NHS whistleblower wins dismissal case against England’s health regulator

Shyam Kumar was unfairly sacked by CQC after raising patient safety concerns, Manchester tribunal finds

A hospital inspector who was sacked by the health regulator after raising concerns about patient safety, inadequate inspections and bullying, has won an employment tribunal against his dismissal.

Manchester employment tribunal found that the orthopaedic surgeon Shyam Kumar was unfairly sacked as a part-time special adviser by the Care Quality Commission.

It found that the CQC failed to accept his whistleblowing was valid and tried to discredit him.

Kumar, who also worked at University Hospitals of Morecambe Bay NHS foundation trust, raised concerns about clinical negligence, manipulated waiting lists and significant patient harm at the trust. He warned the CQC that the trust wanted to bury concerns “under the carpet”.

He later complained about the inadequacy of CQC inspections into the trust and said the regulator was unwilling to examine high infection rates and instances of bullying and harassment of doctors.

Kumar was so frustrated that his concerns were being ignored that he threatened to stop taking part in inspections, the tribunal heard.

He was dismissed by the CQC in 2019 when senior figures at the regulator accused him of using his position to “intimidate colleagues”, according to emails disclosed to the tribunal.

The regulator also sought to discredit him by asking his trust for details of any disciplinary action against him.

The tribunal noted that Kumar had not been subject to any such action. It said: “There were suggestions of misconduct by the claimant … where no evidence of this existed.”

BBC News reported him saying: “The whole energy of a few individuals in the CQC was spent on gunning me down rather than focusing on improvement to patient safety and exerting the regulatory duties.”

During one of the hearings he said: “I was perceived as a troublemaker within the CQC, or as a thorn in their side.”

The tribunal concluded that Kumar was raising legitimate concerns about patient safety and that these led to his sacking. It said: “It is very clear that the emails and concerns raised by the claimant in the form of protected disclosures had a material influence on the decision to disengage him.”

Kumar was awarded £23,000 for injury to his feelings.

The surgeon said he was relieved about the verdict, adding: “From a personal point of view, I feel vindicated.”

The CQC said: “We accept the tribunal findings and have learned from this case. We have already improved many of our processes and will continue to review these based on the findings to ensure we make any further necessary changes.”


Matthew Weaver

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Medically fit patients waiting months to be discharged from England’s hospitals
Charities say social care crisis is ‘crippling patient flow’ in hospitals and has created a ‘miserable situation’

Andrew Gregory Health editor

31, Aug, 2022 @6:13 PM

Article image
Children in mental health crisis spent more than 900,000 hours in A&E in England
Exclusive: Children as young as three in emergency departments for mental health problems, data obtained by Labour reveals

Denis Campbell Health policy editor

09, Feb, 2023 @7:55 PM

Article image
Flu season in England is worst for a decade, says health secretary
Steve Barclay acknowledges NHS is under ‘severe pressure’ and expresses regret over instances of poor care

Aubrey Allegretti, Robert Booth and Denis Campbell

09, Jan, 2023 @5:50 PM

Article image
‘There’s only so much I can take’: England’s doctors on the picket line
Low rates of pay and ‘dangerous’ staffing levels lead to first joint strike for junior doctors and consultants

Hannah Moore

20, Sep, 2023 @11:58 AM

Article image
Manchester attack surgeon: 'The impact for patients is likely to be lifelong'
Adam Reid describes treating the injuries of the Manchester bombing victims, using techniques developed on the battlefield

As told to Helen Pidd North of England editor

26, May, 2017 @4:35 PM

Article image
Hospital apologises for voicemail privacy breach in Manchester
Sensitive patient information inadvertently heard by man calling to change appointment

Amy Walker

04, Jan, 2019 @4:37 PM

Article image
Nightingale hospitals in northern England on standby as Covid cases rise
Hospitals in Manchester, Sunderland and Harrogate told to prepare, says Stephen Powis

Sarah Boseley Health editor

12, Oct, 2020 @12:01 PM

Article image
NHS to deploy street mental health teams to help England’s rough sleepers
Exclusive: £3.2m plan aims to curb rise in people sleeping rough as councils cut homelessness budgets

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

11, Jun, 2023 @7:30 AM

Article image
Dangerous NHS England hospital roofs ‘will not be fixed until 2035’
FoI request reveals long wait to repair roofs at risk of collapse, including those affecting Truss and Coffey constituents

Denis Campbell Health policy editor

28, Sep, 2022 @6:18 PM

Article image
NHS cannot afford to finance pay rises from existing budgets, hospitals say
Social care, prevention and public health services could be cut if government insists on funding 6% pay rise from health budget

Anna Bawden and Aubrey Allegretti

14, Jul, 2023 @4:32 PM