Understanding the aim of ‘poo in the post’ tests for bowel cancer | Letters

Damian Glancy addresses the lack of public awareness of what the test is actually meant to achieve, and its implications

I read the recent letters regarding the bowel cancer screening “poo in the post” test (18 May) with an enduring sense of frustration regarding the lack of public awareness of what this test is actually meant to achieve and its implications for them.

Bowel cancer commonly gives rise to no symptoms, hence the need for a national screening programme. However, due to limited resources (colonoscopy capacity), this is set up to detect a group of asymptomatic people who would otherwise have gone undiagnosed, with the aim of benefiting us at a population level overall while acknowledging that some people with a negative test may have been falsely reassured that they do not have bowel cancer.

The new “poo test” called qFIT is highly sensitive, but the “q” stands for quantitative. That means that the threshold value of a positive test can be altered depending on the circumstances.

We have seen a lot in the media about pre-test probabilities and the meaning of a result in relation to Covid and lateral flow tests. For bowel cancer screening in England, given the assumption that the screening population has no symptoms, the threshold of a positive test is set at 120. But if you present to your GP with potential symptoms, you will be offered a test where it is considered positive if greater than 10 and then referred on for further investigations. For those with a result less than 10, your chance of having bowel cancer at an individual level is then less than 1%.
Damian Glancy
Consultant colorectal surgeon

Have an opinion on anything you’ve read in the Guardian today? Please email us your letter and it will be considered for publication.


The GuardianTramp

Related Content

Article image
‘Poo in the post’ test could save your life | Letters
Letter: Julie Platt draws readers’ attention to the NHS’s screening programme that picks up bowel cancer early even when there are no symptoms


16, May, 2022 @4:48 PM

Article image
The NHS bowel cancer test might save your life, but don’t rely solely on it | Letters
Letters: Michelle Gibson says the ‘poo in the post’ home test kit missed her symptoms, while Christine Ronaldson says it allowed her illness to be spotted early


18, May, 2022 @5:05 PM

Article image
NHS patients waiting months for vital bowel cancer tests, figures show
Health service has set six-week target for two tests to detect UK’s fourth most deadly cancer, but March’s figures show some people are waiting double that

Denis Campbell Health policy editor

11, May, 2017 @7:18 PM

Cancer plan falters on bowel tests

The government's plans to introduce screening for bowel cancer across the UK could founder on the inadequate and over-stretched existing services for diagnosing gut disorders, according to a study.

Sarah Boseley

13, Jan, 2004 @11:06 AM

Article image
War metaphors in cancer conversations | Letters
Letters: Guardian columnist Simon Jenkins argues that people with cancer are fed up of the language of war, but not everyone agrees


01, Feb, 2019 @4:43 PM

Article image
Breast cancer and global big pharma | Letter
Letter: If any more of the NHS is sold off US style, our medical world will lose the heart that contributes to keeping so many of us alive, says Melanie McFadyean


29, Sep, 2019 @4:37 PM

Article image
Screening programme has prevented 20,000 cases of bowel cancer in England
Tests have been available to people aged over 60 since 2006, and will be offered to those aged 50 and above from 2025

Anna Bawden Social affairs correspondent

08, Aug, 2023 @11:01 PM

Article image
Home smear tests will be a game-changer | Letter
Letter: Judith Walker thinks home testing is an excellent idea, but urges people not to blame or shame women who currently don’t take part


26, Feb, 2021 @5:11 PM

Article image
Womb cancer and obesity link must not be ignored | Letter
Letter: The myth that people can be obese and healthy is pervasive, writes Dr Jonathan Riley


19, Sep, 2022 @4:13 PM

Article image
Deborah James legacy: huge rise in online checks for bowel cancer signs
NHS chief says James’s last message to public to ‘check your poo’ is life-saving

Caroline Davies

01, Jul, 2022 @11:01 PM