representatives of 14 health unions said they would not submit evidence about 2023/24 to it because “the lengthy pay review process is not able to deliver what is needed right now”. They want to hold direct talks with ministers to agree pay rises instead.

“The pay review body process doesn’t fit the current context”, said Sara Gorton, Unison’s head of health and the chair of the NHS group of unions.

Prof Philip Banfield, the chair of the BMA, said: ‘The medical profession has long lost faith in the fairness or independence of this process. Neither junior doctors nor consultants will even submit evidence this year, knowing the process is rigged from the start.”

No 10 said they were disappointed that the health unions, which wanted to set up the pay review bodies, have decided not to take part in the process.

The PM’s official spokesperson said: “It is disappointing that they have taken this step. We do think it’s in everyone’s interests for the unions to contribute.”

He said the government had committed to “properly” consider a one-off payment and backdating the 2023/24 pay deal to this month as potential ways of ending the dispute.

Meanwhile, physiotherapists will soon join nurses and ambulance staff in striking in pursuit of a better pay deal for this year.

They will stage their first strike at 30 NHS trusts in England on 26 January with a second planned – this time at 60 trusts – unless Barclay increases the £1,400 offer.

Contributors

Denis Campbell Health policy editor and Pippa Crerar Political editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Health unions call off strike action in Scotland after new pay offer
Hospital and ambulance service staff represented by Unite and Unison agree to deal brokered by ministers

Severin Carrell Scotland editor

12, Dec, 2022 @5:41 PM

Article image
Three health unions call off strikes in England and agree to pay talks
GMB, Unison and Chartered Society of Physiotherapy take up offer of talks after government concessions

Heather Stewart

03, Mar, 2023 @5:28 PM

Article image
Nurses to strike in England, Wales and Northern Ireland after talks fail
Royal College of Nursing leader criticises ‘belligerence’ in meeting with Steve Barclay at which ministers refused to discuss pay

Kiran Stacey, Aubrey Allegretti, Jessica Elgot and Dan Sabbagh

12, Dec, 2022 @11:06 PM

Article image
Sunak’s ‘intransigence’ on pay will lead to more NHS strikes, warns top doctor
Exclusive: BMA council chair says medics will have no option but to stage more industrial action until ministers make ‘credible offer’

Andrew Gregory Health editor

11, Aug, 2023 @5:59 PM

Article image
Nurses’ strike could delay surgery for up to 3m people in England
Those living in south-west, north-west and London most likely to have care disrupted, research suggests

Denis Campbell Health policy editor

11, Nov, 2022 @5:30 PM

Article image
Junior doctors blame health secretary for triggering strikes across England
Steve Barclay accused of ‘wasting months’ by failing to meet unions and being dismissive of their demands for improved pay

Denis Campbell Health policy editor

14, Mar, 2023 @6:00 AM

Article image
Rishi Sunak appears ready to try to tough out further wave of NHS strikes
High-risk tactic increases likelihood of combined stoppages by nurses and junior doctors in England

Peter Walker Political correspondent

16, Apr, 2023 @5:13 PM

Article image
Nurses to cut short strike as court rules second day of action unlawful
Ruling prompts RCN leader Pat Cullen to condemn government for ‘taking its own nurses to court’

Daniel Boffey Chief reporter

27, Apr, 2023 @4:22 PM

Article image
Union leader calls Rishi Sunak deluded as NHS pay row escalates
GMB’s Rachel Harrison says staff will not be ‘fobbed off’ by PM ‘kicking the can’ into next year’s pay round

Denis Campbell, Kiran Stacey and Rachel Hall

06, Feb, 2023 @7:19 PM

Article image
Ministers could offer one-off payments as way to end public sector strikes
Strikes must be called off for talks to start, says No 10, as ministers given more freedom to talk to unions

Jessica Elgot, Denis Campbell, Heather Stewart, Pippa Crerar and Richard Adams

22, Feb, 2023 @7:22 PM