Care for UK’s most vulnerable faces ‘collapse’ as providers count cost

Increasing numbers of providers, such as Leonard Cheshire, are ‘handing back’ contracts not viable at current funding levels

For several years now, as austerity sucked billions out of social care, the highly specialised UK social care system for adults with complex physical disability, learning disability and autism has been quietly held together by the benevolence of charities.

Charities and not-for-profit firms have poured millions of pounds of reserves into propping up the supposedly taxpayer-funded services they provide under contract to councils and the NHS. That subsidy seemed sustainable when inflation was low and subbing underfunded public services did not put the charity’s own survival at risk.

This year, as the cost of living crisis exploded, wages and energy prices soared and the social care staffing crisis worsened, many of those charities – at risk themselves of becoming unviable – have realised they can no longer afford to run at a loss. The system, as Mencap argues, is “broken” and it is not clear when or how it will be fixed.

Leonard Cheshire is evicting some of its residents, playing what one observer called “a game of chicken” with council funders over who pays for rising costs. Increasing numbers of providers are “handing back” contracts to deliver care packages not viable at current funding levels. A staffing crisis so acute – a record 165,000 vacancies – that some draw on their reserves to fund pay rises to attract or keep staff.

It would be wrong, says one social care insider, to see this as a case of “bad provider syndrome”; rather it is a lesson in the consequences of state under-investment. “If you do not fund the system properly it collapses, and this is what we are seeing now,” they said.

One provider said it was difficult to hire staff because council contracts effectively capped the amount they could pay in wages at a market rate way below that currently being offered by rivals like Aldi and Tesco. Another said she was ashamed she could not pay more because some of her care staff had to use food banks.

This “market dysfunctionality” has become so ingrained over the years, according to a recent provider-commissioned report, that it “has until now been largely accepted that some services will aways operate at a loss because they are inadequately funded”.

Private providers would baulk at such unpromising financial pickings, yet charities in the sector say they stay in the market to protect the people they serve: highly vulnerable individuals who thrive on stable relationships with skilled, trusted, experienced carers, who know the people they care for inside out.

Cutting back on care funding, along with the bare minimum service that results once charities and their subsidies disappear, disrupts those relationships and offers a dismal prospectus for service users. “It would be a case of: washed, fed, dressed, stick people in front of the TV. Is that the quality of life anyone would want?,” said Mencap’s Jackie O’Sullivan.

Last week’s autumn settlement promised an extra £3bn a year for local authorities in England over the next two years, big chunks of it aimed at easing the discharge from NHS beds of older patients. But it is unlikely to change the weather for this under-reported, underfunded sector of social care and the people it cares for.


Patrick Butler Social policy editor

The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
Overseas hiring spree planned for care homes in England amid winter fears
Government plans to boost staff numbers with more foreign workers, with NHS managers sent abroad to recruit

Jamie Grierson

19, Aug, 2022 @7:56 AM

Article image
Shortfall of £2.3bn a year in England’s care homes ‘putting people at risk’
Exclusive: Funding hole directly affects elderly people whose bills are entirely or partly paid for by councils

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

28, Feb, 2023 @4:00 PM

Article image
Disabled care home residents evicted in charity’s dispute with councils
Exclusive: Leonard Cheshire says it can no longer afford to subsidise care services inadequately funded by councils

Patrick Butler Social policy editor

25, Nov, 2022 @6:00 PM

Article image
Older people dying for want of social care at rate of three an hour
Age UK estimates that between last general election and next, 74,000 of cohort in England have died or will die waiting for care

Amelia Hill

21, Nov, 2019 @12:01 AM

Article image
Thousands of vulnerable people held unlawfully in care homes – report
Law Commission study, laid before parliament, reveals growing strain on already overburdened care system

Owen Bowcott Legal affairs correspondent

13, Mar, 2017 @11:00 AM

Article image
Vulnerable adults at risk as councils face £1bn social care shortfall
Outlook for care provision in England is bleak with cuts eating into resources despite rising need for support, says report

Patrick Butler Social policy editor

12, Jul, 2016 @11:01 PM

Article image
Health secretary sets up £500m fund to discharge medically fit NHS patients
Thérèse Coffey announces measure aimed at freeing up beds in hospitals in England before winter pressures

Denis Campbell Health policy editor

22, Sep, 2022 @1:54 PM

Article image
‘A horrible winter lies ahead’: next PM will inherit an NHS on its knees
Experts say Tory leadership rivals appear not to have grasped the scale of the crisis facing the service

Andrew Gregory Health editor

29, Aug, 2022 @11:00 AM

Article image
Benefits claimants suffering under end-of-life DWP rule
Terminally ill, disabled and mentally ill people spending final weeks struggling to get social security help

Patrick Butler Social policy editor

09, Jun, 2021 @5:01 AM

Article image
Care providers ask for doubled fees to care for people discharged from hospitals
Care England says current funding is ‘inadequate’ if homes are to pay staff more and manage rehabilitation

Robert Booth Social affairs correspondent

09, Jan, 2023 @12:00 AM