Ministers could offer one-off payments as way to end public sector strikes

Strikes must be called off for talks to start, says No 10, as ministers given more freedom to talk to unions

Ministers have been given the freedom to talk to unions about pay settlements that could include backdated or one-off payments as ways to end the escalating series of public sector strikes.

But Downing Street said it was critical unions agreed to call off planned industrial action before talks could begin, as the Royal College of Nursing (RCN) did on Tuesday.

It is understood that the Cabinet Office has given guidance to secretaries of state about the new parameters within which they can negotiate. They underline the expectation that new efficiency reforms will be announced in return for pay deals and the pre-condition that planned strike action must be cancelled for intensive negotiations to commence.

However, the Treasury has said any pay increases above the 3.5% maximum planned for 2023-24 must be funded from existing budgets, which could force departments to find billions in savings.

For example, if NHS staff do receive a 5% uplift next year, the Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) and NHS England could have to find about £1.8bn from their budgets to bridge the gap between that amount and the 3.5% the government said on Tuesday was all it could afford.


“It is up to secretaries of state how that works in practice,” one Whitehall source said. “But categorically, pay awards will be from existing departmental budgets. That has not changed.” Asked if that restriction came with potential cost for tackling the NHS backlog, the source said it was important that broader efficiencies were part of the final package.

The health secretary, Steve Barclay, is understood to be prepared to discuss backdating next year’s pay settlement, which would be a way of meeting the red line for all 12 health unions that pay for this year must be on the table – without reopening the full settlement.

A DHSC source rejected the GMB union’s claim that Barclay is trying to “divide and rule” the health unions by holding “intensive” pay talks with only the RCN. The source stressed that the RCN had shown “huge amount of goodwill” in backchannels and conversations with officials, and that calling off planned action was crucial to entering the intensive talks.

Barclay and RCN officials on Wednesday began discussing a number of options for improving nurses’ pay both this year and in 2023-24. They are thought to include both consolidated and also non-consolidated pay rises, a strategy which the Labour government in Wales is using as part of its efforts to reach a settlement with NHS unions there.

As well as pay, the talks will examine ways to lift administrative burdens on nurses and ways to reduce agency costs, as well as non-pay issues raised by unions including flexible working. Talks are expected to be ongoing over the coming days.

No 10 has made it a red line that the intensive phase of talks can only begin when strike action is called off.

“Strike action is very disruptive and there needs to be a lot of focus from all departments on contingency planning if they’re going ahead, which means it makes it more difficult to have these sort of detailed negotiations. It means being in a good constructive place,” one official said.

However, the National Education Union has said it will not pause planned industrial action next week until it has a clear indication of what is on offer from the government. Downing Street said the offer of talks would only stand once that had been called off.

“We’re obviously disappointed given I think the NEU and many other unions have wanted to talk about pay and have wanted to have these discussions for some time,” Rishi Sunak’s official spokesperson said. “The discussions and the talks are on the basis that they do stop strike action – there will be no talks, obviously, if they do not take that step.”

Leaders of teaching unions including the NEU say the education secretary, Gillian Keegan, has failed to offer any movement on pay, with several characterising the talks to date as “polite discussions”, and one describing them as “meandering”.

Paul Whiteman, the general secretary of the National Association of Head Teachers, said Keegan was making matters worse by insisting that strikes first be ruled out, adding: “After a series of meaningless encounters, the secretary of state holds out a public olive branch with thorns attached that make it impossible to grab.”

The NEU’s leaders said the union’s executive could call off next week’s regional strikes in England if the government makes a “serious proposal” by Saturday. “As things stand, however, no such offer has been made and the strikes remain in place,” the union said.

Sunak himself is understood to be taking a keen interest in the detail of the reforms that are possible, particularly in the NHS, which can free up frontline health workers from bureaucratic burdens.

“He is getting into the detail, he wants to fix those problems,” one senior official said. “Over the spring we want to see these issues being worked through and fixed. I think there is a realisation that we must demonstrate he is a prime minister fixing problems and improving long-term issues. Then we get breathing space to talk about long-term ambitions.”


Jessica Elgot, Denis Campbell, Heather Stewart, Pippa Crerar and Richard Adams

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Rishi Sunak preparing for fresh concessions to end public sector strikes
Negotiations with teachers begin and junior doctors also agree to formal talks following action this week

Heather Stewart, Kiran Stacey, Richard Adams and Rachel Hall

17, Mar, 2023 @8:31 PM

Article image
Nurses to strike in England, Wales and Northern Ireland after talks fail
Royal College of Nursing leader criticises ‘belligerence’ in meeting with Steve Barclay at which ministers refused to discuss pay

Kiran Stacey, Aubrey Allegretti, Jessica Elgot and Dan Sabbagh

12, Dec, 2022 @11:06 PM

Article image
Rishi Sunak appears ready to try to tough out further wave of NHS strikes
High-risk tactic increases likelihood of combined stoppages by nurses and junior doctors in England

Peter Walker Political correspondent

16, Apr, 2023 @5:13 PM

Article image
Sunak tries to remain above fray as public sector strikes continue
PM likely to find it increasingly difficult to stay out of debate as industrial action escalates

Heather Stewart

31, Jan, 2023 @3:00 PM

Article image
Junior doctors blame health secretary for triggering strikes across England
Steve Barclay accused of ‘wasting months’ by failing to meet unions and being dismissive of their demands for improved pay

Denis Campbell Health policy editor

14, Mar, 2023 @6:00 AM

Article image
Nurses to cut short strike as court rules second day of action unlawful
Ruling prompts RCN leader Pat Cullen to condemn government for ‘taking its own nurses to court’

Daniel Boffey Chief reporter

27, Apr, 2023 @4:22 PM

Article image
Ex-Tory cabinet minister calls on Rishi Sunak to help resolve NHS pay disputes
Politician says PM ‘so focused on hiding in plain sight’ and echoes growing calls for PM to step in to avert strike

Kevin Rawlinson and Aletha Adu

17, Feb, 2023 @12:14 PM

Article image
Nurses in England are on weaker ground with new strikes – and ministers know it
Steve Barclay and Rishi Sunak are gambling that nurses’ appetite for a fight is waning – and ballot results back them up

Denis Campbell Health policy editor

17, Apr, 2023 @6:48 PM

Article image
Up to 32,000 Unison NHS staff in England to strike on 8 March
Union hits out after it was excluded from talks between health secretary and Royal College of Nursing

Heather Stewart

22, Feb, 2023 @3:52 PM

Article image
NHS strikes: Steve Barclay expected to announce formal pay offer
Offer to unions involved in strikes in England expected to include one-off payment of up to 6% for this year

Heather Stewart and Jessica Elgot

16, Mar, 2023 @11:47 AM