Public sector pay rises cannot match inflation, says transport secretary

Mark Harper raises likelihood of winter strikes as he says keeping pace with living costs is unaffordable

Inflation-matching pay rises for struggling public sector workers are “unaffordable”, the transport secretary has said, raising the likelihood of winter strikes going ahead across the rail network, schools and the NHS.

Mark Harper said there was not a “bottomless pit” of money to meet the demands of workers planning to take industrial action in the coming weeks, even though benefits and pensions are going up in line with inflation.

Britain is facing a wave of strikes not seen for a generation, with nurses due to stage their first ever UK-wide action next month, as they join planned strikes by train drivers, postal workers, civil servants and potentially teachers in disputes over pay and conditions.

The transport secretary has adopted a more constructive approach to the rail unions after months of stalemate, in a return to the “beer and sandwiches” charm offensive of the 1970s, meeting the RMT chief, Mick Lynch, for talks this week and the Aslef general secretary, Mick Whelan, next week.

In a departure from the more aggressive policy of his predecessor Grant Shapps, he pledged to take a “grownup” approach to the dispute and help “facilitate agreement” between the rail firms and the unions to try to avert strikes over Christmas.

Yet Harper told Sky’s Sophy Ridge on Sunday programme: “Inflation-matching or inflation-busting pay rises are unaffordable. We want to try and give all the workers in the public sector who work very hard decent pay rises, but they can’t be inflation-busting pay rises.

“There simply isn’t the money to pay for those given the context, we haven’t seen those in the private sector either, the private sector pay rises have generally been settled below the level of inflation, which I accept is difficult for people.”

He insisted there could be no substantial pay rise for rail workers without reforms such as seven-day contracts, lifting a ban on overtime, allowing ticket office staff to work on platforms and using technology to spot and repair faults on the tracks.

“The train operating companies and Network Rail will have the ability to reach a deal, but we have to be able to have that reform package negotiated, because it’s only that, that throws up the savings. I do not have a bottomless pit of taxpayers’ money to throw at this problem,” he added.

The RMT has announced eight days of strikes in December and January, and Aslef may announce more after a meeting on 7 December. But unless a deal is done within the next week, the rail companies could struggle to avoid days of disruption over Christmas as it takes time to get timetables and services back on track.

The former Tory party chair Jake Berry said he had “real hope” for a settlement as he criticised Harper’s predecessor for making a “big mistake” by taking a “not me, guv” approach to talks.

Frances O’Grady, the general secretary of the TUC, welcomed reassurances from the transport secretary that he would “encourage and help” the two sides in the rail industry dispute reach a settlement, after stalemate under his predecessor, saying the government had the capacity to “pull the strings”.

She added that rail workers wanted their “fair share” of the £500m profit earned by the industry. “This is an industry that’s made £500m of profit and staff, quite rightly, who have worked through Covid, want their fair share.”

Labour’s Lisa Nandy said the government should be “moving heaven and earth” to avert strikes and criticised Harper’s remarks over pay rises, telling Sky News: “They’re unaffordable because of 12 years of Tory government and 44 days in which Liz Truss and Kwasi Kwarteng crashed the economy.

“I think there ought to be a level of humility about that within government. What he should be doing is moving heaven and earth to try and avert strikes coming up this winter. It’s been a really tough year for a lot of people and nobody wants to see strikes, least of all the people who are having to resort to strike action.”


Pippa Crerar Political editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Ministers could offer one-off payments as way to end public sector strikes
Strikes must be called off for talks to start, says No 10, as ministers given more freedom to talk to unions

Jessica Elgot, Denis Campbell, Heather Stewart, Pippa Crerar and Richard Adams

22, Feb, 2023 @7:22 PM

Article image
Public sector strikes row escalates as unions plan coordinated ‘day of action’
Unions react furiously to proposed legislation for Wales, England and Scotland they say will allow ministers to ban strikes

Peter Walker and Denis Campbell

10, Jan, 2023 @6:53 PM

Article image
Ambulance strike: NHS leaders urge public to avoid risky activity
Bodies representing NHS care in England also call for Rishi Sunak intervention but PM refuses to budge on pay

Denis Campbell, Steven Morris and Dan Sabbagh

21, Dec, 2022 @12:05 AM

Article image
Public sector strikes could hinder police work, says Met chief
Mark Rowley says industrial action will exacerbate health-related calls and distract from crime workload

Tom Ambrose

12, Nov, 2022 @1:21 PM

Article image
Sunak tries to remain above fray as public sector strikes continue
PM likely to find it increasingly difficult to stay out of debate as industrial action escalates

Heather Stewart

31, Jan, 2023 @3:00 PM

Article image
UK strike calendar – service stoppages planned for March and April
All the dates for strikes and stoppages across health, transport and education networks

Joe Middleton, Mabel Banfield-Nwachi, Anna Leach, Garry Blight, Safi Bugel and Casper Hughes

23, Mar, 2023 @4:08 PM

Article image
Rishi Sunak may consider one-off payment to end nurses’ strikes
PM for first time signals willingness to help with cost of living as ministers prepare for talks with health unions

Pippa Crerar Political editor

08, Jan, 2023 @7:28 PM

Article image
Public sector strikes 'a damp squib', says Cameron - video

The prime minister told parliament that the government's planned public sector pension reforms are essential and that strike action has been 'something of a damp squib'. David Cameron said on pensions it was 'hard to imagine a better deal than this' and reminded those taking industrial action that negotiations are still ongoing

30, Nov, 2011 @3:42 PM

Article image
Junior doctors blame health secretary for triggering strikes across England
Steve Barclay accused of ‘wasting months’ by failing to meet unions and being dismissive of their demands for improved pay

Denis Campbell Health policy editor

14, Mar, 2023 @6:00 AM

Article image
Up to half a million to strike across UK as talks go ‘backwards’
Action by teachers, civil servants, Border Force staff and train drivers to go ahead, with ministers accused of ‘stonewalling’

Jessica Elgot, Sally Weale and Gwyn Topham

31, Jan, 2023 @10:02 PM