Want levelling up? Stop running everything from London | Letters

Nicholas Falk recommends the German model of devolving financial powers to cities and regions. Plus letters from Sushila Dhall and Kim Loader

The pleas for the north to match German levels of investment miss some crucial factors (What would a genuine plan for levelling up the north of England look like? Ask a German, 25 January). In Good Cities, Better Lives, published in 2013, Prof Sir Peter Hall and I drew on case studies of the resurgence of Hamburg, Berlin, Leipzig, Dortmund, Kassel and Freiburg to explain how German cities had powered ahead. There were eight factors: municipal leadership, highly connected cities, a knowledge-based economy, engineering excellence, regional finance, urban pride, a climate of innovation and intelligent spatial planning.

On a second visit I was impressed by how the devolution of power, thanks to the principle of subsidiarity, enabled key local actors in business, universities and local authorities to collaborate on a spatial plan. Leipzig lost 90% of its manufacturing jobs after reunification. Yet it not only attracted BMW’s giant car plant and engineering centre but also converted the largest spinning mill in the world into hundreds of art studios and galleries. Given our current crises, government must surely devolve financial powers to our cities and regions and stop trying to run everything from London?
Dr Nicholas Falk
Executive director, the Urbed Trust

• The promotion of bus use in the government’s levelling up agenda (One in 10 bus services axed despite Johnson’s public transport pledge, 25 January) runs contrary to what we see on the ground here in Oxford. Here, funding has been made available for general traffic restraints, with an emphasis on walking, cycling and bus use, in response to the declaration of climate emergency, at the same time as buses have become fewer and less accessible (with ticketing regimes that can be expensive and exclusive).

If at the same time as we close small residential roads to through traffic, put in place wide new cycle lanes, free up pavements for walkers and wheelchair users, and propose new traffic filters, buses are also cut or undermined by the national bus companies, this feeds a sense of grievance on the part of car drivers. They see the privilege of driving undermined and no viable alternative. Not only does this waste public money, it undermines the strategy that is needed, and sets community groups against one another.
Sushila Dhall
Chair, Oxford Pedestrians Association

• Considerable pressures are being placed on local authority budgets, staff and systems as a result of bidding for funds, as councils try to increase their resources and improve services (Councils forced to freeze levelling up projects as soaring costs exceed grants, 24 January). But authorities do not always know the full costs of entering a bidding process and a lack of contingency planning for a range of outcomes can cause problems.

This is not evidence from the recent bidding for levelling up moneys but the results of my research published in 2002 examining the impact on local authorities of competing for funds. Not only are these problems still occurring, but they do so against a backdrop of local government finances ravaged by austerity. It is time for a reformed funding process so that local government can focus on delivering services rather than jumping through whatever government funding hoops are currently in vogue.
Kim Loader
Goathland, North Yorkshire

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Levelling-up grants don’t make up for cuts to regional funding | Letters
Letters: Jim Bamford says mainstream funding needs to be rebalanced; plus letters from John Marriott, Joanna Christina and Les Bright

23, Jan, 2023 @4:16 PM

Article image
What would a genuine plan for levelling up the north of England look like? Ask a German | Andy Burnham
They have laws requiring equality between the states and a funding regime to make it happen. Imagine that kind of Britain, says Manchester mayor Andy Burnham

Andy Burnham

25, Jan, 2023 @6:00 AM

Article image
Rebalancing power away from Westminster is vital | Letters
Letters: Readers respond to an article by John Harris on why the highly centralised model of governance is failing the country


27, Oct, 2020 @5:43 PM

Article image
Renaissance Florence is a ludicrous model for levelling up | Letters
Letters: Lauro Martines gives us a history lesson on the reality of life in Renaissance Florence. Plus letters from Michael Sanders, Sylvia Dunkley and Yvonne Williams


07, Feb, 2022 @5:20 PM

Article image
Rural bus services cut or nonexistent | Letter
Letter: Outside of towns and cities, people can be stranded by poor public transport, writes Judith Laity


14, Dec, 2020 @6:16 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on levelling up: a serious project meets a deeply unserious PM | Editorial
Editorial: Boris Johnson claims he is spreading wealth beyond London. MPs say he is gambling with taxpayers’ money


08, Jun, 2022 @5:59 PM

Article image
Heroes and villains in urban development | Letters
Letters: Franklin Medhurst’s plan to preserve and rebuild Stockton’s Georgian town centre was derailed by the murky web of corruption around John Poulson, writes Hilary Cashman – while John Griffiths says the Poulson scandal was not confined to northern England


12, Feb, 2021 @5:36 PM

Article image
Can Labour think big and make levelling up work?
Lisa Nandy hopes Labour will seize the chance for a rebalancing that can change the whole of the UK

Julian Coman

24, Jul, 2022 @5:00 AM

Article image
Railways U-turn highlights Westminster’s contempt for the north | Letters
Letters: Tim Treuherz contrasts the neglect of northern infrastructure with the massive investment in southern cities such as Oxford, while Jeffrey Henderson calls for devolution and more regional autonomy. Plus letters from Glyn Turton and Lyn Summers


23, Nov, 2021 @4:59 PM

Article image
The Guardian view on the levelling up white paper: anaemic and inadequate to the task | Editorial
Editorial: Resources as well as pious intentions are needed to drive an economic renaissance in the north and Midlands


02, Feb, 2022 @7:14 PM